Questions and challenges to the statements of OSHO

[شمله ور خراساني]

Pure rhetoric and generalization.

When the house needs to be cleaned call 'Bilal', when the mosque needs to be cleaned call 'Bilal'. But when it is the time to decide the kingship one of the claimants is the father-in-law, the other is his son-in-law. Where is 'Bilal' now? Bilal, was and remained, a slave.

What equality.

Sangar brother are you aware of how the Caliphate was won by the alliance between the traders (Ummayahs) and the political front of Umar and AbuBakr RA? How the Caliphate passed to the Ummayads at the third time of asking? How the Caliphate was nothing nut theological aristocracy?

Even before that the major decisions were always decided by the infuential people of the tribal confederations and those with connections and resources.

Stop reading anit-Islamic propaganda written by kufaar!

Islam was completed when the last verses were revealed where Allah said that religion is perfected and he completed his favor upon humanity.

What the Umayads did and did not is of no religious significance.

[Badlun]

[QUOTE=Sangar;24941]
Neither Qur'an nor Hadith does prescribe a specific form of government and bureaucracy.

Few things that Islam does advocate are certain rules and morals. QUOTE]

This is what I always insist that islam is only a religion(faith+worship+morality) nothing more than that.

[Badlun]

Islam was completed when the last verses were revealed where Allah said that religion is perfected and he completed his favor upon humanity.

What the Umayads did and did not is of no religious significance.

It means we are now understabnding each other. What you say here entails in making Islam only a religion.

[شمله ور خراساني]

You are deliberately trying to extract the wrong message from my statements to get away with your previous posts.

Don't do that.