Is this forum even for pashtuns?

[graveyardofempires]

in this forum ive heard people talk in a manner which in noway can be pashtuns.ive never in my life heard so many twisted people and than claiming to be pashtuns.
when i do a post about pukhtunkhwa than some people jump trying to defend the paskistani establishment.and when i put an Afghan video people try to ridicule afghans and their religion and tag it as "bedouin culture" arab culture etc.we know those are codes use for Islam.

and than there are these Atheist pashtuns who are totally lost and can never be representatives of pashtuns and yet they try to impose their ideology upon us.

so what is this forum about?
and is this how pashtuns are because ive never in my life met such people with those idiotic ideas about pashtuns.

i think there are a some people on this forum who sound pashtun and som ethat have nothing in common with pashtuns.

so here are the question:

1:are you a true pashtun?
2:do you have ghairat?
3:are you a muslim?
4:do you hate pashtuns?
5:do you hate muslims?
6:do you have repsect for your ancesters?

just answer in YES/NO.

thank you

[Catya Sher]

Very a propos question.
Intelligent members here posit that a number here are Tajiks or others
who are masquerading as Pashtuns.
A few have been 'outed' - perhaps, who can say because it is all online.

It is difficult to say without people being able to speak to or see the suspicious members in question...

Why would other groups WANT to be here posing as Pashtuns, anyway, though, unless they are harboring some kind of agenda....

I think it's good these questions above were brought up.
They should be analysed to figure out WHY
PF has such a non-Pashtun tone to it.

Then those Indian members who were so pushy like drona. I hope he's not here anymore.

One had to fight through huge walls of their unpleasant challenges just to
try to find the way to have a pleasant discussion about useful topics.

Instead, all of those were derailed or impeded by the unfriendly interventions by various people.

One does wonder WHY they would be here, and regularly too. Don't they have IndianForums to be active in?!

[MazloomYarMasud]

Just because you have tasted a reality check does not mean you can make drama out of your distaste to others.

Firstly You are a Taliban supporter, You assumed Nek Mohammad Wazir was a Proud Pashtun, You did not know Nek was a Punjabi Talib supporter and a Alqueda operative, plus he was a Proud Pakistani Wazir.

Secondly,you assumed every Pashtun is like you, one side fronting a Nationalist opinion then on the other side screeming "Muslim Unity" but You want to divide Pakistan which is a 99 percent Muslim state.

I think we have another Unknownprince here.

You live in a fantasy of all Pashtuns being united and all fighting for Loy Afghanistan but that is not the case. You need to do some reading on the current events in your region and educate yourself on this bogus heros you claim to follow.

The ancestors of Pashtuns did not start when Islam was created, we were way way way Pashtun before Islam ever was created.

So which ancestors are you referring too?

Finally to end this, Do not even dare to compare todays Taliban with our ancestors, our ancestors never used children to blow themselves up in Markets like Daddullah the Arabised Terrorist Talib did.

Plus, we as the god-less do not specifically target Islam, We do not need to target Islam, Muslims within themselves do a much better job at it, Shias vs Sunni,Wahabi vs Sufi etc etc. Religion is Religion, Pashtuns need to get with time and let go of these fairy tales.

Kind Regards

[IamDZJ]

Do you need a tissue?

[MazloomYarMasud]

Very a propos question.
Intelligent members here posit that a number here are Tajiks or others
who are masquerading as Pashtuns.
A few have been 'outed' - perhaps, who can say because it is all online.

It is difficult to say without people being able to speak to or see the suspicious members in question...

Why would other groups WANT to be here posing as Pashtuns, anyway, though, unless they are harboring some kind of agenda....

I think it's good these questions above were brought up.
They should be analysed to figure out WHY
PF has such a non-Pashtun tone to it.

Then those Indian members who were so pushy like drona. I hope he's not here anymore.

One had to fight through huge walls of their unpleasant challenges just to
try to find the way to have a pleasant discussion about useful topics.

Instead, all of those were derailed or impeded by the unfriendly interventions by various people.

One does wonder WHY they would be here, and regularly too. Don't they have IndianForums to be active in?!

Again, the usual Pro Pakistani Jihadi Catya Sher.

Why do Indian members hit your nerve Mrs Catya? Or is it Hamid gul got you on his standby!

Like I said before, prove yourself to us as you claim to be a Journalist. Most of us here think your some FBI agent trying to brainwash us and then mislead us into your trap.

How can a woman or man from America in this day and age still support Harems. You are beginning to sound like "Jihad Jane"

[graveyardofempires]

Do you need a tissue?

tissue? for what?

[graveyardofempires]

Just because you have tasted a reality check does not mean you can make drama out of your distaste to others.

Firstly You are a Taliban supporter, You assumed Nek Mohammad Wazir was a Proud Pashtun, You did not know Nek was a Punjabi Talib supporter and a Alqueda operative, plus he was a Proud Pakistani Wazir.

Secondly,you assumed every Pashtun is like you, one side fronting a Nationalist opinion then on the other side screeming "Muslim Unity" but You want to divide Pakistan which is a 99 percent Muslim state.

I think we have another Unknownprince here.

You live in a fantasy of all Pashtuns being united and all fighting for Loy Afghanistan but that is not the case. You need to do some reading on the current events in your region and educate yourself on this bogus heros you claim to follow.

The ancestors of Pashtuns did not start when Islam was created, we were way way way Pashtun before Islam ever was created.

So which ancestors are you referring too?

Finally to end this, Do not even dare to compare todays Taliban with our ancestors, our ancestors never used children to blow themselves up in Markets like Daddullah the Arabised Terrorist Talib did.

Plus, we as the god-less do not specifically target Islam, We do not need to target Islam, Muslims within themselves do a much better job at it, Shias vs Sunni,Wahabi vs Sufi etc etc. Religion is Religion, Pashtuns need to get with time and let go of these fairy tales.

Kind Regards

according to you anyone who doesnt agree with you abou the war on our lands is taliban supporter.
you are weak mr,and thats how you will stay.
there are thousands of people in the west demonstrating against the war in Afghanistan and drone attacks and you think they are taliban supporters.
you think you are smart but the reality is all know is a big NOTHING.

[sahil112]

Just because you have tasted a reality check does not mean you can make drama out of your distaste to others.

Firstly You are a Taliban supporter, You assumed Nek Mohammad Wazir was a Proud Pashtun, You did not know Nek was a Punjabi Talib supporter and a Alqueda operative, plus he was a Proud Pakistani Wazir.

Secondly,you assumed every Pashtun is like you, one side fronting a Nationalist opinion then on the other side screeming "Muslim Unity" but You want to divide Pakistan which is a 99 percent Muslim state.

I think we have another Unknownprince here.

You live in a fantasy of all Pashtuns being united and all fighting for Loy Afghanistan but that is not the case. You need to do some reading on the current events in your region and educate yourself on this bogus heros you claim to follow.

The ancestors of Pashtuns did not start when Islam was created, we were way way way Pashtun before Islam ever was created.

So which ancestors are you referring too?

Finally to end this, Do not even dare to compare todays Taliban with our ancestors, our ancestors never used children to blow themselves up in Markets like Daddullah the Arabised Terrorist Talib did.

Plus, we as the god-less do not specifically target Islam, We do not need to target Islam, Muslims within themselves do a much better job at it, Shias vs Sunni,Wahabi vs Sufi etc etc. Religion is Religion, Pashtuns need to get with time and let go of these fairy tales.

Kind Regards

there is a fb group called re-think afghanistan, guess who started that? it was a white peron, omg he must be a taliban supporter according to your logic :O and so must be the thousands of other people who have joined the group in support of it who i must yet again point out are white/black etc so in basic form for you to understand they are neither afghan or pakistani or arab or even muslim for that matter but according to your logic they must all suddenly be taliban supporters nw. what do you think we should do with them?

[Digital Malang]

Do you need a tissue?

It's not funny. Here is a serious talk going on.

[Fatima]

Get over yourself.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Peera this is a forum and part of the nature of forums is the concept of difference of opinions. We have to cater to all opinions (whether we like them or not). Since none of us are convening a milli jirga we can't pretend to represent 60 million Pashtun/Afghans. Manana

[sahil112]

Get over yourself.

where abouts afghanistan are you from?

[Alchemist]

mazloom aka MI6 has lost his marbles...
but I guess you can't blame him...for being so damn paranoid.

do me next :D

[Admin Khan]

Graveyard of Empires,
I understand your frustration, and if you think anyone is attacking someone, feel free to contact me. We have rules set up which we expect everyone to follow. However, you have to understand we have hundreds of members and all our members don't think alike. If anyone insults Islam, or bashes Afghanistan/Pashtunkhwa, just PM me. You have yet to report anything. What you need to realize is we have Pashtuns who love Pakistan, and we also have Pashtuns who love Afghanistan.

If everything was as lovey dovey as you make it sound, we wouldn't be in this international mess. Whatever you witness here is exactly what you would witness on ground reality. Nearly everybody here is a Pashtun, and all of us are trying to understand each other.

[sahil112]

If everything was as lovey dovey as you make it sound, we wouldn't be in this international mess. Whatever you witness here is exactly what you would witness on ground reality. Nearly everybody here is a Pashtun, and all of us are trying to understand each other.

beautifully written