Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Moving targets: the female dancers of the Swat Valley

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Moving targets: the female dancers of the Swat Valley



    Moving targets: the female dancers of the Swat Valley

    Ghazala Javed had the dreams of any young woman her age - lifelong security, happiness and a husband to love.

    Sweet-faced and with girlish innocence, she listed all the qualities she was looking for in a husband - he had to be kind and understanding, but most of all he had to let her sing after they wed.

    Javed was one of the rare few who had "made it" - one of the infamous community of singers and dancers carrying on a legacy of Pashtun culture in Pakistan's notorious Swat Valley. They have survived despite concerted efforts by religious extremists to drive them out and in the face of opprobrium from academics, who see their art as a "vulgar" reinvention of classical music and dance.

    Javed was put to work as a teenage dancer at 14 and married in her 20s to a man twice her age to secure the family's future. He banned her from singing and they divorced two years later when she discovered he already had two other wives.

    But it was the discovery of that golden voice in 2008 that catapulted her to fame and promised a different life from the fate which met most of the performing community, forced to dance and sing from necessity rather than desire and living on the fringes of society.

    She was a rare breed - she loved singing and earned respectability, status and wealth, becoming as adept at performing old folk tunes as the Pashto pop songs for which she earned worldwide fame, drawing crowds of thousands in Dubai, Malaysia, Qatar and across Europe.

    Earlier this year I had the privilege of a private audience with the 26-year-old performer, lounging on cushions in her parents' majlis - one of six homes her fortune had built - as her father poured milky tea and Javed sang.

    Seven weeks later she was dead, gunned down with her father in a hail of bullets as she left a beauty salon.

    In the immediate aftermath, police said her ex-husband Jahangir Khan was a chief suspect, his motive thought to be the shame heaped on him after she left him and resumed her singing career.

    Whatever the truth, she is unquestionably the latest victim in an industry where choosing to perform can literally mean life or death.

    A pretty, chubby-faced teenager plumps down on a tattered armchair, full of excited banter about her day at school.

    There were the lessons in maths and English, friendships forged in the playground and the journey back to the cramped home she shares with 17 relatives. But Waheeda's education does not end when she gets home from school.

    At the urging of the five grown men squeezed into a tiny sitting room-cum-bedroom, the 13-year-old shrugs off her hijab and abaya, slicks on some maroon lipstick, puts a Pashto pop CD on play and begins to shimmy to the music.

    The lime green walls of the claustrophobic room, stuffed with worn furniture and vases of artificial flowers, begin to close in. This is a scene of excruciating discomfort.

    Waheeda is one of the famed dancing girls of Banr, a neighbourhood in the town of Mingora, in the heart of the Swat Valley.

    She comes from a long line of dancers, whose folkloric moves and knowledge of poetry and classical music historically drew rapturous crowds during week-long melas at Eid, weddings and festivals.

    Those days, though, are long gone. While the girls are still trained from a young age, they now tend to perform to groups of male customers. And rather than being accompanied by skilled musicians, they are more likely to perform to pop music.

    Caught between two diametrically opposed camps, they have been driven behind closed doors to keep a tradition going - albeit in a limp imitation of the art th....

  • #2
    Yuck!

    I am no bird, and no nest ensnares me.

    non commercial would cost less if he was in charge himself which he plans on doing. right now it's n herat but soon it will be in qanadahar.

    Comment


    • #3
      Let's be honest, She hardly had a "golden voice" as the article mentions but at the same time she had the right to pursue her dreams as long it was within the law. There was clearly a demand for her "talent" and she had a family to feed so we can't really blame her for what she did.

      Comment


      • #4
        Really sad to see our people becoming like this.
        I really Love Swat people and this kind of things makes me sad.

        Comment


        • #5
          Ghazala Javed was alright. I don't know if she was really carrying on the 'legacy' of Pashtun culture as mentioned in this article or if what she produced was really 'art'. I feel sad for the Waheeda girl, they make it seem like the poor girl is dancing out of her own will, when in reality she's probably impoverished, and seeing that her ancestors were all dancers too or (duman) as Pashtuns call them, she probably has no other option, but to dance for others because her destiny was already determined because of the kind of family she was born into. I hated how the article twisted reality.
          True wisdom comes to each of us when we realize how little we understand about life, ourselves, and the world around us. - Socrates

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by pashtanajan View Post
            Ghazala Javed was alright. I don't know if she was really carrying on the 'legacy' of Pashtun culture as mentioned in this article or if what she produced was really 'art'. I feel sad for the Waheeda girl, they make it seem like the poor girl is dancing out of her own will, when in reality she's probably impoverished, and seeing that her ancestors were all dancers too or (duman) as Pashtuns call them, she probably has no other option, but to dance for others because her destiny was already determined because of the kind of family she was born into. I hated how the article twisted reality.
            one must have self respect, i know the family might have been very impoverished but dancing and selling yourself should not be an option. first its her family they should all burn in hell if they were making their daughter dance but they should die from hunger and live a respectful life than be rich and be a dama

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by pashtanajan View Post
              Ghazala Javed was alright. I don't know if she was really carrying on the 'legacy' of Pashtun culture as mentioned in this article or if what she produced was really 'art'. I feel sad for the Waheeda girl, they make it seem like the poor girl is dancing out of her own will, when in reality she's probably impoverished, and seeing that her ancestors were all dancers too or (duman) as Pashtuns call them, she probably has no other option, but to dance for others because her destiny was already determined because of the kind of family she was born into. I hated how the article twisted reality.
              Thats how they started the caste system in India

              Comment


              • #8
                Kil the "men" and the women will be just fine.

                Comment


                • #9
                  ^nothing mends the shredded pieces of a woman's soul like the love affection and respect of a good man. he will give you wings to fly with and not once by lending you his own courage but guiding you towards your own. good women raise good sons.

                  it's very easy to condemn the families of these woman for allowing them or placing them in these positions where they have to dance to make a living for themselves and their families. what we don't understand is that by constantly looking down at them and shunning them off from society, we have left them with that one choice only. the only thing that they are responsible for is allowing these men to take advantage of their position in society by practicing behind closed doors.

                  when ghazala became a singer, she had everyone's respect for six months until videos of her dancing in those weddings went viral. she was presenting herself on stage far better than naghma does but no one noticed that.


                  "To burn always with this hard gemlike flame, to maintain this ecstasy, is success in life."





                  Comment


                  • #10
                    But a good man isn't in the picture where these women are concerned. You will only have ones that sell and others that buy. By force or by trickery. I don't understand a man wanting to live off the women in his life. It's the most unmanly thing he can do. It's something else if he's crippled in one way or another. These men who eat off their daughters, sisters, wives need to be killed like dogs and the same goes for men who provide the demand. There are other means of earning a living. Not every poor person resorts to selling themselves or the women in the family. And lets be honest, music is the last thing being pursued here.

                    As for your good women raise good sons comment. It sounds really nice but is not true I'm sure you know lol. There is so much more involved in the raising and development of a person than a good mother lol
                    Last edited by water; 09-29-2012, 06:15 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      these young girls are forced into dancing business, some of them gets lucky turn to singing.
                      it does seem like ghazala javed ex-husband is just a scapegoat. no one turn their eyes towards the real killers. why no one asks akram khan durrani why his son killed himself after the death ghazala javed? even his son had warned his father akram khan durrani nothing must happen to ghazal javed, the woman he loved and wanted to marry her.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by water View Post
                        But a good man isn't in the picture where these women are concerned. You will only have ones that sell and others that buy. By force or by trickery. I don't understand a man wanting to live off the women in his life. It's the most unmanly thing he can do. It's something else if he's crippled in one way or another. These men who eat off their daughters, sisters, wives need to be killed like dogs and the same goes for men who provide the demand. There are other means of earning a living. Not every poor person resorts to selling themselves or the women in the family. And lets be honest, music is the last thing being pursued here.
                        either you have never been in poverty or you have forgotten. i recently saw a documentary about penniless afghans handing over their daughters for debts incurred to druglords, after their opium fields being forcibly eradicated, by the government and the westerners.
                        their own lives had been threatened and some children had been kidnapped by the druglords. these fathers were in terrible distress over this. one had turned to smoking opium.
                        apart from the war, the people of pakistan and afghanistan also suffer from severe droughts, floods and landslides, etc.
                        how is killing people like dogs, a solution to problems within society, including severe poverty?
                        why is it not ok for a woman to be the breadwinner, if that is the only means possible for people to survive?
                        some australian families i know, take turns, where the man is sometimes the outside worker and sometimes the homemaker, when that is the convenient option for availability of an income.
                        Last edited by faye; 09-29-2012, 09:45 PM.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I was talking about men who are prostituting their women and men who provide the demand for it. Most girls in this so called singing business are used as pawns in the hands of these men. Singing is the last thing they're interested in

                          The rest of what you said is irrelevant to the topic.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            a woman who chooses prostitution or anything of that nature over no life at all, has made her bargain. as they say, "justice serves those who serve themselves".

                            "To burn always with this hard gemlike flame, to maintain this ecstasy, is success in life."





                            Comment


                            • #15
                              so much for Pashtunwali ...I always knew that **** was fake as ****
                              [QUOTE=Afghanistan2010;658085][B]He is no different [COLOR="Red"]than us[/COLOR][/B],[B]he[COLOR="Red"] blindly believes [/COLOR]in the words [COLOR="Red"]of other men[/COLOR][/B],:[/QUOTE]

                              2010 Admitting he's a blind believer not in God, but what other men says.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X