what do you think about this person?

[ZarakDurrani606]

Just remember illegal CNIC doesn't make you Pakistani, be prepared to go back by end of 2017.

If ever we go..... its with our lands. Just keep that in mind, next time you feel the need to use the " kala ba zey" card, kid.

[toughpashtun]

You are in a minority . Go out in KP and ask about afghans from Pashtuns of KP and you will know how they feel . The biggest anti - Afghan these days are the Pashtuns from KP themselves . Its a no brainer why . If they love us so much what are they doing involve in Kidnappings and Extortion inside Peshawar ?

Exactly. I agree with you that nowadays among the Pakistani people it is the Pashtuns who have most hatred for Afghans.
But it was not always like this.
There obviously are Afghans who are responsible for criminal activities in Pakistan , but to paint the entire community with the same brush is not right.
The media also plays a role in causing divisions.

In this story which was posted by OP , the Afghan is showing a hostile attitude towards Pakistan while sitting in Pakistan , which doesn't help him at all.

[ZarakDurrani606]

Why anyone have to ask first to report criminals? Where is written that Pakistanis have to show big hearts? Millions of afghanis have illegal CNIC and are involved in anti-state activities. They most be reported and arrested.

No one asked you to do anything punjabi. These people you are referring to are OUR brothers and have every right to roam khyber. " involved in anti-state terror activities"..... so poor children who pick trash for a living are somehow anti-state actors? Is that what the grorious pakistan army is training to counter? Get yourself checked punjoo. tHe pakistani punjabi state, failing to divide Pashtuns in their narrative, proceeds to dehumanise them . I would'nt expect you to understand this anyways sharmedaliya. You punjoos are so warm towards your sikh brethren from india yet become autistic screechers whenever you hear "Afghan".

[toughpashtun]

If ever we go..... its with our lands. Just keep that in mind, next time you feel the need to use the " kala ba zey" card, kid.

Are you Afghan?Or from Charsadda?

[ZarakDurrani606]

Are you Afghan?Or from Charsadda?

Charsadwal wrora. It was in response to that guy's rants about "remove afghans"

[toughpashtun]

Charsadwal wrora. It was in response to that guy's rants about "remove afghans"

Okay. But you did not reply to my earlier post where I explained my point as a reply to your initial comment.

[ZarakDurrani606]

Okay. But you did not reply to my earlier post where I explained my point as a reply to your initial comment.

Fair enough. I apologize for miscostruing some of the points that you proposed. However, i stand by what i said earlier (not in your reply to your comment) but otherwise. I know that pakistan and to some extent, the afghan government use rhetorics, purpose being, to divide Pashtuns and thus make them easier to manipulate. People like logical disgust me since they have no better thing to do than fruitlessly endeavour to actively subvert and convolute facts.

[Peacelove]

The problem lies in afghan government and its narrative..They are just propagating hate among afghans..I means its very logical if some afghan is in Pakistan and in conversation start bashing Pakistan..The other guy will definitely think if Pakistan is so bad what he is doing here ?Or May be his hatred later on push him to help some criminals for terrorist activities as he does not care about pakistan and pakistani people.
This situation is very peculiar..
Further afghans are not just in KP they are across the country..No body allow such a privilege to them except paksitan
:Ali family lives in Afghanistan, according to him his mother died when he was only 8, his father re-married and his step-mother doesn't give a f*** about him. He lives here because economically Pakistan is feasible for him, in other words he doesn't give a f**** about Pakistan, and he hates his step-family.
Even after this he hates paksitan i don;t know why..This guy living in islambad/Pindi as mentioned in his replies...So nationalistic who are saying there land no its not there land.
Problem is the guy is committing crime by taking CNIC illegal..This will put him in further problem
Also the guy who posted this if he would be so sincere instead of doing this after argument he should have reported him earlier if he has to show his duty..
I think afghanistan like Iran..So paksitan should learn something from Iran on how to deal with Afghanistan..
Nationalist here on this forum and in general are in minority..Otherwise KP would have selected ANP or PMAP instead of PTI.. as We all know CM khattak views..

[ZarakDurrani606]

The problem lies in afghan government and its narrative..They are just propagating hate among afghans..I means its very logical if some afghan is in Pakistan and in conversation start bashing Pakistan..The other guy will definitely think if Pakistan is so bad what he is doing here ?Or May be his hatred later on push him to help some criminals for terrorist activities as he does not care about pakistan and pakistani people.
This situation is very peculiar..
Further afghans are not just in KP they are across the country..No body allow such a privilege to them except paksitan
:Ali family lives in Afghanistan, according to him his mother died when he was only 8, his father re-married and his step-mother doesn't give a f*** about him. He lives here because economically Pakistan is feasible for him, in other words he doesn't give a f**** about Pakistan, and he hates his step-family.
Even after this he hates paksitan i don;t know why..This guy living in islambad/Pindi as mentioned in his replies...So nationalistic who are saying there land no its not there land.
Problem is the guy is committing crime by taking CNIC illegal..This will put him in further problem
Also the guy who posted this if he would be so sincere instead of doing this after argument he should have reported him earlier if he has to show his duty..
I think afghanistan like Iran..So paksitan should learn something from Iran on how to deal with Afghanistan..
Nationalist here on this forum and in general are in minority..Otherwise KP would have selected ANP or PMAP instead of PTI.. as We all know CM khattak views..

What are you trying to imply? 'Nationalistic'..... so lands we have held for centuries are not ours and belong to some government that was only conceived some 70 odd years ago? No, you're deluded friend. And we all know how pakistan treats "its own" Pashtuns. They are kept in a perpetual state of terror, and naturally their hate is directed towards Afghans, but this hate is contrived through subversion. If you had brains enough to fill a teaspoon, you'd see this trend all around you. How its propogated via media. As for your implying that i'm nationalistic puts you in the same boat as all those crying normies in the west. Don't get butthurt when we cherish our identities. The rest of pakistan is disillusioned and tries to cling to cultures and ideologies that they have no connection with.

[Peacelove]

What are you trying to imply? 'Nationalistic'..... so lands we have held for centuries are not ours and belong to some government that was only conceived some 70 odd years ago? No, you're deluded friend. And we all know how pakistan treats "its own" Pashtuns. They are kept in a perpetual state of terror, and naturally their hate is directed towards Afghans, but this hate is contrived through subversion. If you had brains enough to fill a teaspoon, you'd see this trend all around you. How its propogated via media. As for your implying that i'm nationalistic puts you in the same boat as all those crying normies in the west. Don't get butthurt when we cherish our identities. The rest of pakistan is disillusioned and tries to cling to cultures and ideologies that they have no connection with.

Nothing on the relevant post did you reply friend..Is it paksitan that has terrorize Afghanistan from 1947 ? How come Pakistan has terrorize me when we are 1000 times better then our folks across the durand line..Where everybody is fighting each other ..Strange the second most people in every walk of life are terrorize..?Please see afghanistan and you will know what is terrorize thing ..When you can't go out side your home and earn a simple living for your loved one..You are telling me we are terrorize when in Karachi it is not sindhis who are second majority after mohajirs..It is pashtuns..You are deluded not i am..Or you can say most of the pashtuns and kp are deluded as we will keep selected PTI and any other party rather a Surkhiya like ANP or PMAP

[ZarakDurrani606]

Nothing on the relevant post did you reply friend..Is it paksitan that has terrorize Afghanistan from 1947 ? How come Pakistan has terrorize me when we are 1000 times better then our folks across the durand line..Where everybody is fighting each other ..Strange the second most people in every walk of life are terrorize..?Please see afghanistan and you will know what is terrorize thing ..When you can't go out side your home and earn a simple living for your loved one..You are telling me we are terrorize when in Karachi it is not sindhis who are second majority after mohajirs..It is pashtuns..You are deluded not i am..Or you can say most of the pashtuns and kp are deluded as we will keep selected PTI and any other party rather a Surkhiya like ANP or PMAP

No offense but your language skills are incorrigible. I'd rather not discuss anything regarding Pashtuns and Afghanistan with you. As you're non-pashtun i would'nt expect you to understand much. The veracity of your claims and salient points that you were trying to get across to me shows that you're no more than trying to banter.

[Kabulistan]

What if these are all Desis pretending to be Pashtnun and trying to stir Up animosity between Pashtuns and try to make them further away from One another ?

[ZarakDurrani606]

What if these are all Desis pretending to be Pashtnun and trying to stir Up animosity between Pashtuns and try to make them further away from One another ?

Could be........ i dunno, do you think so?

[Kabulistan]

Could be........ i dunno, do you think so?

IT would make sense if IT was....Pakistaniyat is strongly pushed by the government....

I Dont believe someone would Talk bad about people of his own ethnicity regardless of national borders...

[ZarakDurrani606]

IT would make sense if IT was....Pakistaniyat is strongly pushed by the government....

I Dont believe someone would Talk bad about people of his own ethnicity regardless of national borders...

Exactly. Persons that emulate such behaviour can only be termed traitors at best