Pashtanai qabilay

[torkham]

I invite knowledgeable members to ascertain accuracy of this document:

https://www.scribd.com/doc/15687191/Pashtun-Tribes-Pukhtun-Tribes-

It is a tribal structure map in list format.

Please comment on accuracy with particular emphasis on:
Baitane bracketed as Ghilji
Sarban bracketed as Durani
Correct place of each subtribe under relevant main tribe
Omissions and Additions

For instance:
1)Under Gharghast tribe, the subtribe (12)Sapai (safi) appear.
I can confirm from other sources (Khyber.org) that safi belong to Gharghast tribe.

2)under Sarban(Durani), the subtribe (31) Momand appear.
I can confirm Momand appear correctly placed under Sarban tribe, however the intermediate sub-tribe Ghoria Khel linking Sarban to Momand is not indicated (www.freewebs.com/mohmands)

3)bracketing of Sarban as Durani - no evidence available to confirm or refute.

4)Under Sarban, sub-tribe (18) is Saakzai. No evidence to support this. However ScimitarX has claimed sakzai to be Ghilji.

So please look at the structure see if you find any anomalies.

Manana

[Afghanistan2010]

There are some wrongs i have seen in some of these structure maps regarding paktyawal tribes...for others i can't say much.

[torkham]

There are some wrongs i have seen in some of these structure maps regarding paktyawal tribes...for others i can't say much.

Thanks. Please comment what is incorrect, give me specific detail. I'll compile it and after some time map out a new tribe tree.

[Afghanistan2010]

Brother your link is not working properly.

[torkham]

Brother your link is not working properly.

Try now. Move the slide tool t bottom to see pages 1 through 8.

[Afghanistan2010]

Yes,i overlooked it,and it is all fine til now,inshaAllah i will check with other sources,if i find anything not suiting i will report,but good job mashaAllah.

[Midnight_Sun]

There is a far superior Pashtun Qabiley book written by Dr. Latif Yaad. It has been recently updated as well.

You can download the PDF e-book from Khyber.org:

http://www.khyber.org/books/latifyada.pdf

[torkham]

There is a far superior Pashtun Qabiley book written by Dr. Latif Yaad. It has been recently updated as well.

You can download the PDF e-book from Khyber.org:

http://www.khyber.org/books/latifyada.pdf

thanks!!!!
i will look into it. the books i have seen are by the english who were in india, not what i am looking for.

[Midnight_Sun]

Dr. Latif Yaad's book is a lot more in detail and adds footnotes on prominent figures that are not known by the Western World. You will like it a lot better.

[torkham]

midnightsun, latif yada book stops after 'kaaf'. where is the other part? you know, 'laam, meem, nun . . . '