Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Are most non-Pashtun Afghans pro-Pakistani and support the Durrand Line?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Are most non-Pashtun Afghans pro-Pakistani and support the Durrand Line?

    Is it that Tajiks, Uzbecks and Hazaras (Northern Alliance) are pro Pakistani and will recognize the durrand line and all anti-Pakistani sentiments and anti-Durrand line sentiments come only from Afghan Pashtuns?

    Like because they need the Durrand line otherwise they'd become the shear minority of Afghanistan.

  • #2
    I've spoken to some Tajiks and other non-pashtun Afghans such as Uzbeks both irl and online and they opposed the reunification A'stan and KPK; they're afraid of becoming a minority and being ruled by Pashtuns so they would rather have a Turkestan/Khorasan/Loy-Tajikistan and personally as a native Abbotabadi, i don't want my native lands of Hazara and Mansehra merging with Afghanistan, and the Lar Pashtuns can decide for themselves.
    "I bow to no one, except ALLAH. I dont bow to punjabay, do not bow to kabulay and afghanay, do not bow to faujay and mullay, do not bow to asfandyarwalay and petty khanays...i am traitor to all of them." - Smartay

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by tripledouble View Post
      I've spoken to some Tajiks and other non-pashtun Afghans such as Uzbeks both irl and online and they opposed the reunification A'stan and KPK; they're afraid of becoming a minority and being ruled by Pashtuns so they would rather have a Turkestan/Khorasan/Loy-Tajikistan and personally as a native Abbotabadi, i don't want my native lands of Hazara and Mansehra merging with Afghanistan, and the Lar Pashtuns can decide for themselves.
      wait, you are a Hazara ? The Mongolian ones?

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by kanishka View Post
        wait, you are a Hazara ? The Mongolian ones?
        lol no, Hazara and Mansehra are districts in KPK and the people there speak Hindko and Kohistani and we're all mostly Sunni.
        "I bow to no one, except ALLAH. I dont bow to punjabay, do not bow to kabulay and afghanay, do not bow to faujay and mullay, do not bow to asfandyarwalay and petty khanays...i am traitor to all of them." - Smartay

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by kanishka View Post
          wait, you are a Hazara ? The Mongolian ones?
          1. Hazara is a "division" (administrative area) inside Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Hazarewals are people of that region.

          2. These Hazarewals or Hazaras speak Hindko.

          Many are originally Pashtuns who have become Punjabized/Hindkoized but are originally from tribes such as the Jadoons, Tareens and others.

          Others are just Hindko/Punjabi such as Gujjars and so on.

          They have nothing to do with the Hazaras of Afghanistan who are Mongoloid, Shia, Farsi-speakers.
          * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by tripledouble View Post
            lol no, Hazara and Mansehra are districts in KPK and the people there speak Hindko and Kohistani and we're all mostly Sunni.
            Jadoon or tanoli?
            [URL="http://historyofpashtuns.blogspot.com.au/2014/07/afghan-sikh-wars.html"][SIZE=5][COLOR=Green]History of Pashtuns[/COLOR][/SIZE][/URL]

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Smarty View Post
              Jadoon or tanoli?
              neither, my father's family is from the Tareen tribe and my mothers family have different origins, probably some Gujjar ancestry.
              "I bow to no one, except ALLAH. I dont bow to punjabay, do not bow to kabulay and afghanay, do not bow to faujay and mullay, do not bow to asfandyarwalay and petty khanays...i am traitor to all of them." - Smartay

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by tripledouble View Post
                neither, my father's family is from the Tareen tribe and my mothers family have different origins, probably some Gujjar ancestry.
                Then you must be originally from haripur if you are tareen
                [URL="http://historyofpashtuns.blogspot.com.au/2014/07/afghan-sikh-wars.html"][SIZE=5][COLOR=Green]History of Pashtuns[/COLOR][/SIZE][/URL]

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Smarty View Post
                  Then you must be originally from haripur if you are tareen
                  Yes, my paternal grandparents are but they settled in Abbotabad because it is the biggest city of hazara and the future capital
                  "I bow to no one, except ALLAH. I dont bow to punjabay, do not bow to kabulay and afghanay, do not bow to faujay and mullay, do not bow to asfandyarwalay and petty khanays...i am traitor to all of them." - Smartay

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by tripledouble View Post
                    Yes, my paternal grandparents are but they settled in Abbotabad because it is the biggest city of hazara and the future capital
                    So you are supporter of soba i hazara . Why exactly?
                    [URL="http://historyofpashtuns.blogspot.com.au/2014/07/afghan-sikh-wars.html"][SIZE=5][COLOR=Green]History of Pashtuns[/COLOR][/SIZE][/URL]

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by tripledouble View Post
                      Yes, my paternal grandparents are but they settled in Abbotabad because it is the biggest city of hazara and the future capital
                      So you are supporter of soba i hazara :P , Why exactly?
                      [URL="http://historyofpashtuns.blogspot.com.au/2014/07/afghan-sikh-wars.html"][SIZE=5][COLOR=Green]History of Pashtuns[/COLOR][/SIZE][/URL]

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by tripledouble View Post
                        Yes, my paternal grandparents are but they settled in Abbotabad because it is the biggest city of hazara and the future capital
                        Do you consider yourself Hindki or Pashtun?

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Azad Pashtunistan View Post
                          Do you consider yourself Hindki or Pashtun?
                          I consider myself Hindkowan but i also acknowledge by pashtun lineage.
                          "I bow to no one, except ALLAH. I dont bow to punjabay, do not bow to kabulay and afghanay, do not bow to faujay and mullay, do not bow to asfandyarwalay and petty khanays...i am traitor to all of them." - Smartay

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by tripledouble View Post
                            I consider myself Hindkowan but i also acknowledge by pashtun lineage.
                            That's strange. I always thought that everyone by their father's ethnicity.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Azad Pashtunistan View Post
                              That's strange. I always thought that everyone by their father's ethnicity.
                              Yes, but father speaks Hindko too, a lot Hindkowans have Pashtun blood but we also have dardic ancestry as well
                              "I bow to no one, except ALLAH. I dont bow to punjabay, do not bow to kabulay and afghanay, do not bow to faujay and mullay, do not bow to asfandyarwalay and petty khanays...i am traitor to all of them." - Smartay

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X