Understanding Pashtun Nationalism

[abassinafghan]

well , the nationalist who dances for dallar , the islamist who dances for dallar by crosstrade true saudi rial and rupee.

but to which doll dance sada mamat ???????

[checkmate]

Who are Pashtun nationalists? Asfandyar Wali ? Hamid Karzai? Ahmad Karzai?

Don't these people support the US war against Afghanistan and FATA?

So, how can they be so-called Pashtun nationalists?

Didn't ANP support Soviet war against Afghanistan, and now supports the US war against Afghanistan?

So how are they Pashtun nationalists?

Putting aside the fact that nationalism is prohibited in Islam, these people are an insult to the very term nationalism. Show me any instance in history where nationalists of any nation supported war upon their country.

Is it therefore no wonder the futile state of their politics.

Who is better? A man who does not support war upon his Muslim brethren in Afghanistan and FATA, or a man who openly and fully supports war upon them?

The future belongs to those who are freeing their country.

[checkmate]

Till these so-called secular pashtun nationalists pick up arms and fight for their own ideals rather then sit back like cowards and support foreigners war against their own people, they will remain hated and insignificant. They will only be hated and blamed for their support for wars upon Afghanistan.

If these so-called Pashtun nationalists wanted to establish credibility, wouldn't they be opposed to rather then supportive of the US war in Afghanistan?

Shouldn't thy be defending FATA? Isn't that what nationalists are supposed to do? These people are no patriots at all.

Their record of betrayal speaks for itself: supported the Soviet war against Afghanistan, and today support the US war against Afghanistan.

What movement is there? It is a complete joke and mockery of nationalism in the first place.

[bernardwhite]

who were considered the Pashtun nationalist's during the soviet invasion?

what did they want? how did they go about getting it?

would you call Hekmatyar a Pashtun nationalist?

though Tajik, could you call Massoud an Afghan nationalist?