Pakistan and Afghanistan must become one country

[erlangner]

Da saeed khan ghareeb khabar na de, che dunya pa kom dang walara da. Saeed khana democracy dasay na chaleegi. Lagga dunya ogoora, gani bia ba germnay ao france yao mulk wo, zakka che kha democracy pakkay da, kho walay na yao zae kegi, zakka che nasal da yao bal na juda de.

[Shehbaz Khan]

When you are better with your parents and family Pashtuns will be better with the poeple of their own nation, this is a simple logic. The cause of our worst condition lies mainly due to our division. Afghanistan is our fatherland but the land of the people of Northern and Southern Pakhtunkhwa was forcefully made part of the British India by the british. Our land being part of Pakistan is the continuation of that British created division. And it is also a simple thing that this division not only caused the devastation of Azad Afghanistan but we too here suffered severly and the our sufferings grow day by day. So return to our own true history is inevitable if we have any wish to get back our lost identity, our pirde, our autonomy as nation and to live a peaceful and prosperous life.

__________________________________________________ __________


This logic is not that simple as you are making it .. Ok We suffered because we lost our father why you suffered? When I say we need for a united Pak-Afghan state is that the mutual benefit of both will be seen by a common federation and hence even this new State will emerge as a bigger power in the World

[Saeed Khan]

Khyal Jana wrora manam that we are all in imperfect conditions. It was due to happen because of many forces played their dirty role in the region. If we succeeded in driving out foreign interference and reach to a point to settle our differences then i am as high optimistic as K2 to see our people prosperous.

[Shehbaz Khan]

DO you think by unifying both, you will get a piece of bread better than today. Are you sure that this special mentality in pakistan will sit aside and will say ok, now eat your bread. What will be the base for this unification? What is the common between the two? Then if your answer is religion then why the pushed away bengladesh? Why they dont make such an offer to Iran? The answer is they want to occupy and make a colony, seem impossible.
__________________________________________________ _______
No but that mentality will not even sit aside when you will snatch the whole NWFP/Pakhtunkhwa from them .. The base for such unification will be the mutual benefit of both the countries and their people .. We all know how Afghans were welcomed by the people of Pakistan so this is will be the main reason for this unification .. The common interest of both the countries !!

[khyaal]

This logic is not that simple as you are making it .. Ok We suffered because we lost our father why you suffered? When I say we need for a united Pak-Afghan state is that the mutual benefit of both will be seen by a common federation and hence even this new State will emerge as a bigger power in the World

I don't think you read posts carefully. Just like you I too belong to Khyber Pakhtunkha and charsada district.

[Shehbaz Khan]

What you fail to realize as well is that Pakistan does not met Pashtun states pre requirements. We Pashtuns do not want to speak in Urdu, yes Urdu should be learned but our mother tongue Pashto should be given more importance.

If we get this Loy Pakistan or whatever its called Pashti will be on a further declination. What we need is a state that will work for betterment of Pashtun rights and Pashto language.

You are from Karachi, Karachi has the most Pashtuns in the world. How many Pashto schools do you have again? This is what I mean.
___________________________________________
We Pakhtuns don't want to speak Urdu .. If I agree with your thought than how are we gonna interact with the people of the world .. We don't want to speak urdu but we want to speak English :s
Pashtoon rights and Pukhtu is a language ..
Well Pakhtun rights are down to earth even in Afghanistan :s How many people are getting thier rights over there and moreover coming to the language ... Leave Karachi aside how many schools in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa with so called ANP you have got that teaches Pukhtu.. ?

I agree with you on that .. As the constitution of IRP allows all the provinces to choose thier language for literature .. It's we Pakhtuns who are not selecting pakhtu in KPK

[khyaal]

Khyal Jana wrora manam that we are all in imperfect conditions. It was due to happen because of many forces played their dirty role in the region. If we succeeded in driving out foreign interference and reach to a point to settle our differences then i am as high optimistic as K2 to see our people prosperous.

Malgaria you are too forgetful. You should have noticed that Pakistan is not just imperfect, it is a complete disaster for every nation. Just remember the history of Bengalis when there were no foreign forces in the region.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Rokhana wrora though with due respect Abul Kalam Azaad said this long time ago and Pakistan is still surviving though all the powers of the World are trying to break it down .. The Bangladesh senario was totally different I hope you won't quote that

[Saeed Khan]

Da saeed khan ghareeb khabar na de, che dunya pa kom dang walara da. Saeed khana democracy dasay na chaleegi. Lagga dunya ogoora, gani bia ba germnay ao france yao mulk wo, zakka che kha democracy pakkay da, kho walay na yao zae kegi, zakka che nasal da yao bal na juda de.

Za ghareeb kho da khabar yem che pa south africa ke torak ao speenak pa democracy ke wakht terawal shee nu bia dalta wale na.. ao za kho hairan da yam che Alhamdollilah zamong pakhtano kho pa har institution ke shta ao progress kawee ao ghat ghat businessmen dee pa Karache, islambad ap pa lahore ke nu bia da sa da domra geele de.. ka pa har shee khita ba achawoo.. laga guzara kawa kana manra

[Shehbaz Khan]

Khyaal wror jana this is what you thought may be you are right may be due to my childish attitude I may be missing many things
People living in one area can have difference of opinion

[khyaal]

We Pakhtuns don't want to speak Urdu .. If I agree with your thought than how are we gonna interact with the people of the world .. We don't want to speak urdu but we want to speak English :s
Pashtoon rights and Pukhtu is a language ..
Well Pakhtun rights are down to earth even in Afghanistan :s How many people are getting thier rights over there and moreover coming to the language ... Leave Karachi aside how many schools in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa with so called ANP you have got that teaches Pukhtu.. ?

I agree with you on that .. As the constitution of IRP allows all the provinces to choose thier language for literature .. It's we Pakhtuns who are not selecting pakhtu in KPK

You are talking of very very superficial issues, the real issues are far deeper.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Agreed To Saeed Brother .. We Pakhtuns are there in the Federal Govt .. We are in Govt in the two Provinces still monga gela mand yao ..

Actually we are not backward because Punjabis or someone else are eating us .. We are backward zaka che zamonga khpal ledaraaan khamaraan di aao zamonga weena kharsawi !! Zamonga haq khwri

[khyaal]

you just read Pir Rokhan's post and trace Pakistan's history along those lines, hope you will find clues to your naive questions. Apart from that you must know that Pashtun(afghans) are different people with a separate history from the people of Punjab and Sindh.

[Shehbaz Khan]

You are talking of very very superficial issues, the real issues are far deeper.

___________________

Wror jana this was a reply to another member .. Bring Forward the main issues

[khyaal]

Agreed To Saeed Brother .. We Pakhtuns are there in the Federal Govt .. We are in Govt in the two Provinces still monga gela mand yao ..

Actually we are not backward because Punjabis or someone else are eating us .. We are backward zaka che zamonga khpal ledaraaan khamaraan di aao zamonga weena kharsawi !! Zamonga haq khwri

Do you know that were just there in federal and provincial governements and state institutions with more rights under the British. My friend read some history first.