Are balochis really descended from kurds and azeris?

[A.Alraeesi]

Are they really descended from kurds and azeris
From most balochis i saw they didnt look like kurds and azeris some of them looked indian and somalian with very dark skin
But i also saw a few that looked arab and a very few which had light eyes, hair, etc.
I also read that balochi and kurdish is so close?

[Ajwan]

y do u always ask?????????

[A.Alraeesi]

Shutup

[Ajwan]

i wont

[JattApache]

Because there are some brahui people living in balochistan( they are dravidian, that's why they have a dark skin ), they aren't baloch, but baloch people were obviously mixed with them.

And we can also say that the baloch's dark skin is due to the hot climate in south balochistan.
But normally, baloch people are related to the persians and kurds.

[A.Alraeesi]

Ok thanks

[Karachi]

balochis are mixed with south asians, though their culture/language may have come from the Kurdistan area

[A.Alraeesi]

balochis are mixed with south asians, though their culture/language may have come from the Kurdistan area

Ok thanks

[A.Alraeesi]

Alraeesi, you're loss!

What do you mean?

[Hakim Khan Urgonai]

balochis are mixed with south asians, though their culture/language may have come from the Kurdistan area

Some are also mixed with Arabs and Zanzibarians, especially in Makran, Iran and Oman.

[Wahe Guru]

Are they really descended from kurds and azeris
From most balochis i saw they didnt look like kurds and azeris some of them looked indian and somalian with very dark skin
But i also saw a few that looked arab and a very few which had light eyes, hair, etc.
I also read that balochi and kurdish is so close?

Could Kurds and Azeris be descended from Balochis??

Here I have a photo of some Kurds, though it is not to say they all look the same or as in this photo.

kurdish men husyan.jpg

Kurd child.
kurish child girl .jpg

[A.Alraeesi]

Some are also mixed with Arabs and Zanzibarians, especially in Makran, Iran and Oman.

Some of the balochi tribes are of arab descent. But there is also a baloch tribe called kurd

[A.Alraeesi]

Could Kurds and Azeris be descended from Balochis??

Here I have a photo of some Kurds, though it is not to say they all look the same or as in this photo.

[ATTACH]7628[/ATTACH]

Kurd child.
[ATTACH]7629[/ATTACH]

I guess not all kurds look the same :p

[Sakapane]

Are they really descended from kurds and azeris
From most balochis i saw they didnt look like kurds and azeris some of them looked indian and somalian with very dark skin
But i also saw a few that looked arab and a very few which had light eyes, hair, etc.
I also read that balochi and kurdish is so close?

Balochis are definitely from Kurdistan and probably originated from them. As far as I know there is a tribe among Balochis which also indicates this with their name (have forgotten which one this was). However Balochis have mixed with dravidians and other people of the area. Brahuis are more like Balochis which have mixed with Dravidians and just adopted their language. genetically they are very similar to Balochis. Makrani are also Balochis which have mixed with Africans.

[Sakapane]

Did you not say earlier today in another thread (Are Kurds Iranics - yes they are btw!) that Balochs are "probably" from Aleppo in Northeastern Syria (in fact it's NorthWESTERN Syria a place 1000 km away) despite Syria being inhabited by Semetic peoples for as long as cultures have existed in that region?

My fault I meant Northwestern Syria. Your misinterpreting and creating your own facts. Syria as a country with its modern borders was created by the French mandates. Aleppo was originally more connected to Anatolia. Mesopotamia and Eastern Anatolia was first settled by CAUCASIAN people like Hurrians (which belong to Kurdish ancestors and are the source for Ergativ in Kurdish language), as a second wave the Aryans and the Assyrians from Akkad and Babylon (located in South and Central Iraq) arrived. They were enemies while the Aryans established the Mitanni Kingdom, Assyrians conquered it, till the Medes which originated from Mitanni conquered it back. So where do you see evidences for your supposed "Semitic" origin of Aleppo?

Now they are suddenly "definetely" from Kurdistan (Aleppo has nothing to do with Kurdistan - the tiny Syrian Kudistan is in the NorthEASTERN region 1000 km away)

Aleppo borders the Kurdish regions in Anatolia and was originally part of it. Even the dance Syrian Arabs dance is called "Baloch" by themselves.

Indo-Iranians like Kurds etc. are not from the Middle East but probably Central Asia or Iran. Or Anatolia.

Nobody claims that they are from current Arab countries in the Middle East.

Its not clear till today from where they originated but like I said Kurds do also have other ancestors than Iranic tribes and Central Asia, Anatolia, Levant was culturally, genetically and historically more connected to each other as the Arabian peninsula. The presence of Iranic tribes predates that of Arabs for some thousand years. The only Semites which arrived almost at the same time were the Assyrians. Look where Aleppo is located. The whole area in Northsyria was populated by Kurds but with the current Assad regime many Arabs where settled in between Northeastern and Northwestern Syria to destroy the continuity.

And just by the way for your information, Semites are Afroasiatic Speakers and Afroasiatic Groups are believed to have originated somewhere between North Africa and the Levant (probably between Egypt and South Syria/Jordan.)