doubt naik?

[king-zazai]

YouTube - Refutation Of Zakir Naik by Abu Khadeejah


just wondering who here is actually with or against naik???


and plz no non-religous or people who are out of the fold of normal Islamic beliefs reply to this thanks....

[king-zazai]

on a personal note i used to be a BIGGG fan of Dr.zakir naik and as time passed and i learned more and more about the deen of allah i dont agree on what he says and the things he does sometimes and now i dont listen to him

his knowledge compared with other sheiks is no comparision

[Notorious Pashtana]

just wondering who here is actually with or against naik???

and plz no non-religous or people who are out of the fold of normal Islamic beliefs reply to this thanks....

What do you mean by people who are out of the fold of normal islamic beliefs?

I don't think Naik is a bad guy, I don't think he's useless or should be disregarded either, but i also don't think he's a scholar or is anywhere near knowledgable as compared to some other aalims.

Initially, I too thought he was good (mostly because of his rapid quoting style he took from Ahmed Deedat) but after really paying attention to him i do have issues with his methods, his style, and many of his thoughts. he preaches the "middle way" but comes out with some pretty major extremes. he blows his own trumpet (a lot), and more importantly, he is very repetitive. after sitting through a couple of his Q&A's there is nothing new to learn from him, it's all the same stuff, same examples, same quotations, even the same questions being asked over and over again! does no one honestly have a new question to ask him??? listening to him is like deja vu, he's just memorised heaps of stuff and has put it on repeat. a very desi-style-ratta-maar.

I don't believe anything that doesn't make sense to me, he has said stuff that hasn't made sense to me and he's failed to explain it appropriately, so I have disregarded those bits he's preached, the rest, i'm ok with, but no one seems to stop him when he's wrong or extreme, nor does anyone even question his method of preaching. a couple of times i could have sworn the questions asked were clearly staged, they fit right in where they had to, and even a non-sense reply is always accepted??? and no one is allowed to ask for clarification either??? he is totally staged.

[Michin Khel]

zazai you are still underage . For God sake dont listen to your arab shiekhs, use your peanat size brain.

[Michin Khel]

What do you mean by people who are out of the fold of normal islamic beliefs?

This kid wants some e-fights. Last year he came and started harassing certain members because of their beliefs.
King zazai you are not even a pashtun. Stop spreading sheikh non-sense here.

[emkhan]

yes such people always look for small issues and create issues...
Let him do his great job... why creating hurdles in his ways...
wake up those who are sitting idle and doing nothing..

[Michin Khel]

Atleast he has converted many non-muslims directly or indirectly to islam. Zazai sahab what are your achievements?

[emkhan]

his achiements are only to criticize other and finds ways how to get others down by using false propaganda mind...

[Dukemina]

Stop the personal attacks. *rollseyes*

Personally, I think Zakir Naik has done an outstanding job in regards to Muslims living in India. He has given them a platform to practice their religion - and that too, not a bad one. It is wise of him to deal with people according to their background and he does a fairly decent job, way way better than many others. Because he doesn't live in the west he probably wouldn't connect with us as it wouldn't be so beneficial to us and our lifestyle.

[king-zazai]

What do you mean by people who are out of the fold of normal islamic beliefs?

I don't think Naik is a bad guy, I don't think he's useless or should be disregarded either, but i also don't think he's a scholar or is anywhere near knowledgable as compared to some other aalims.

Initially, I too thought he was good (mostly because of his rapid quoting style he took from Ahmed Deedat) but after really paying attention to him i do have issues with his methods, his style, and many of his thoughts. he preaches the "middle way" but comes out with some pretty major extremes. he blows his own trumpet (a lot), and more importantly, he is very repetitive. after sitting through a couple of his Q&A's there is nothing new to learn from him, it's all the same stuff, same examples, same quotations, even the same questions being asked over and over again! does no one honestly have a new question to ask him??? listening to him is like deja vu, he's just memorised heaps of stuff and has put it on repeat. a very desi-style-ratta-maar.

I don't believe anything that doesn't make sense to me, he has said stuff that hasn't made sense to me and he's failed to explain it appropriately, so I have disregarded those bits he's preached, the rest, i'm ok with, but no one seems to stop him when he's wrong or extreme, nor does anyone even question his method of preaching. a couple of times i could have sworn the questions asked were clearly staged, they fit right in where they had to, and even a non-sense reply is always accepted??? and no one is allowed to ask for clarification either??? he is totally staged.

i mean people like luffy who dont have a clue about islam and there aqeedeh is way of and are lost astray people like that who just waist peoples time and can never be serious about anything

dont want there useless posts

[Mujib]

This is not a refutation, but a rant that advocates one particular side in a conflict between two extremist groups. Both groups should be avoided.

Zakir Naik is a great speaker when it comes to polemics. But he is not a scholar and cannot be relied upon to answer questions related to sacred law or beliefs.

[کیش]

Who are the "scholars" who know more then Zakir Naik?

[Alchemist]

Who are the "scholars" who know more then Zakir Naik?

YouTube - Sin City -Sheikh Sulaiman Moola


YouTube - Ways to Paradise - Imam Siraj Wahhaj

YouTube - Music, Art, Photography - Contemporary Issues Bilal Philips

YouTube - Message to muslims in the westen world 1(Salman al Awda)

YouTube - sheikh: Ali gomaa Forty Nawawi Episode5

YouTube - Shaykh Habib Ali Jifri - Traditional Islam vs. Modernist Islam

YouTube - Brotherhood in Islam - Abu Usamah at-Thahabi


And my sheikh:

YouTube - SH. Said Rageah - Never give up



zakir naik himself has admitted that he is not a sheikh, or an Alim. He has not studied Islam in any type of Islamic institution or taught by any Sheikh.

[کیش]

You don't need to be taught in any Islamic school, or by a sheik. I have taught myself like Zakir Naik has.

Would you put Anwar Al-awaki in that list? Isn't he a Sheik?

[emkhan]

Who are the "scholars" who know more then Zakir Naik?

Mujib is a big scholar... sitting in his room and posting messages on PF.