Is it Haram to divide Pakistan?

[graveyardofempires]

You didn't say anything about my statement(s) on the topic. You just came back and told me something about me .. Kindly comment on my comments not on my personality.

your statement is flawd and so are all of your statements so i will not,no more reply to any of them.
i know your position is against our unity and interest and pro devide and conquer in this case devide and rule policy of the british.

end of story

[BLS_1919v2.0]

^^ graveyard take it easy...let us hear him out. I don't support the division of Afghanistan.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Well that is what I keep asking you all. Why use Pashtunistan as a crutch? Why don't you advocate it from the beginning? See I disagree with toranama on this and believe in uniting Afghanistan and Pashtunkhwa, but we both agree on unifying Pashtuns. However you shehbaz wrora stay on pro-Pakistan and then you sometimes switch to Pashtunistan.....why don't you take that stand from the beginning?

The bold part is something I need to answer.

By Pro-Pakistan you mean why I support Pakistan at times? Right?
It's because Pakistan couldn't be wrong all the time. I gladly welcome all the attacks on Pakistan's wrong policies but if someone will continue attacking Pakistan blindly and just saying this and that I have to dis-agree with him and support Pakistan

Pakistan is my country, My home, My identity throughout the world. I've to support it when it's right and I've to agree that many times it's going wrong.

[graveyardofempires]

The bold part is something I need to answer.

By Pro-Pakistan you mean why I support Pakistan at times? Right?
It's because Pakistan couldn't be wrong all the time. I gladly welcome all the attacks on Pakistan's wrong policies but if someone will continue attacking Pakistan blindly and just saying this and that I have to dis-agree with him and support Pakistan

Pakistan is my country, My home, My identity throughout the world. I've to support it when it's right and I've to agree that many times it's going wrong.

than you have no identity,maybe than jinah is your father.

[Shehbaz Khan]

devide afghanistan?hahahahahhahahaha
you moron,Afghanistan is a country while pakistan is created by british occupying Afghan land.
dont you ever dare to talk non sense.
we will not give up an inch of our land from Amu river till Atok.
there will never be a separate homeland just for pashtuns,its is Afghanistan,take it or leave it.

pakistanis have the same tactics as israel but the difference is israeli claim has more credibility.

Why is it Haram to divide Afghanistan?

Stop using foul language. Afghanistan is a country which sold a part of it's body to the British? What you think about such a country?
You don't accept my proposal, I don't agree with yours. There will be Afghanistan than there will be Pakistan simple Don't get emotional.

[Shehbaz Khan]

your statement is flawd and so are all of your statements so i will not,no more reply to any of them.
i know your position is against our unity and interest and pro devide and conquer in this case devide and rule policy of the british.

end of story

If you think what I highlighted than you just have to say that, nothing about me personally as it's our opinions about things that we discuss here not our personalities.

[MazloomYarMasud]

I am a Maseed from Tawda Cheena in South Waziristan. I was born in DI Khan Pakhtunkhwa. I have been to Waziristan. Graveyardempire dude, you can not handle the truth. You are just a Emotional kid. So stick to Topic or just deal with the fact that your hero Nek Mohammad Wazir referred to his Pashtuns as atomic bomb of Pakistan Army. lol!

[BLS_1919v2.0]

The bold part is something I need to answer.

By Pro-Pakistan you mean why I support Pakistan at times? Right?
It's because Pakistan couldn't be wrong all the time. I gladly welcome all the attacks on Pakistan's wrong policies but if someone will continue attacking Pakistan blindly and just saying this and that I have to dis-agree with him and support Pakistan

Pakistan is my country, My home, My identity throughout the world. I've to support it when it's right and I've to agree that many times it's going wrong.

Ogoraa dagha khabaraa da graana. One moment you say Pashtunistan next moment Pakistan. I know Pakistan isn't always wrong, but it is the issue of politics and interests. Isn't it fair to be sincere with oneself and nation and pick a straight forward course?

[MazloomYarMasud]

I personally could not give a damme about Pakistan or Afghanistan, but I do not like hypocrites.

Afghanistan with exception to Daud done nothing for the reclaiming of the land back, In Pakhtunkhwa there no party who wants to return to Afghanistan.

But the topic is, under what Islamic justification can you divide a Muslim Country such as Pakistan? I want solid facts presented please

[Shehbaz Khan]

Ogoraa dagha khabaraa da graana. One moment you say Pashtunistan next moment Pakistan. I know Pakistan isn't always wrong, but it is the issue of politics and interests. Isn't it fair to be sincere with oneself and nation and pick a straight forward course?

Malgarya, tarso che Pashtunistan yao soch day nu ta sa way che tar haghi poori za sa wokam pakistan pasi kanzali wokam? Na.. Till that time I've to serve and fight for the interest of my people within and under the laws of Pakistan

[graveyardofempires]

Why is it Haram to divide Afghanistan?

Stop using foul language. Afghanistan is a country which sold a part of it's body to the British? What you think about such a country?
You don't accept my proposal, I don't agree with yours. There will be Afghanistan than there will be Pakistan simple Don't get emotional.

there will be Afghanistan because there have been Afghanistan
pakistan is like israel an occupying force with zionist agenda.
pakistan was created by a kafir to serve them.
Afghanistan never sold any part,its your paki mentality which is corrupt.
pakistanis along with british fought against muslims in pukhtunkhwa and Afghanistan and one of them was your babayee qaum jinah.

even if our King signed an agreement,it was with british and it said that over 100 years the agreement will be non binding.

i dont care what someone like you have to say.im here to defend my peoples right and if you think you can deny them that and steal our land than the struggle will continue.

you are a shameless person with no ghairat or identity.

pakistan was created by a seculerist using religion to brainwash the masses just like kamal ataturk and theodor herzl.

[MazloomYarMasud]

Ogoraa dagha khabaraa da graana. One moment you say Pashtunistan next moment Pakistan. I know Pakistan isn't always wrong, but it is the issue of politics and interests. Isn't it fair to be sincere with oneself and nation and pick a straight forward course?

I can provide 1000s of solid quates whereby it states that dividing the Muslim Ummah is Haraam. In the case of Pakistan, which is a prodominately Muslim country has former land of Afghanistan, that land was not stolen or taken, it was given by Abdur Rahman, since that day, there have been many chances to reclaim it but with exception to Daud and we know what happened to him in the process, there has been no attempt to reclaim it.

[Dreamer]

Malgarya, tarso che Pashtunistan yao soch day nu ta sa way che tar haghi poori za sa wokam pakistan pasi kanzali wokam? Na.. Till that time I've to serve and fight for the interest of my people within and under the laws of Pakistan

lol.... lame

[graveyardofempires]

I personally could not give a damme about Pakistan or Afghanistan, but I do not like hypocrites.

Afghanistan with exception to Daud done nothing for the reclaiming of the land back, In Pakhtunkhwa there no party who wants to return to Afghanistan.

But the topic is, under what Islamic justification can you divide a Muslim Country such as Pakistan? I want solid facts presented please

under what islamic justification can you create a muslim land by deviding other muslims and all this done under supervision of the british raj.

you guys are up to your neck in it.

[MazloomYarMasud]

there will be Afghanistan because there have been Afghanistan
pakistan is like israel an occupying force with zionist agenda.
pakistan was created by a kafir to serve them.
Afghanistan never sold any part,its your paki mentality which is corrupt.
pakistanis along with british fought against muslims in pukhtunkhwa and Afghanistan and one of them was your babayee qaum jinah.

even if our King signed an agreement,it was with british and it said that over 100 years the agreement will be non binding.

i dont care what someone like you have to say.im here to defend my peoples right and if you think you can deny them that and steal our land than the struggle will continue.

you are a shameless person with no ghairat or identity.

pakistan was created by a seculerist using religion to brainwash the masses just like kamal ataturk and theodor herzl.

I do not understand why you hate Secularists for? Your Jihadi Shariat promoters love Pakistan and consider it the gate of Islam!

Taliban never objected to Pakistan! they even attended Public Military shows during the 90's.