Helping or ruining culture?

[afghan]

this is still more descent than whats happening in peshawar, the girls jumping like monkeys they have no idea of dancing, they just go the stage shakes their butts.they look weird. Its the pashtunland this all is happening. beautiful songs have been ruined. how can we complain of totally diffirent culture, and country. her dressing seems pretty normal for her country. some examples:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hO-yNcYFAs&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpZCgOXcNEg&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpO-9B4mSHs&feature=related

there are hundred like these. our culture is ruined in our own pashtun land.

[tor_khan]

When the quality of "entertainment" that is vomitted up out of the Peshawar media scene, I guess we can't complain that Tajiki/Tajikistanis don't have a good grip on our culture.

There's a whole list of them - Dilnaz, Hadiqa Kiyani, Deeyah, Sharon Osser etc. and many, many more who see the commercial benefit in performing using Pashto language. Frankly, as the previous post says, watching them is less embarassing than watching us, mispronuciation notwithstanding.

[شمله ور خراساني]

this is still more descent than whats happening in peshawar, the girls jumping like monkeys they have no idea of dancing, they just go the stage shakes their butts.they look weird. Its the pashtunland this all is happening. beautiful songs have been ruined. how can we complain of totally diffirent culture, and country. her dressing seems pretty normal for her country. some examples:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hO-yNcYFAs&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpZCgOXcNEg&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpO-9B4mSHs&feature=related

there are hundred like these. our culture is ruined in our own pashtun land.

I think Taliban are useless. Howcome they do not target kill all these pimps and ho's?

[شمله ور خراساني]

Guys n girls Salamoona

A couple of yrs ago i met this new singer in kabul. He had recently returned from Tajikistan after making a video.
He gave me his cd which i never watch till today lol, but i saw one of his clips on youtube.. some 5 to 10 tajikistani girls wearing Traditional Afghani dress dancing on stage.

I really didnt like it because those clothes are worn by our proud Pashtanai and were worn by women like Malalai and Nazo.

2nd thing is that many of them specially tajikistani singers come up with pashto songs n music wearing naked clothes.
I have the example of it,, this girl ruined the beautiful song of Ustad shah wali which i really love.







So now you ppl decide .. is it helping our culture or pashtunizm or destroying it?

This woman is not just a very bad singer. She is also extremely ugly. Looks like one of those bacha-berish fro those bacha bazi video's on youtube.

[MazloomyarMaseed]

Let women from Tajikistan wear Afghan clothes, as if we Pashtuns care about our culture and people.

[Marwat]

This is a slap to our culture.

[afghan]

I think Taliban are useless. Howcome they do not target kill all these pimps and ho's?

taliban are targetting there only the pashtuns who can raise their voice against pakistan, who can call for pashtun unity.

[Azmatullah]

Terrible song, she can't even pronounce the words right, lol... this woman must think she is Madonna.

[Sheenka]

OUR MOST PASHTUNS DRESS LIKE THIS ANYWAY
LOL
WE SHOULD BE HAPPY THIS MAKES OUR LANGAUGE FAMOUS , PLUS THEY R AT LEAST BETTER THAN PAKISTANI PASHTO DANCE (DEMI)

http://www.youtube.com/watch#!v=KKTUI0BEO_Q&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch#!v=oTvL8VoESTM&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9tRLGgWIpM

watch the background ppl
thats how pashtoon dresses normally and them ppl made it fun :@

[AnGaaR]

Let women from Tajikistan wear Afghan clothes, as if we Pashtuns care about our culture and people.

Our national clothes are not made for those kinda women to wear, recently i saw these 3 tajiki girls in america dancing in very wedding party wearing afghani clothes. da zmong da culture spakawai da.
May some dont care about their culture but i am damn proud of it and i care alot.

[MazloomyarMaseed]

How can people here say its runing our culture because the way shes dressed, there are people here who promote short sleeves and jeans which is in honest opinion no different than what the girl is wearing on the video.

Let her sing what she wants, because even if somebody opposes her as being a tajik, they are deemed as racist and a not good pashtun.

[*Mahzala*]

How can people here say its runing our culture because the way shes dressed, there are people here who promote short sleeves and jeans which is in honest opinion no different than what the girl is wearing on the video.

It seems you still haven't understood the argument in those posts. What a shame.

[MazloomyarMaseed]

It seems you still haven't understood the argument in those posts. What a shame.

Whats so shameful in what i wrote.

If a Afghan woman can wear Jeans and short sleeve tops, but then criticise a Tajik woman wearing an Afghan dress, what difference does it make.

[*Mahzala*]

There is nothing shameful about what you wrote. I do not side those who 'promote' short sleeves (in the presence of non-mahrams, of course), nor do I advocate jeans. It is a figure of speech; that it seems you missed the point in the posts you referred to in your previous post.

And I don't think this thread is limited to dress. =)

[Afghan_Soldier]

Stop being the xenophobic moles. There is nothing wrong with these Tajiks singing Pashtu. I like the first video, it sounds funny and nice these Tajiki girls singing for us. And Mullah Sangar thinks she looks like bacha bersih..hahaha. lol

It makes me laugh when I see people like Marwat and others from Peshawar faking and hyping up about Pashtun culture and music when their whole music entertainment is exclusively the squeaky monkeys some one explained early, jumping up and down and . These ones at least has more class than you Mujrah girls exported from Panjab. I am not condoning the immodist cloths being wore (I hardly see anything revealing any way) by these girls, but they are still more modest and 'bahaya' than the monkeys jumping at the back for Nazia Iqbal. I agree with torkhan.