Is this board overrun with Indians?

[roadrunner]

I've noticed a lot of Indians hiding behind non Indian usernames (Khalsa Warrior appears to be the bravest internet Indian). I was doing some calculations. There's more than a billion Indians, most of them unemployed with nothing to do. Doesn't this make all forums a little heavy on the Indian side?

[N.E rocker]

Who said we have nothing to do,we r executing our master plan right here,take over the world by sheer strength of numbers.Pretty ingenious, right!!!!

PS khalsa must have really pissed u off

[roadrunner]

My conclusions so far of the board. Many adolescent westernized Pashtun and non Pashtun origin individuals, more Indians than made out, several hiding behind Afghan ids. Some from Pashtun lands, Shehbaz Khan imo I can't fault as genuine. Along with some Pashutn nationalists (disproportionately represented), and Tajiks. Any disagreement?

[roadrunner]

You are pretty wrong. The majority here are nationalists. Khyaal, Pir Rokhan, Mi6, Tor_Khan, Ijaz Yusufzai, Feroz Afridi and so many more. We do have a few Indians who we admire and we also have Punjabis who we admire. We also have Pakis like Shehbaz Khan who we admire. We also have brave Pashtuns like Shadow Caster who we admire.

You are still new Roadrunner you have not yet met 5 percent of the PF community.

LOL. I love the naivity of youth.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Roadrunner, your initial post is devoid of so much logic, this belongs in the hall "typical conspiratorial jokes"....you just fulfilled a stereotype..pat yourself on your back.

[KhalsaWarrior]

I've noticed a lot of Indians hiding behind non Indian usernames (Khalsa Warrior appears to be the bravest internet Indian). I was doing some calculations. There's more than a billion Indians, most of them unemployed with nothing to do. Doesn't this make all forums a little heavy on the Indian side?

You dont mind telling others about their immaturity while you display yours by making personal remarks.

I am not a Pashtun and neither did I ever pretend to be one but I bet I am a better addition to this forum than a hate mongering, bigot Pakistani.

And what do you mean by non-Indian usernames? Does an Indian has to have the word India in his username?

[roadrunner]

You dont mind telling others about their immaturity while you display yours by making personal remarks.

I am not a Pashtun and neither did I ever pretend to be one but I bet I am a better addition to this forum than a hate mongering, bigot Pakistani.

And what do you mean by non-Indian usernames? Does an Indian has to have the word India in his username?

Khalsa, you want to stifle debate. I must confess as to being wrong about you. Having reported me (and your fellow Indian MINIons) you're clearly just a kid with no bravery. I did think you had some spine but clearly i was wrong.

[KhalsaWarrior]

Khalsa, you want to stifle debate. I must confess as to being wrong about you. Having reported me (and your fellow Indian MINIons) you're clearly just a kid with no bravery. I did think you had some spine but clearly i was wrong.

You, the mature one, are yet to understand how to debate and show civility at the same time. If calling a person names and abusing his country is how you display your standards of bravery in debate, then I'd much rather not debate with you and be called as lacking courage!

[roadrunner]

You, the mature one, are yet to understand how to debate and show civility at the same time. If calling a person names and abusing his country is how you display your standards of bravery in debate, then I'd much rather not debate with you and be called as lacking courage!

That's not a problem. You're obviously too weak and your attempted insults are too lacklustre. You may ignore.

[roadrunner]

Roadrunner, you think everyone's a kid and naive. Clearly, only you are the mature, sensible, adult around here.

14, 15 is a bit on the child's side. I only ask that kids make themselves known. One doesn't want to engage a sparrow in serious debate and upset the applecart.

And I believe Khalsa made a perfectly valid point apropos "non-Indian" name. What is an Indian name and what's a non-Indian name?

Names and pictures are irrelevant on the internet was what I meant. It's not difficult for the whole board to be Indian except you and me, and one or two others. Even if they have bright shiny Bollywood pictures on display. This is fair comment I think.

I also believe that "overrun" is not the correct word for the amount of Indians we have on PF. I've seen perhaps less than 10, although that may be because I'm not as active now as I used to be before, so I don't know exactly who you are referring to. Even if they did overrun this board, would there be a problem? If yes, why? If not, what is the purpose of your initial post? (I by no means mean to discourage you from sharing your personal observations. However, I do think that in cases where the conclusion has no validity to it, perhaps it's a better idea to explain your reasoning more.)

I think a Pashtun forum should be representative of Pashtuns. That's why I think we should treasure Shehbaz Khan on here, for all that I disagree with him on, he would be someone imo who's a product of the Pashtun culture and the Pashtun land. If it's overrun by Indians (and Pashtun nationalists I'd add too), it then becomes a non representative forum of Pashtuns. A more minor point is when Indians pile in it all starts turning into India vs Pakistan, which you can see by the amount of threads they start on this.

[KhalsaWarrior]

That's not a problem. You're obviously too weak and your attempted insults are too lacklustre. You may ignore.

May be I am too weak to insult you in your way but make any more of your silly and bigot posts and you will have me tearing your arguments apart. One by one.

[roadrunner]

May be I am too weak to insult you in your way but make any more of your silly and bigot posts and you will have me tearing your arguments apart. One by one.

You must be joking. I couldn't imagine you tearing wet paper even with your claims of internet warriorship. It's a discussion forum. So fee free to criticize my posts. That's what I'm here for.

[roadrunner]

Oh, you determine that someone's a "child" based on her/his age? That's interesting. Because I don't, and I think those who do are kids themselves.

Why do you need "kids" to make themselves "known" to you? Can you not tell by how they talk or interact with others, or how they handle debates or disagreements?

Yes, it's possible. but I don't have files on the personas here.

What does it mean to be representative of Pashtuns? Over 90% of the forum is Pashtun, as far as I know. So if you think that in order for this forum to be declared Pashtun, it must be majority Pashtun, that's already the case.

it means to represent what the majority of Pashtuns think. Now it's tricky because first you need to define a Pashtun. Second, you'd need to vet people. I don't believe 90% of this forum are Pashtun, even by the loosest standard of definition of a Pashtun. IPs are irrelevant, ISPs more relevant, proxies make it even worse, maskers etc etc. Let me ask you something, Roshina. Do you believe Pashtun Nationalism is a priority amongst Pashtuns living in the Pashtun lands?

[KhalsaWarrior]

You must be joking. I couldn't imagine you tearing wet paper even with your claims of internet warriorship. It's a discussion forum. So fee free to criticize my posts. That's what I'm here for.

Glad you see still see this as a discussion forum. I was beginning to think you saw it as a "shouting insults" match!

[roadrunner]

Glad you see still see this as a discussion forum. I was beginning to think you saw it as a "shouting insults" match!

that certainly tore my argument apart