Lahore mastermind Qari Zubair killed in Pakistan shelling

[Zaadgaan Kabul]

He will pretty obvious point out Pashtun discrimination against non Pashtuns.

You see all these Afghanistani fanboys share a common pattern and behavior. I mean they are right when they claim Pashtun rulers were a bunch of uneducated tribal fascists. And the are right when they claim our current relationship with Porkistan was screwed by Pashtuns. But they exaggerate and play all the time the victim card.

Being a poor victim has always been a Hazara trick. Now even many Tajiks and Pashtuns are adopting this annoying attitude. The truth is Tajiks, despite being banned from the higher political post since the creation of this fake country called Afghanistan, we ran all the administration, culture and economy. So I don't see why we should be bitc*ing all the day long.

Listen, you moron, if you do not know me or my person, do not talk in my place. In Afghanistan, everyone suffered. From Aymaks to Zazais and Zadrans. Pashtuns were and are the most suffering victims in the last 200 years. If you monkey do not know what I mean then just keep silent or ask like a cultured person for more information but do not talk in the place of anyone garbaging the space with your little tolo news information or tolo history knowledge. Pashtuns had no ''Pashtun'' rulers, but foreign and alien people pretending to be Pashtuns. While one family was taking advantage from this british game, 99,98% of Pashtuns suffered. Karzai and Ghani are also self-claimed Pashtuns yet Pashtuns are dying everyday, raped, killed, dishonoured, robbed and plundered and in some regions even enslaved and forced into prostitution. So pleeeease, do not comment in my place or direct your talks to me if you don´t know what I mean!!! please

[Firdousi]

Listen, you moron, if you do not know me or my person, do not talk in my place. In Afghanistan, everyone suffered. From Aymaks to Zazais and Zadrans. Pashtuns were and are the most suffering victims in the last 200 years. If you monkey do not know what I mean then just keep silent or ask like a cultured person for more information but do not talk in the place of anyone garbaging the space with your little tolo news information or tolo history knowledge. Pashtuns had no ''Pashtun'' rulers, but foreign and alien people pretending to be Pashtuns. While one family was taking advantage from this british game, 99,98% of Pashtuns suffered. Karzai and Ghani are also self-claimed Pashtuns yet Pashtuns are dying everyday, raped, killed, dishonoured, robbed and plundered and in some regions even enslaved and forced into prostitution. So pleeeease, do not comment in my place or direct your talks to me if you don´t know what I mean!!! please

Ey, why so rude, bro? Calm down lol

Please, stop talking out of your a*s and back up your claims with proofs. Still waiting for the link regarding Karzai stealing 70% of foreign aid lol

[khushal]

He will pretty obvious point out Pashtun discrimination against non Pashtuns.

You see all these Afghanistani fanboys share a common pattern and behavior. I mean they are right when they claim Pashtun rulers were a bunch of uneducated tribal fascists. And the are right when they claim our current relationship with Porkistan was screwed by Pashtuns. But they exaggerate and play all the time the victim card.

Being a poor victim has always been a Hazara trick. Now even many Tajiks and Pashtuns are adopting this annoying attitude. The truth is Tajiks, despite being banned from the higher political post since the creation of this fake country called Afghanistan, we ran all the administration, culture and economy. So I don't see why we should be bitc*ing all the day long.

All of you are claiming things without sources including these fortress of munifiqyat pakis.

It is the tribal nature of pashtuns that has kept tajik and farsi culture safe from pashtun nationalists from destroying it. When a urdu speaking paki or a farsiwan afghani sits with a group of pashtuns, they all talk the language of the new comer, farsiwan dont do such a thing. The pashtun nationalists could not organize his own people with such a narrative which is why pashtuns rebelled against amanulah khan. The tribal pashtun can only be organized under an islamic narrative.

[Firdousi]

All of you are claiming things without sources including these fortress of munifiqyat pakis.

It is the tribal nature of pashtuns that has kept tajik and farsi culture safe from pashtun nationalists from destroying it. When a urdu speaking paki or a farsiwan afghani sits with a group of pashtuns, they all talk the language of the new comer, farsiwan dont do such a thing. The pashtun nationalists could not organize his own people with such a narrative which is why pashtuns rebelled against amanulah khan. The tribal pashtun can only be organized under an islamic narrative.

Its not because we don't want to.. its because we can't. Pashtuns, since most of them hail from a tribal-non urban background, if they want to live in the cities need to learn the urban language which in our case is farsi. Thats why in Herat, most of Pashtuns living around the city had to learn Farsi and forget Pashto: because their language was useless in a Farsi environment.

Farsi has always been the lingua franca of this region. So Persianspeakers didn't need to learn other languages. Why most of Americans or Brits can't speak more than one language? Because there is no need to do so. Same thing happen with us (to a smaller degree, of course).

BTW you should try to interact a bit more with Tajiks. We highly value manners and hospitality too. You would be amazed by all those taarofi games lol

[khushal]

Its not because we don't want to.. its because we can't. Pashtuns, since most of them hail from a tribal-non urban background, if they want to live in the cities need to learn the urban language which in our case is farsi. Thats why in Herat, most of Pashtuns living around the city had to learn Farsi and forget Pashto: because their language was useless in a Farsi environment.

Farsi has always been the lingua franca of this region. So Persianspeakers didn't need to learn other languages. Why most of Americans or Brits can't speak more than one language? Because there is no need to do so. Same thing happen with us (to a smaller degree, of course).

BTW you should try to interact a bit more with Tajiks. We highly value manners and hospitality too. You would be amazed by all those taarofi games lol

Where I live, most of the Afghans are farsiwan so I interact with many Tajiks. One of my really good friend from childhood is a panjshirai.
We already know that pashtuns that live in farsi areas speak farsi and pashtuns that live in panjab speak panjabi and vise versa. Tajiks that live in pashtun areas speak pashto and panjabis that live in FATA speak pashto. I live in America, Ive learned to speak English and I live around many latinos so Ive picked up spanish as a result. Thats natural but I kknow many Tajiks that speak good pashto and the pashtuns still speak farsi around that person. It is not the fault of the farsiwan or the panjabi that such a thing happens. I am just saying that pashtuns have that character. We are not nationalistic by nature.
We are proud of who we are but we dont impose our own culture or language on others. The proof is that farsi has been kept safe in Afghanistan more than any other country in the World today.

[Firdousi]

Where I live, most of the Afghans are farsiwan so I interact with many Tajiks. One of my really good friend from childhood is a panjshirai.
We already know that pashtuns that live in farsi areas speak farsi and pashtuns that live in panjab speak panjabi and vise versa. Tajiks that live in pashtun areas speak pashto and panjabis that live in FATA speak pashto. I live in America, Ive learned to speak English and I live around many latinos so Ive picked up spanish as a result. Thats natural but I kknow many Tajiks that speak good pashto and the pashtuns still speak farsi around that person. It is not the fault of the farsiwan or the panjabi that such a thing happens. I am just saying that pashtuns have that character. We are not nationalistic by nature.
We are proud of who we are but we dont impose our own culture or language on others. The proof is that farsi has been kept safe in Afghanistan more than any other country in the World today.

Good points.

But I must point out that Pashtuns when it comes to ethnicity are indeed nationalists. Much more than Tajiks. Tajiks take pride in their culture, heritage and language. Most of Heratis don't even know the difference between Tajik and Persianspeaker. They believe its the same thing lol

Frankly speaking to me culture is much more important than ethnicity. In my book if you speak Farsi and you are culturally "Persian", you are Persian. Same thing goes for Pashto and Pashtun culture. I don't see any difference between Herati Tajiks and Herati Pashtuns. They look the same, they speak the same, they behave the same so its BS to separate us along ethnic lines. I used to believe that those pashtuns living in Herat were invaders, immigrants,.. but every time I visit Herat I realize most of Heratis don't give a crap about it. All this Tajik vs Pashtun BS is an online and political phenomenon. Average people don't care so much about it.