Is it only the Job of Pashtuns to defend Afghanistan?

[Abdali]

Why aren't Tajiks,Uzbek helping Pashtuns defend Afghanistan?

Why is it only the duty of the Pashtuns to defend the honor and pride of Afghanistan?

We have been defending this country from long even before Alexander the great, we have always been successful now we are up against 40plus countries again , alone and our very own 'Tajik,Hazara, Uzbek' brothers are not helping us, in fact taking advantage of the US.


Do you think when the Americans leave, the Pashtuns will release their anger on them for betraying the Pashtun South?

I just find it strange how they claim Afghanistan to be also their country yet have never had the guts to defend against invaders while Pashtuns have been doing it since day one.


Seems very cowardlike but lets keep this civil.*

[IamDZJ]

let me guess...because by ur definition, only pashtons are doing the actual job of defending afghanistan. mind you, none of the wars in afghanistan were or are being fought by pashtun army alone. get your facts right.
more than 60% members of the current army in afghanistan are tajiks. truth is, you people are to selfish to see anything else rather than your self. afghanistan does not only belong to pashtuns and no way in hell were they always fighting for it alone.
you should be ashamed of your selves for denying every other ethnic group in afghanistan the loss they went through over the years.
you can't fight the wars inside yourselves. what would selfish idiots like you do for the country?

[IamDZJ]

^Rofl.

you are funny girl.


the Afghan army is presently not defending Afghanistan at all.

That is why Pashtuns are not joining.


It is a clear fact and well established fact that.


Pashtuns defeated the soviets.
Not the Tajiks.

Pashtuns defeated the British 3x
Not the Tajiks.

Pashtuns are up in war against 40 countries.
Not the Tajiks.


Pashtuns ruled Persia(Hotaki from Kandahar)
Not the Tajiks.

Pashtuns ruled India (Ahmad Shah Baba from Kandahar)
Not the Tajiks.


The USA admits it's the Pashtuns they are up against in the war.
NOT THE TAJIKS.


If you can't admit that the Pashtuns have primarily defended Afghanistan, there is a BIG BIG problem and you should do some research.


When the Pashtuns defeated the British the British told Afghans)Pashtuns) that they are martial race.

who gave you the right to speak in our personal matters?

[IamDZJ]

you were sold off with the durand line. had the thieves of pakistan not murdered Dr. Najib you would be free by now but for now you are doing great as a pakistani slave. you are a brother to your other fellow thieves. you are nothing to me.

[Master Khan]

^Rofl.

you are funny girl.


the Afghan army is presently not defending Afghanistan at all.

That is why Pashtuns are not joining.


It is a clear fact and well established fact that.


Pashtuns defeated the soviets.
Not the Tajiks.

Pashtuns defeated the British 3x
Not the Tajiks.

Pashtuns are up in war against 40 countries.
Not the Tajiks.


Pashtuns ruled Persia(Hotaki from Kandahar)
Not the Tajiks.

Pashtuns ruled India (Ahmad Shah Baba from Kandahar)
Not the Tajiks.


The USA admits it's the Pashtuns they are up against in the war.
NOT THE TAJIKS.


If you can't admit that the Pashtuns have primarily defended Afghanistan, there is a BIG BIG problem and you should do some research.


When the Pashtuns defeated the British the British told Afghans)Pashtuns) that they are martial race.


haven't you watched Rambo movies lol all you see is Pashtuns of Afghanistan defeating Russia all you hear is Pashto, not dari.

Yeah thats true.
Pashtuns are fought for this country all the time.
I never heard anything about a tajik fighting against America or anything.

[Mayana]

let me guess...because by ur definition, only pashtons are doing the actual job of defending afghanistan. mind you, none of the wars in afghanistan were or are being fought by pashtun army alone. get your facts right.
more than 60% members of the current army in afghanistan are tajiks. truth is, you people are to selfish to see anything else rather than your self. afghanistan does not only belong to pashtuns and no way in hell were they always fighting for it alone.
you should be ashamed of your selves for denying every other ethnic group in afghanistan the loss they went through over the years.
you can't fight the wars inside yourselves. what would selfish idiots like you do for the country?

Agreed.

You think only Pashtuns have made sacrifices for Afghanistan? Get yo facts straight.
EVERY single ethnic group has made sacrifices for Afghanistan. I'm sorry to break it to you but unlike you want to think, Afghanistan is not only the Pashtuns country. It has citizens from all different backgrounds and it is their HOME as well and they DO protect it unlike others who sit here and talk beautiful about "Afghanistan kho da Pashtano Watan day"

You think Pashtuns were out there fighting every invader and Tajiks/Uzbaks/Hazara were in their homes drinking Chai? PLEASE, get out of Lala-land.

[IamDZJ]

DaZahrooJam,

The fact that you failed to respond to my points shows you know deep down Pashtuns defended Afghanistan against all invaders while other ethnic groups spectated and wished bad.

Even Ahmad Shah Masood(Thank God he died)allowed his people to talk bad about Pashtuns.


Stop talking about Pakistan I am a proud ethnic Afghan and I love my motherland. You should be thanking the Pashtuns for defeating al those countries rather then you speaking Pashto you would have been speaking Russian or Greek or something.


larobar yaw Afghan

She just left. Im sure she has alot to say when she comes back so good luck lol.

[Mayana]

Mayana,
it's a well established fact that it was the Pashtuns who defended Afghanistan from it's invader.


Even the British admit this. British admits it was the Pashtuns who defeated them 3 times.

It was Pashtuns who fought the soviets.

Show me proof that Tajiks supported them.

Show me proof that Tajiks defeated the british.



Even right now, show me proof that Tajiks are defending Afghanistan from 40 plus countries.



It was the Pashtuns Mayana, It was them. Do some research,please.

How about you show me proof that that is a well-established fact and that no other ethnic group in Afghanistan has done a thing against invaders?
Sha?

Sha.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Mayana,
it's a well established fact that it was the Pashtuns who defended Afghanistan from it's invader.


Even the British admit this. British admits it was the Pashtuns who defeated them 3 times.

It was Pashtuns who fought the soviets.

Show me proof that Tajiks supported them.

Show me proof that Tajiks defeated the british.



Even right now, show me proof that Tajiks are defending Afghanistan from 40 plus countries.



It was the Pashtuns Mayana, It was them. Do some research,please.

Yes it is true that the Afghans who were fighting britain were pashtuns from both sides of the durand line. And most of the fighting is in those areas. However, since I am happy you said lar au bar yaw afghan, when do you plan to join these brave pashtuns in their liberation from these nato countries plus their allies (which pakistan is a vital part of). Bottom line will you also defend Afghanistan in the tradition of the pashtun people?

[IamDZJ]

DaZahrooJam,

The fact that you failed to respond to my points shows you know deep down Pashtuns defended Afghanistan against all invaders while other ethnic groups spectated and wished bad.

Even Ahmad Shah Masood(Thank God he died)allowed his people to talk bad about Pashtuns.


Stop talking about Pakistan I am a proud ethnic Afghan and I love my motherland. You should be thanking the Pashtuns for defeating al those countries rather then you speaking Pashto you would have been speaking Russian or Greek or something.


larobar yaw Afghan

i refuse to reason with someone who denies half of my nation and then claims to be a true afghan who is logged in to a discussion forum as a pakistani. okay?
you better thank God he died. if he was alive, he would have kicked off ur hind all the way back to where it belongs. rather than dividing us, worry about your own position and situation.

[IamDZJ]

I am a proud Pakistani but also a proud Afghan

no such a thing

[Baran]

ya halaka pakistania che posh she che warsara jawab nishta no chup keega tre ..

sa la yai gusa kayee..

haqeeqat bia hom haqeeqat v ..ho sook tre starge pata ki..

lolx

[IamDZJ]

When you are unaware and uneducated, everything looks blind.

you need some one to slap you right back in to reality. how can a pakistani be an afghan?

[BLS_1919v2.0]

you need some one to slap you right back in to reality. how can a pakistani be an afghan?

DaZahroJaam you can be both...as pakistan is not an identity, rather a federation of different nations. By your logic how can a tajik from Afghanistan be a tajik, since tajikistan is north of Amu? Every Pashtun is an afghan...I agree that those who are disloyal to afghan watan for whatever other nationality should choose their words carefully, however at the same time we call such people traitors. Za da pakistan tharffdaaree na kaoma ao na mae khwakh dae pakistan state, kho khabaraa ba safaa kaoo.

Khabaraa raaghla on who did what where, well then we need to ask ourselves a key question, what do we gain from all of this? If say we fight for another 40 years, will we gain anything? Do we have an endgoal in mind?

[Baran]

there are 3 million pakistani afghans..they are afghani and they are pakistani.

u can ask them :P