Originally posted by jodigul
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Pashtuns backbone of Afghanistan
Collapse
X
-
This is not true. Out of the original 'Pakistan' there have been nationalist-cum-seccessionist struggles amongst all ethnicities, save Punjab. Remember Khair Bux Marri, Ghulam Murtaza Syed etc. The anger against Punjabi dominance has always existed but has been pushed underground due to different reasons eg Afghanistan conflict. Do not forget that Pakistan is a valuable tool for the imperialist forces for their hegemonistic designs in C/S Asia.
-
Punjabis in Quetta are because of pashtun's protection, it is the balochs who are killing you.Originally posted by Punjabi View PostAfghanistan is our brother. And we are helping them.
Punjabis do not wish bad for Pashtuns at all.
why do you guys kill us in Quetta?[B]
.............
[/B]
Comment
-
Do not flatter yourself. The Pakistani state did not accept the Afghan refugees out of sympathy or brotherly Islamic feelings. Thus:Originally posted by Afghanprincess^But why do we tend to always have a negative atitude for a country that has hosted nearly 5million of our refugees and a country that never said o to the refugees and it has open borders.
1 The Afghan refugees, despirited, homeless and divided, were a perfect recruitement ground for the contined war in Afghanistan. They were a perfect setting for being the foot soldiers of the Punjabi proxy army in Afghanistan.
2 Pakistan, or the military establishment, earned billions of dollars from international donors in the name of Afghan refugees. I heard a figure of some 75b $ (but I am not sure).
Thus it is obvious that Pakistan benefited, as oppossed to the common propaganda, by housing (or camping ) the Afghan refugees.
Comment
-
You forget that Quetta has large afghan immigrants, they are much assimilated with locals and are quite imposing.Originally posted by Punjabi View Postno it's Pashtuns.
I lived 15 years in Quetta.
Pashtunsabd Baluchs both kill us and disrespect us.
They also impose Pashto on us. They refuse to speak Urdu or call themselves Pakistani.[B]
.............
[/B]
Comment
-
This is funny and ridiculous at the same time. When have you helped Afghanistan my brother? When you were the foot soldiers of the British Army invading Kabul and Kandahar? When you were funding and sheltering an assortment of terrorist and fasadi organizations in the 80s? When you were ruling Kabul through Rawalpindi and trying to fragment Afghanistan?Originally posted by Punjabi View PostAfghanistan is our brother. And we are helping them.
Punjabis do not wish bad for Pashtuns at all.
why do you guys kill us in Quetta?
We are better off without your help. Thank you very much.
Comment
-
We are against taking the life of any innocent civilian. But you must take pains to understand what brought Balochistan to this position?Originally posted by Punjabi View Postno it's Pashtuns.
I lived 15 years in Quetta.
Pashtunsabd Baluchs both kill us and disrespect us.
They also impose Pashto on us. They refuse to speak Urdu or call themselves Pakistani.
Hints: 27/3/1948,1959,1962,1973,2006.
Comment
-
Marha tsok wayi de quettay k pakhtano punjabiyan marra wi?Originally posted by Nadir Shah View PostWe are against taking the life of any innocent civilian. But you must take pains to understand what brought Balochistan to this position?
Hints: 27/3/1948,1959,1962,1973,2006.
Baloch awo pakhtun gudwud kawa.[B]
.............
[/B]
Comment
-
Malgarya, za heesok gad wad kawom na. Zamaa maana daa wa che mung da har wagarhi da jwand da saataney jman kawu, kho daa fikr laru, che bayad de pa de fikr washi che tsa awamil wu che Balochan ye da Pakistan na la tar de pore mutanafira krhal? Aw daa ham che ka da Pashtun, Sindhi , Siraiki da haquuq saatana wa nashwa no deyr zar ba dwee ham pr dey lor rawaan shee.Originally posted by jodigul View PostMarha tsok wayi de quettay k pakhtano punjabiyan marra wi?
Baloch awo pakhtun gudwud kawa.
Comment
-
You are right brother. Quetta is historically, linguistically, culturally and territorially an extension of Kandahar. Indeed, the whole of Balochistan was once under the control of Ahmed Shah Baba. As is true for so many regions of Eastern Pashtun Watan, the division is unjust and unnatural.
Comment
-
Yes Pashtunkhwa is a rightful half of Afghanistan. Its division caused us a lot of harm. Just like the Germans reunited inshallah so will we.Originally posted by Nadir Shah View PostYou are right brother. Quetta is historically, linguistically, culturally and territorially an extension of Kandahar. Indeed, the whole of Balochistan was once under the control of Ahmed Shah Baba. As is true for so many regions of Eastern Pashtun Watan, the division is unjust and unnatural.
Comment
-
similarly, we dont want anything to do with sindhis, panjabis, etc. Kabul drama like the pashtunkhwa drama is partially thanks to GHQ. Leave Afghanistan alone, it will rebuild.Originally posted by pakistani^we don't want anything to do with Tajaks and Uzbeks.
we wil not unite with war torn Afghanistan
Comment
-
Brother, You cannot live in forced islolation in the 21st century. There is no differences between Pashtun/Tajiks/Uzbeks etc that cannot be solved across the table. Furthermore, the ethnic stuff has been brought to fore only due to the 30 years of war and by certain vested iterests who want to de-stabilize the Afghan Republic.Originally posted by pakistani^we don't want anything to do with Tajaks and Uzbeks.
we wil not unite with war torn Afghanista
Comment

Comment