Future Map of Loy Afghanistan(pukhtunistan)

[Shehbaz Khan]

I heard the same people talking a few days back that the swaties are most bayghairat people and now they are saying that Swat will be the capital lol :D
I didn't waste a second on the video :P

[fzpz]

forget the persian and punjabi parts, why are baloch areas part of loy afghanistan? I forgot, ocean access! Reading Baloch Hal, it's easy to see how much they dislike pakhtuns.

[fzpz]

GOE, it probably closer to the truth that more lar pakhtuns fight for Pakistan/Porkistan/Punjabistan/Pakjabistan/etc than for the colonial buffer state of Afghanistan, or the internet empire of Pashtunistan.

[fzpz]

@Karachi...just like when you visit Pakistani forums and you see "Kashmir banaega Pakistan.."...as this is a Pashtun/Afghan forum, you will see people talking about Loy Afghanistan or Pashtunkhwa. This is an inclination, a desire for people. Palestinians, Kurds, Baloch, etc all have their dreams and desires. So in this forum, there is a portion of us who would love to see us unified. It is as simple as that.

Vast difference. An actual verifiable movement versus no inclination from the people at hand (Kashmiris vs Pak Pashtuns). Sure, negligible portions on the internet. It is as simple as that.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Vast difference. An actual verifiable movement versus no inclination from the people at hand (Kashmiris vs Pak Pashtuns). Sure, negligible portions on the internet. It is as simple as that.

Lol you are kidding right? There are probably more Pashtuns that are pro-union than Kashmiris wanting to join Pakistan. if anything Pakistan has failed on the kashmir front totally. Militarily, morally, historically, and politically. Loy Afghanistan, or Pashtunistan or whatever for that matter is contingent on the Pashtun populace...if they see their political union in the near future it is possible, as the people are of the same nation. Kashmir, on the other hand, would like their own state and have little interest in staying with either of the two. Nice try though.
oh and Baloch may dislike Pashtuns, but they will embrace us 9/10 when compared to Pakistan or Panjab. Again nice try.

@Manzareh, panjab and sindh are part of the sub-continent, and have no connection to Loy Afghanistan. It is as simple as that.

[کیش]

If all the persian parts are in included in 'Loy afghanistan' why arent the Punjabi parts?

I said am in favor of uniting all Afg/Pak, into one nation. I don't like the name Loy Afghanistan, it should be called something neutral.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

^^we should retain our Afghan/pashtun identity, neutral or no neutral name.

[کیش]

If anyone is against this, and says he's a Muslim is confused. You should welcome all sorts of unification. The average poverty rate in Afghanistan/Pakistan, is pretty high, not to mention the literacy rate

Both countries need to exile every government worker, and start afresh.

I guess that would be the Mahdi's job. I could guarantee all of you would be against the Mahdi.

[کیش]

^^we should retain our Afghan/pashtun identity, neutral or no neutral name.

If they wanna a whole province called Pashtunistan, no problem. But we cannot treat Baluch, Parsiwaans, Punjabi's as second class citizens.

[کیش]

uniting whole pak will make no difference, Afghanistan will become a fifth province of pakistan and pakistan might adopt Farsi as the national language. I have heard this from many pakistanis. They would love to change their language to farsi and be known as persians. This scenario doesn't serve the intrests of pashtuns. we will either have to speak urdu or persian with farsiwan and pakistani backup. punjabis will still outnumber us 3-1.

Thats a bad bad solution. Right now pashtuns make 15% of pakistan, thats like the way hazras or uzbeks are in Afghanistan who make 9% of population each. They are known as minorities and will never have much power. much like pashtuns of pakistan being 15% of population will never have enough power to retain their identity in the long run.

They all need to change their mind state if they want to move on from the worlds laughing stock.

They need to leave this chauvinistic, and racism attitude tha every group has in their. Everyone needs to calm down, and treat other members of other groups the same. America isn't perfect, but see how it works? Almost all groups of the region are Muslims, and need to start acting like one.

We need to also unite with every other Muslim group.

[Fahd]

I said am in favor of uniting all Afg/Pak, into one nation. I don't like the name Loy Afghanistan, it should be called something neutral.

over my dead body

[کیش]

Still we should have something like European Union, languages may differ state to state.

Urdu is not even related to Punjabis. I know , still the system in Pakistan, jobs etc for provinces is based on population , which should be changed .

They need to adopt the US system, how every ethnicity lives with others. Theirs some racism, but it's still a very low percentage

The language is a problem, but it can be resolved.


Fahd
Habibi, don't waste your life.

[Fahd]

LOL ya habibi walaka tol pakistan pa afghanistan one nation kama !!
we just gona take our land nothing else

[BLS_1919v2.0]

If they wanna a whole province called Pashtunistan, no problem. But we cannot treat Baluch, Parsiwaans, Punjabi's as second class citizens.

I never said that. I would agree with timbucktu about a palk-afghan reunion now, it will make us their backyard. It made sense before, but not anymore..for now we should first strive for an autonomous Pashtunkhwa (unified) and Afghanistan....and in the near future slowly bring the union.

[fzpz]

Lol you are kidding right? There are probably more Pashtuns that are pro-union than Kashmiris wanting to join Pakistan. if anything Pakistan has failed on the kashmir front totally. Militarily, morally, historically, and politically. Loy Afghanistan, or Pashtunistan or whatever for that matter is contingent on the Pashtun populace...if they see their political union in the near future it is possible, as the people are of the same nation. Kashmir, on the other hand, would like their own state and have little interest in staying with either of the two. Nice try though.
oh and Baloch may dislike Pashtuns, but they will embrace us 9/10 when compared to Pakistan or Panjab. Again nice try.

@Manzareh, panjab and sindh are part of the sub-continent, and have no connection to Loy Afghanistan. It is as simple as that.

Oh oh, hit a raw nerve. Projection of your reading about the famed pashtun nationalism. It never got going. The probably is also like a lot of your other "probables", in your head. The thing with Pakistan vis a vis Kashmir is that Pak doesn't have to do anything, it's the Kashmiris fighting for their rights, however they define them (pak or independence or india or timbaktu). While afghanists keep blabbering on the internet and nothing happens. Keep trying and telling yourself things, probably the only thing to do given the pathetic state of pashtun nationalists and their dreams. Peace lala