Zakir Naik rejects Two Nation Thoery- Creation of Pakistan

[emkhan]

there are some disputes between muslims and hindus but my last trip to india, i stayed mostly, in muslim owned and run hotels and met the head of the andaman islands (which is controlled by india)tourism board. she is a muslim. many of the shops i frequented were owned by muslims and mosques were calling to prayer over loudspeakers.
i am not suggesting that indians control any other country than india but i dispute your claims emkhan.

you are not saying that but indirectly you are actually you are saying. Don't be so clever. We better know who to live with.

[khushal]

Emkhan has no claims. He has no idea what is reality. He only knows what the pakistani military has brainwashed him with. If the 2 nation theory was in fact something that has some sense, he would not be in Britain because according to him, Muslims can not live with others and hindus can not live with others.

He has no idea what he is talking about. No sane person can say that human beings can not live together because of simple difference.

[khushal]

i told you so many times. Here, i am on student visa and very soon i will leave. I am not under british rule. but back home if i was with india i had my whole life with hindus and i had to be ruled by the hindus.

So what you are saying is that it is OK to study under British rule but not OK to study under muslim pakistani rule or under hindu india rule.

[emkhan]

Emkhan has no claims. He has no idea what is reality. He only knows what the pakistani military has brainwashed him with. If the 2 nation theory was in fact something that has some sense, he would not be in Britain because according to him, Muslims can not live with others and hindus can not live with others.

He has no idea what he is talking about. No sane person can say that human beings can not live together because of simple difference.

we better know who to live with... If you like india why don't you migrate to india ? I don't know why some guys of this forum are dying for india ?
I am afraid india is funding some of you guys...

[faye]

you are not saying that but indirectly you are actually you are saying. Don't be so clever. We better know who to live with.

why would i say what i said? i don't need to bulls*** people. if you are assuming that is what I do, then perhaps it is what YOU do. i am sick of people on this forum making dumb and false accusations against me.
i would like to see india rule itself, aghanistan rule itself and pakistan rule itself, all without the interferences from each other or western countries. so stick that in you pipe and smoke it

[emkhan]

So what you are saying is that it is OK to study under British rule but not OK to study under muslim pakistani rule or under hindu india rule.

i think there is nothing to study in British or India or anywhere else...

[khushal]

i think there is nothing to study in British or India or anywhere else...

So if there is nothing to study in Britain, what are you doing there, to go to the local pub and BS with the Brits.

[emkhan]

i said there is nothing wrong in studying in britain or india

[khushal]

i said there is nothing wrong in studying in britain or india

You did not say that in the previous post but thanks for the correction.
Let continue.
So what your saying is that it is OK to study under Hindu Rule but not OK to live under Hindu rule. Did I get you right this time.

[khashayar]

^ yes that is correct....anymore questions put them through to my secretary

[emkhan]

You did not say that in the previous post but thanks for the correction.
Let continue.
So what your saying is that it is OK to study under Hindu Rule but not OK to live under Hindu rule. Did I get you right this time.

yes right.

[khashayar]

^ I just said that.

[khushal]

yes right.

Did Jinnah preach this in his 2 nation theory emkhan. Did he tell the Pakistani's to get their education from the Hindus and hate them at the same time.

[khashayar]

^ why do you love Hindo so much? Are you hindo?

[khushal]

^ why do you love Hindo so much? Are you hindo?

Your a bit immature to understand the flawed logic behind the 2 nation theory. I am merely defending Zakir Naiks statement about how wrong it was for the partition of the subcontinent. It caused the suffering of millions of people muslim, hindu and sikhs, and that suffering is continuing to this day. You and Emkhan have been brainwashed so mush by the PAkistani establishment that it will take years for you to realize that the partition was not devised by Hindus or muslims from within the subcontinent but by an outside force.

Why dont you ask Zakir Naik, is he a secrete hindu for talking against the partition.