maata la jannata kabul khkukay dey..

[khushal]

These pakis are singing pro afghan songs just for the money but this guy is an idiot, most afghans would not like what he says.

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

These pakis are singing pro afghan songs just for the money but this guy is an idiot, most afghans would not like what he says.

Only Pakified Pashtuns like Push-Pop ( Pashto pop music from Peshawar)

[Shehbaz Khan]

Khushal: Why Afghans won't like him?

[afghan]

Khushal: Why Afghans won't like him?

who cares what khushal says this moron himelf isnt liked by afghans. all afghans love Haroon Bacha. peshawar has given kabul the most patiriotic and best singers ever. the best example is ustad Awalmir, Gulzama, Gulshan and many more.

[khushal]

Khushal: Why Afghans won't like him?

Im assuming these pashwaris motive to sing these pro afghan songs is to tap into the afghan market for higher revenue pupose and this guys statement "janat na Kabul khkwalia de" is offensive to most afghans. The only afghans that would cheer for this statement are mostly in the west who are mostly out of touch with their countrymen.

[khushal]

who cares what khushal says this moron himelf isnt liked by afghans. all afghans love Haroon Bacha. peshawar has given kabul the most patiriotic and best singers ever. the best example is ustad Awalmir, Gulzama, Gulshan and many more.

What do you know about afghansitan, your under the impression that afghans worship medina. I would advise you to go get an education.

[Yousafzai Pakhtun]

Im assuming these pashwaris motive to sing these pro afghan songs is to tap into the afghan market for higher revenue pupose and this guys statement "janat na Kabul khkwalia de" is offensive to most afghans. The only afghans that would cheer for this statement are mostly in the west who are mostly out of touch with their countrymen.

Well you are accepting these are pro-Afghan songs that he sings but on the other hand you are saying these songs are offensive to most of the afghans. lewaney shwey laka che? and please elaborate why this song is offensive to afghans.

Haroon, Takar and Gulzar are nationalist singers who never tried to sing a song that goes against nationalism and their ideology. For this even they had to suffer with the hands of Talibghwans. They were attacked many times and at last Haroon and Takar were compelled to leave peshawar, but they never stopped singing and praising the pashtun land and its beauty like their predecessors Khushal Khan Khattak and Ghani khan.

Now enjoy this beautiful song lyrics by Ghani khan:
Stargo Da Janan Ke Zama - YouTube

[Yousafzai Pakhtun]

زمونږ د کلي په ملا افرين
د سپرلي رنګ، د رباب ټنګ وژني
په شاړه سر دي د نفرت دلالان
امجده مينه به څوک څنګ وژني

[afghan]

Im assuming these pashwaris motive to sing these pro afghan songs is to tap into the afghan market for higher revenue pupose and this guys statement "janat na Kabul khkwalia de" is offensive to most afghans. The only afghans that would cheer for this statement are mostly in the west who are mostly out of touch with their countrymen.

The more you post the it proves you are truly an idiot. Why do you think one can get rich only if he or she sings in pashto. Look fool most of these nationalist singers have businesses on the sides and jobs as well. How many nationalistic beautiful songs were sung by awalmir have you heard in the conditions he was living? Look at muqurai saeb he is running a business and sardar Ali taker running a business. Harpoon Bacha has a job. Then why most of our so called Pashtun singers singing in Dari. The pashto music industry is in its worse state. Get a life.

[ډګروال]

yes Afghan is right
pashto dhamtob industry in its worst state.

btw i love that song kabul ta zama by karan khan
but this haroon bacha song is garbage.

khushal you are rigth "janat na kabul ekhkulai dai " is extremely offensive.


the same way of you read poetry of ghani khan you would understand their hidden hatred for Islamic way of life while secretly promoting sharab and prostitution.
all of his poems and that sung by sardar ali takkar are coding it with Mullah, they aim their hatred to mullah.
its like saying they hate teachers but are not against education.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Ghani Khan promoted Sharab and Prostitution?

[khushal]

Well you are accepting these are pro-Afghan songs that he sings but on the other hand you are saying these songs are offensive to most of the afghans. lewaney shwey laka che? and please elaborate why this song is offensive to afghans.

Pro Afghanistan meaning that the songs are designed to praise afghansitan but sometimes the design is flawed and that is my point about the subject song in this thread. Zeek Afridi and Musharaf Bangash sing pro Afghansitan songs but their songs are not offensive. Haroon, judging by this song, does not understand Afghans.

[DaZahroJaam.]

"pa mastaano ki d aqal khawand ghal dey.."

[Kushan Prince]

Lol I always found it hilarious when Pekhewaris would sing about Kabul in every song. Like there's more then one city in Afghanistan you know lol.

[afghan]

Why do you have to talk in an offensive manner?
I never said one can get rich, most of you post is a strawman fallacy that has nothing to do with the argument.

The argument is that the motive for peshawaris singing songs that praise afghansitan is to tap into the afghan market to sell their music. Since by your admission pashto music is in its worst state, they need new markets to tap into. My original point was that Haroon is out of touch, he is not doing himself a favor if his goal is to tap into the afghan market if he is sing songs that say "janat na Kabul khkwalai de." He is doing something that is counter productive.

Another point I would like to make is that militant "Kunis" like yourself who promote "kwana wair ka wana" actually strengthen militant salafis who would like to ban music all together. They use yours and Haroons "kunitoob" of offensive material as ammunition to make their point.

now i know why you hate some one is praising kabul. yeh the kabulis talk to Sisies like you that way. you poor thing never try to go there again.
you only understand the language of kabulis. you are outa touch with the reality.
you are contradicting yourself, get some sleep once you wake up try to read what you have posted.