Tweet
Are Actions Part of Imaan? Can someone become a kaafir through deeds?
Bismillah,
As Salaamu Alaykum,
In the previous topic we established that there are those who believe that if you abandon a particular deed in Islam, you are still a Muslim. People believe that the one who doesn't pray is not a kafir.
I disagree. Because from what I know, if you do not pray, you become a kafir. And the evidence for that were posted in the previous thread.
However, we've reached a point where the discussion turned to the core of the issue.
The core of the issue is belief that Imaan is in actions of the heart, actions of the tongue and actions of the limbs.
Some claim that actions of the limbs are not part of Imaan. They also believe that you can still be a Muslim if don't have any deeds.
So in order to clarify this matter, I suggest that all of you who hold different opinions regarding this matter, present your proofs from Quran and Sunnah.
If I happen to hold an opinion which is false, then I am glad to learn from you.
As Salaamu Alaykum,
In the previous topic we established that there are those who believe that if you abandon a particular deed in Islam, you are still a Muslim. People believe that the one who doesn't pray is not a kafir.
I disagree. Because from what I know, if you do not pray, you become a kafir. And the evidence for that were posted in the previous thread.
However, we've reached a point where the discussion turned to the core of the issue.
The core of the issue is belief that Imaan is in actions of the heart, actions of the tongue and actions of the limbs.
Some claim that actions of the limbs are not part of Imaan. They also believe that you can still be a Muslim if don't have any deeds.
So in order to clarify this matter, I suggest that all of you who hold different opinions regarding this matter, present your proofs from Quran and Sunnah.
If I happen to hold an opinion which is false, then I am glad to learn from you.
Comment