ANA soldiers torturing (foot sole beating) some locals, Dutch soldiers walking in

[abubaker]

this is truly sickening, and we blame the Punjabi for killing our brethren

si khpal darta wagi si no prado na sa gila


KRO-Reporter -

[afghan]

i think the prisoners are panjabies, one of the soldiers speak in urdu.

[abubaker]

what the hell would punjabi solders be doing in SPIN GHAR.

They are not punjabies the prisoners are Afghans being tortured by ANA and Dutch soldiers.

Yeah I think you do need a flash player.

[afghan]

what the hell would punjabi solders be doing in SPIN GHAR.

They are not punjabies the prisoners are Afghans being tortured by ANA and Dutch soldiers.

Yeah I think you do need a flash player.

no one is arguing what their origina is, the languages they speak is dari, urdu and i think pashto as well. i believe the afghan government wont hire panjabies, but i guess these prisoners are panjabies.

[khyaal]

this is truly sickening, and we blame the Punjabi for killing our brethren

si khpal darta wagi si no prado na sa gila


KRO-Reporter -

So the news is here just to counter the reports of Paki army's horrendous crimes in Pakhtunkhwa? Ok, I admit that paki army is a lot better for Pashtuns than this ANA. lol

[abubaker]

no one is arguing what their origina is, the languages they speak is dari, urdu and i think pashto as well. i believe the afghan government wont hire panjabies, but i guess these prisoners are panjabies.

non of the prisoners could be heard in the video

even if they were punjabies should thy be treated like that? what happened to the Geneva convention then.

@ KHAYAL chatyato bandi sar ye, kam kas dalta dasi khabara kaldi

[Zahed]

non of the prisoners could be heard in the video

even if they were punjabies should thy be treated like that? what happened to the Geneva convention then.

@ KHAYAL chatyato bandi sar ye, kam kas dalta dasi khabara kaldi

the question is what 're Punjabis doing in Spinghar? 'n we don't know who they 're 'n what they 've done so how can u guys judge so easily 'n so quickly?

[abubaker]

are you people stupid or what, there are no punjabies in the video

[afghan]

are you people stupid or what, there are no punjabies in the video

open your ears and listen to what they say in the video? why would afghan soldiers speak urdu? does it make sense? may be they have caught some ISI guys. do you know who those guys are?

[abubaker]

i don't hear any urdu

may be you are hearing what you want to hear

[Zahed]

i don't hear any urdu

may be you are hearing what you want to hear

or u 're ur ears to something u don't want to hear. just listen very carefully at the end.

[abubaker]

the operation was lead by the Dutch, so maybe what your hearing is Dutch

the video was filmed by one of the Dutch soldier during the raid, go to the website and read the translation of what he says, no where does he mention the presence of any punjabies, why would he omit such detail in his post, if he is willing to expose his own people then what is there to stop him from mentioning Punjabi involvement in the operation

btw from what i can hear the ANA are clearly speaking southern pashto