Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

what is the exact reason of hate between salafis and sufis?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • what is the exact reason of hate between salafis and sufis?

    so what is the exact reason of hate between salafis and sufis?

    Can anyone list the reasons

    The thing is I have friends from both of these divisions, but my friends are moderate, meaning they are not extremist sufis or extremist salafis, to me both of them make sense and both have good arguments. It's just they still don't like each other, i am not sure why.
    Last edited by Karachi; 12-02-2011, 08:29 PM.

  • #2
    The reasons for salfi's hate towards sufis are worshipping graves, associating partners with God, asking others beside God, not having comprehensive knowledge of Quran and hadith, not quoting Quran and hadith but most the times quoting others etc.

    The reasons for sufi's hate towards salafis are not having love for prophet Muhammad peace be upon him, not having eman in him, not having respect for him that he deserve.
    not talking about love and affection but all the time a rigid behaviour in every matter unnecessarily. not having love for sufis. not endorsing sufis. wrong interpretation of the holy Quran ect etc.

    It is my understanding... whats yours.

    Comment


    • #3
      ^ thats true, that;s the general idea i had, however if those two sentences are the main reason for division, they are only done by the extremist on the two sides. Like I said both my friends are moderate Sufi and Salafi and none of them believe in this kind of stuff

      Comment


      • #4
        Salafis (neo Salafis) have extrem hate for shias
        I as muslim learning from the four madhabs have the same feelings beside that,
        Salafis (neo Salafis ) are to extrem in regarding certain issues and every single act of the sufis they consider as either shirk,bidah or compeletely haram.


        Sufis

        in contrary feel endangered by the neo salafis,they hold more faster to their deviant teachings and make propaganda against salafis and neo salafis.

        they use fabricated ahadiths to explain their deviant beliefs,

        they use the pretext they are peaceful to other religions and sects for example are allied with shia and share some beliefs from them.

        sufis for me are a mix between shiaism and other deviant believes and using sunnah to cover themselves.
        High achievement always takes place in the framework of high expectation.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by emkhan View Post
          The reasons for salfi's hate towards sufis are worshipping graves, associating partners with God, asking others beside God, not having comprehensive knowledge of Quran and hadith, not quoting Quran and hadith but most the times quoting others etc.
          we don't hate them we hate thier stupidity, thier acts of wrongs and still being insistent they are right while can't prove thier rightness.


          The reasons for sufi's hate towards salafis are not having love for prophet Muhammad peace be upon him, not having eman in him, not having respect for him that he deserve.
          not talking about love and affection but all the time a rigid behaviour in every matter unnecessarily. not having love for sufis. not endorsing sufis. wrong interpretation of the holy Quran ect etc.
          WTH BROTHER?
          how the hell can you say we don't love the prophet? and dont repsect him as much he deserve?
          we are the one who fight for islam and for what the denmark did in all the islamic places.
          there is no such things as sufi in the prophet or sahaba time.
          THERE WAS NEVER SOMETHING SUFFI.
          It is my understanding... whats yours.
          i see u shouldnt believe this.
          Last edited by sunni; 12-08-2011, 05:52 PM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by sunni View Post



            WTH BROTHER?
            how the hell can you say we don't love the prophet? and dont repsect him as much he deserve?
            we are the one who fight for islam and for what the denmark did in all the islamic places.
            there is no such things as sufi in the prophet or sahaba time.
            THERE WAS NEVER SOMETHING SUFFI.

            i see u shouldnt believe this.
            Brother, this is not what I feel but this is what they say...
            They love they have for our prophet is different than salafis. The emaan that they have in prophet is very different than salfis.
            I don't want to go into the details but I have been very close with them and I know every little about them and their thinking about salafis.
            I don't endorse their thinking but I just followed the thread...

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by emkhan View Post
              Brother, this is not what I feel but this is what they say...
              They love they have for our prophet is different than salafis. The emaan that they have in prophet is very different than salfis.
              I don't want to go into the details but I have been very close with them and I know every little about them and their thinking about salafis.
              I don't endorse their thinking but I just followed the thread...
              oh i see.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by sunni View Post
                oh i see.
                Wrong. OIC

                Comment

                Working...
                X