Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

We should apologise to Bengalis for the discrimination

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • We should apologise to Bengalis for the discrimination

    Fall of Dhaka: ‘We should apologise to Bengalis for the discrimination’
    By Hassan Naqvi

    Published: December 21, 2013


    LAHORE:

    “Bangla is an older language than Urdu yet in his 1948 speech in East Pakistan Quaid-i-Azam declared Urdu the national language of Pakistan,” Journalist Khalid Chaudhry said on Friday.

    He was speaking at a discussion titled Fall of Dhaka Who is Responsible, here at the South Asian Free Media Association auditorium.
    Chaudhry said not many countries were established on the basis of religion. “We should apologise to the Bengalis for the discrimination they faced,” he said.

    SAFMA Secretary General Imtiaz Alam said the Hamoodur Rehman Commission report should be published and its gist included in the curriculum.

    Alam said Bengalis were discriminated against. “Not a single chief secretary was from East Pakistan,” he said.

    “The Jamaat-i-Islami (JI) acted as an ally of Yahya Khan, who was responsible for the military operation.”

    He said it was sad that Pakistan had not learnt from history. “We should apologise to Bengalis for their suffering at the hands of people from West Pakistan,” he said.

    Reazud Din Ahmed, a Bangladeshi journalist, speaking via conference call said the people of Bangladesh were not happy with the PTI chief’s statement that Qadir was executed because he had been loyal to Pakistan. “Bengalis want an apology over this,” he said.

    Awami National Party (ANP) Central Secretary General Ehsan Wynne said the Bengalis were tolerant people “otherwise East Pakistan would seceded much sooner.”

    “The army and feudals in West Pakistan wanted dictatorship, Bengalis were in favour of democracy,” he said.


    He said the political leaders of the time were responsible for the military operation of 1970. Wynne said East and West Pakistan had little in common “the way we forced them to seek separation wasn’t right.”

    Fall of Dhaka:




    Ehsan Wyne, Central Secretary of the pro-Pashtun ANP, though he himself might be an ethnic Punjabi. The ANP has senior non-Pashtun leaders in it.


    Born in Amritsar (India) on May 3 1938, Ehsan Wyne is currently residing in the city of Lahore....

    Ehsan Wyne, who believes in the philosophy of non-violence and non-sectarianism, aspired to become a lawyer and achieved his goal in 1967.He also participated in the movement against the military regime of General Ayub Khan in the same year and formally joined the National Awami Party (NAP) in 1968.

    He was impressed by the leadership of Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan, a leader of the Indian National Congress before the independence of Pakistan, who spent 33 years in jail as a freedom fighter, and his son Khan Abdul Wali Khan, late leader of the Awami National Party (ANP) who spent 16 years behind bars for the cause of democracy and provincial autonomy. Currently, Ehsan Wyne is the secretary general of ANP...

    Ehsan Wyne, who considers the feudal system the biggest problem in Pakistan, has been in jail numerous times due to his desire to bring about an end to feudalism and military operations in the different parts of the country, particularly in NWFP, Balochistan and FATA, for the restoration of democracy and civil rule, provision of maximum autonomy to the federal units of the countryand a permanent stoppage of military intervention in the political affairs of the country.

    He wants the young generation of today to obtain education and also read the autobiographies of famous personalities, no matter which ideology they follow or promote. In this regard, he particularly emphasises the need for reading the sermon of the Holy Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) he delivered at the time of his last pilgrimage and his biographies.
    Ehsan Wyne



    - The intellectual elite of Pakistan are fully aware of the need to apologize to Bengalis for the crimes of the Pakistani army and state.

    As a Bengali I would like to thank all those Pakistanis who on a personal level have expressed sorrow at the tragedy of 1971, however on a governmental level the state of Pakistan must apologize to Bangladesh.

    If the Pakistani government insists on America apologizing for 20+ Pakistani soldiers killed allegedly by accident what about 0.3 million to 0.5 million Bengalis massacred intentionally?

    Pak wants US to apologise for Salala - thenews.com.pk
    * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

  • #2
    Lmao, makes no difference
    "If you're not ready to die for it, put the word 'freedom' out of your vocabulary." -Malcolm X

    Comment


    • #3
      Pakistan has officially apologized for that discrimination. Move Forward!
      yao warokay ghwandi baagh ao pa khwa ye seen rawan!

      Comment


      • #4
        Heres a video of a porkistani leader insulting innocent Bangladeshi people I posted on facebook. Pls watch it https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v...type=2&theater
        Last edited by hamid954; 12-22-2013, 07:59 AM.
        Facebook Page name: All Afghans & Indians united against Porkistan ISI

        Link: facebook.com/AfghanInterestOnlyNoPuppetry

        Comment


        • #5
          Here is the video on Youtube.

          Former Prim Minister & President of Pakistan Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Calling Bangladeshi People Pig - YouTube


          Bhutto was later hung by the Pakistan army.

          Erdogan, Abdullah Al-Saud and other dictators should take some lessons from that.
          * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

          Comment


          • #6
            .. And Mujib Ur Rehman later killed as well.

            Politicians are the same all over the world. There are many reasons for the downfall of East Pakistan and the birth of Bangladesh.
            yao warokay ghwandi baagh ao pa khwa ye seen rawan!

            Comment


            • #7
              Causes and Implications of Deepening Pakistan-Bangladesh Tensions


              Posted: 12/28/2013 6:39 pm


              The execution of a top Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami (BJI) leader on December 12 on war crime charges and the Pakistani parliament's subsequent expression of "concern" over it have sparked an unprecedented diplomatic row between Dhaka and Islamabad. While the Bangladeshi Prime Minister Shiek Hasina "strongly condemned" Pakistan's interference in her country's domestic affairs, hundreds of Bengali veterans of the 1971 War of Independence and enraged young nationalists asked their government to cut off diplomatic ties with Islamabad.

              The Dhaka protesters, while attempting to besiege the Pakistani High Commission, were stopped by the security guards although they managed to burn Pakistan's flag and the effigies of prominent leaders. Bangladesh also summoned Pakistan's High Commissioner, to protest the resolution against a controversial execution that evokes deep emotions in both South Asian Muslim nations.

              The 65-year-old Abdul Kader Mullah, BJI's deputy secretary general, was accused of mass murder, rape and collaboration with the Pakistani army during the country's liberation movement. Formerly known as East Pakistan, Bangladesh, backed by India, fought a nine-month long war with Pakistan which was described by Princeton University Professor Gary J. Bass as "bloodier than Bosnia" in his revealing book The Blood Telegram.

              In 2009, Bangladesh constituted an International Crimes Tribunal to identify and investigate people who aided the Pakistani military and its local proxies in war crimes against Bengalis who fought for a separate homeland.

              According to some estimates, three million people were killed during the Bangladesh movement. Charged with supporting the Pakistan army in committing war crimes, the BJI has faced the heat of the Tribunal's decisions. In February 2013, the Tribunal sentenced the Jamaat's chief Delwar Hossain Sayeedi to death. His execution triggered nationwide protests that killed more than a hundred people. In August, the Supreme Court declared the Jammat illegal. The BJI, which is an ally of the opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP), blames the ruling Awami League government of "repression on the opposition" in order to impose "a one-party rule practiced in the mid-1970s."

              Maqbul Ahmed, BJI's acting chief, recently accused the ruling party of practicing "unbridled torture upon members of the opposition" and appealed to "our foreign friends" to raise their voice against the government's "subversive" activities against the opposition. Human Rights Watch (HRW) has also criticized Dhaka over "fair trial concerns" in the execution of opposition leaders although the New York-based watchdog says it supports accountability for the "horrific crimes" committed during the 1971 war.

              "Hanging Mollah on the basis of retroactive legislation and then denying him the right to appeal against this sentence is a grave violation of his fundamental rights," said Brad Adams, HRW's Asia Director.

              Bangladesh has recently been engulfed with widespread political tensions and violence ahead of next month's parliamentary elections.

              The December 16 resolution in the Pakistani legislature by the Jammat-e-Islami that was supported by the ruling Pakistan Muslim League of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif coincided with the exact date when Bangladesh separated from Pakistan in 1971.

              Imran Khan, head of the right-leaning Pakistan Justice Movement, billed Mullah as innocent and described charges against him as false. Pakistan's interior minister Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan termed the execution as "judicial murder." He remembered Mullah as "patriotic to pre-1971 Pakistan." The Interior Minister warned Dhaka to avoid reviving the wounds of 1971.

              On the contrary, Faheem Haider, a New York based Bangladesh analyst and writer, says the day-to-day politics in Bangladesh is actually about resurrecting 1971.

              He says Pakistan not only intervened in the domestic affairs of Bangladesh but also seemed to suggest that the country and its people should forget 1971 and move forward.
              "The people of the two countries will never forget 1971," he states, "Pakistanis are often described as caricatures in Bangladesh as those who want to have back a fulsome, whole Pakistan."

              Mr. Haider says the resolution passed in Pakistan's National Assembly lit a fire and those parties in Bangladesh who could use some anti-Pakistan, entirely pro-nationalist, historic sentiments, fanned that lit fire into flames.

              Influential Bangladesh newspaper Daily Star furiously reacted to the Pakistani officials' statements in an editorial on December 19:

              "We are surprised, shocked and outraged," said the newspaper, and reiterated the popular demand for the "long overdue" apology from the Pakistani government for the "genocide against Bengali people".

              Daily Star's demand is consistent with the government's official position. In 2012, the then foreign minister of Bangladesh Dipu Moni told her Pakistani counterpart Hina Rabbani Khar in Dhaka that Pakistan should apologize for "war crimes" against her people. Pakistan, on its part, has repeatedly suggested that the two countries should bury the past and "move forward."

              Within Pakistan, there is little public awareness about the actual causes of the country's disintegration in 1971. The politically powerful military, which is accused of war crimes, has cleverly deflected attention from these allegations. According to the military's version of the history, the Hindu-majority India, Pakistan's "archrival," conspired to break the Muslim nation.

              In July 1972, the Pakistani government formed a judicial inquiry into the causes of the disintegration of the country. Named after the Supreme Court Chief Justice who led the investigations, the findings of the Hamoodur Rahman Commission were not made public for at least three decades as it, according to the leaks in the media, castigated the Pakistani military for the East Pakistan debacle.

              In July 2002, Pakistan's former military dictator General Pervez Musharraf visited Dhaka and offered his country's "sincere regrets' but did not offer an unconditional apology.
              Farahnaz Ispahani, a senior leader of the Pakistan People's Party (PPP) and a former parliamentarian, says the Pakistan military and the right wing forces have never allowed a full apology. The PPP, along with two other secular parties, the Awami National Party and the Muthida Quami Movement (MQM), did not support the pro-Mullah resolution.

              "What should be done but will not be done is an immediate apology to Bangladesh," she observes, "it would be the correct way to diffuse the situation diplomatically as the current government was major backer of the Molla resolution."

              Ispahani, currently a Public Policy Scholar at Washington DC-based Woodrow Wilson Center for International Scholars, says the PPP opposed the resolution because it was "not fitting for Pakistan to interfere in the domestic affairs of a sovereign country."

              Why didn't the PPP apologize when it was in power from 2008 to 2012?
              Ispahani, who also served as former President Asif Ali Zardari's media adviser, says the PPP did not have "sufficient political support" from other political parties.

              "The PPP did not have a majority in the parliament even when it headed the coalition government from 2008-2012," she admits, "The three parties which constitute the moderate and pluralistic voices in Pakistani politics, even together have not had a majority in the National Assembly."

              The parliamentary resolution might be a last-ditch effort by Islamabad to deny perturbing portions of its history but Pakistan seems to be changing as dissenting voices have begun to make surprising inroads in the mainstream national debate. Until recently, the conservative Urdu media significantly contributed in instilling a distorted and misleading history among the semi-literate Pakistanis. However, alternative opinions that support an apology are replacing and dominating older narratives.

              On December 19, Hasan Mujtaba, a prominent journalist, made a passionate appeal to Islamabad to apologize to the Bengalis in an article published in Jang, Pakistan's most circulated Urdu language newspaper.

              Mujtaba, who also reports for the BBC Urdu from New York, said an apology had become every Pakistani's 'national obligation'

              "Since the Holocaust, we committed the worst massacre and genocide in the human history in East Pakistan," he argued, "the memories of 1971 will not disappear unless we apologize."

              Pakistanis are furtively observing the ongoing trails in Bangladesh. While some believe Dhaka is doing the right thing by separating religion from politics, others believe Pakistan should apologize first and then move forward. The Dhaka trials have also emboldened voices that now call for a Bangladesh-style ban on the Pakistani Jammat-e-Islami. Ironically, Syed Haider Farooq Maududi, a son of Abul Ala Maududi, the founder of the Pakistani Jammat, has emerged as an ardent proponent of banning the Jammat in Pakistan.

              "I don't understand why they are putting the Jammat on trial in Bangladesh," he told Hum Shehri magazine, "the trials should actually take place in Pakistan where the actual Jammat is based.



              Causes and Implications of Deepening Pakistan-Bangladesh Tensions | Malik Siraj Akbar
              * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

              Comment


              • #8
                I believe we should apologize

                becaue i want Pakistan to have incredible trade ties with Bangladesh reaching atleast 30-35billion dollars within this decade
                "[B][SIZE="3"]Seer Speen Wazeer[/SIZE][/B]"

                Comment

                Working...
                X