Punjabis are embezzling international aid to FATA

[Azmal]

https://www.facebook.com/AzadPakhtoo...3362368439348/

Until the funds are spend through a multilateral arrangement, including UNO, US, and NATO with a "bit" of representation to Punjabi establishment and its Fathan emissaries, the money would go to drain. Moreover, reforms in FATA are also a per-requisite to any desirable impact of aid money on FATA. Further, genuine representatives of the tribal areas must also be involved.
Just as Ali Jennah called people of FATA “our Muslim brothers across border” for Punjabi establishment people of FATA cash crops, punjos will never want genuine development in tribal areas. It wants to retain it as it is as a strategic outpost and as an excuse to carry on with interference in the neighboring country. There are also other Punjabi interests that would be affected e.g. presently large quantities of marble and timber is being exported to Punjab for processing Punjab's industries. Any large-scale marble industry in Momand and Molagori would affect the interest of the Punjabi industrial class.
Punjos and those lapdog fathan in service of them are saying to world "we know trials and Pashtuns better and we can restore peace and order there...and US and Europe should give us money and we would do the work for them"...and that "only Punjabi Fauj can do the job in FATA". The aid surely would go to drain with even less than 5% of it spent on the development of FATA a situation much worse when NATO etc. would spend it which many spend 20% but with almost 100% fairness.

[Peacelove]

LOL Whatever you afghans say ..I wonder do you know the aid given to Afghanistan ? More than 100 billion dollar ? Who embezzled that ? Tajiks or Ubzbiks?

[Azmal]

LOL Whatever you afghans say ..I wonder do you know the aid given to Afghanistan ? More than 100 billion dollar ? Who embezzled that ? Tajiks or Ubzbiks?

This is not Afghan but Pakistani news...the aid were explicitly given to FATA and ends up for enjoyment of coward Punjo military men.

[Peacelove]

This is not Afghan but Pakistani news...the aid were explicitly given to FATA and ends up for enjoyment of coward Punjo military men.

Again my friend what you have to do with it..Think more about Afghanistan then Paksitan.. Day and night worry for what happening in pakistan while ignoring the situation and reality of afghanistan..
Punjabi fouj has second highest numbers recruiting pashtoons..It is not like ANA ...
Soon FATA will merge with KP and the issues will be resolved..

[~Zarlakhta~]

LOL Whatever you afghans say ..I wonder do you know the aid given to Afghanistan ? More than 100 billion dollar ? Who embezzled that ? Tajiks or Ubzbiks?

Pashtuns. That includes Karzai and his officials. Elites of Kandahar, elites of Nangarhar and elites of Paghman earned the most from the aid. Uzbeks 16 years later are still not better off, Hazaras only flourished because they're now free to move to bigger states for better opportunities. And Tajiks like Ismail Khan, Atta Noor, Fahim have made Balkh, Herat, Panjsher and Parwan provinces one of the most secure and financially stronger provinces of Afghanistan.

I would love to see your sources claiming Uzbeks and Tajiks eating those 100 billion Dollars, though. :-)

[Peacelove]

Pashtuns. That includes Karzai and his officials. Elites of Kandahar, elites of Nangarhar and elites of Paghman earned the most from the aid. Uzbeks 16 years later are still not better off, Hazaras only flourished because they're now free to move to bigger states for better opportunities. And Tajiks like Ismail Khan, Atta Noor, Fahim have made Balkh, Herat, Panjsher and Parwan provinces one of the most secure and financially stronger provinces of Afghanistan.

I would love to see your sources claiming Uzbeks and Tajiks eating those 100 billion Dollars, though. :-)

Lol it was satire..As afghans put everything on others

[~Zarlakhta~]

Lol it was satire..

I would only use satires if there's slight truth behind the sarcasm. :-)

And I don't see how this article, truth or lie, is related to Afghans putting everything on others. But I guess I have to get used to irrelevant comments and claims on this forum.

[Peacelove]

[QUOTE=~Zarlakhta~;803030]I would only use satires if there's slight truth behind the sarcasm. :-)

And I don't see how this article, truth or lie, is related to Afghans putting everything on others. But I guess I have to get used to irrelevant comments and claims on this forum.[/QUOTE

Afghans then should not comment about Pakistan also..Whatever happening there to aid or anything is out internal affair

[~Zarlakhta~]

You can comment about anyone, anything you want. But if you're questioned about it then be able to back up your claim too. :-)

Hugs back. I think.

[Azmal]

Again my friend what you have to do with it..Think more about Afghanistan then Paksitan.. Day and night worry for what happening in pakistan while ignoring the situation and reality of afghanistan..
Punjabi fouj has second highest numbers recruiting pashtoons..It is not like ANA ...
Soon FATA will merge with KP and the issues will be resolved..

FATA and Pashunistan development are directly linked to development of Afghanistan…in fact the reason or creation of FATA, PATA was to carry on with interference in Afghanistan. Ali Jennah speech to FATA/PATA elders declare to Afghans that Pakistan is NOT a new Muslim country but successor of British Raj and will continue the British Raj forward policy towards Afghanistan—this resulted in Afghanistan voting against Pakistan admission to UN and rest is history.
This is exactly the reason only “Islamist” political parties are allowed in FATA and most of the NGOs in Peshawar and Islamabad are controlled by the Punjabi establishment and cannot work in FATA without the approval and dictation of the Pakistan's military and the political administration of tribal areas. The aid surely goes to drain as the Pakistani media points out(video link I posted)… with even less than 5% of it spent on the development of FATA a situation much worse when NATO etc. would spend it which many spend 20% but with almost 100% fairness.
The whole point is, under the current political, and administrative, and foremost security set-up in tribal areas held in place by the federal government of Pakistan and its Punjab-based military, money can never be properly spent in FATA and actual goal of regional peace can never be achieved. The donors and funders must make sure that developmental work takes place under a genuine and representative security, administrative, and political system that is sincerely committed to regional peace and that involves tribes, especially educated ones, UNO, and international NGOs. NATO must be involved at some level to provide security umbrella to the developmental work. Donors and Funders must directly channel funds to the implementation of projects and must be directly involved in the planning and execution process of the developmental work. They must watch the work on ground. With peace in FATA is tied the peace in the region, especially Afghanistan.

[Azmal]

In addition...as past 40 years of insecurity and fighting in our land proves this fact...Pashtunsitan and Balochistan are Afghan land with historical record, and Afghanistan never accepted the British imposed infamous Durand line.

[Peacelove]

In addition...as past 40 years of insecurity and fighting in our land proves this fact...Pashtunsitan and Balochistan are Afghan land with historical record, and Afghanistan never accepted the British imposed infamous Durand line.

Ok don't accept ...Please provide security for what you have and save it from infightings

[Peacelove]

FATA and Pashunistan development are directly linked to development of Afghanistan…in fact the reason or creation of FATA, PATA was to carry on with interference in Afghanistan. Ali Jennah speech to FATA/PATA elders declare to Afghans that Pakistan is NOT a new Muslim country but successor of British Raj and will continue the British Raj forward policy towards Afghanistan—this resulted in Afghanistan voting against Pakistan admission to UN and rest is history.
This is exactly the reason only “Islamist” political parties are allowed in FATA and most of the NGOs in Peshawar and Islamabad are controlled by the Punjabi establishment and cannot work in FATA without the approval and dictation of the Pakistan's military and the political administration of tribal areas. The aid surely goes to drain as the Pakistani media points out(video link I posted)… with even less than 5% of it spent on the development of FATA a situation much worse when NATO etc. would spend it which many spend 20% but with almost 100% fairness.
The whole point is, under the current political, and administrative, and foremost security set-up in tribal areas held in place by the federal government of Pakistan and its Punjab-based military, money can never be properly spent in FATA and actual goal of regional peace can never be achieved. The donors and funders must make sure that developmental work takes place under a genuine and representative security, administrative, and political system that is sincerely committed to regional peace and that involves tribes, especially educated ones, UNO, and international NGOs. NATO must be involved at some level to provide security umbrella to the developmental work. Donors and Funders must directly channel funds to the implementation of projects and must be directly involved in the planning and execution process of the developmental work. They must watch the work on ground. With peace in FATA is tied the peace in the region, especially Afghanistan.

NATO security? excuse me this is PAKISTAN not AFGHANISTAN where NATO and US invaded forces are required neither will required
FATA security is linked with KP now where PTI is doing best then other provinces.. I wish they won again and Khattak will deal with the border as we know his views already

[~Zarlakhta~]

NATO security? excuse me this is PAKISTAN not AFGHANISTAN where NATO and US invaded forces are required neither will required
FATA security is linked with KP now where PTI is doing best then other provinces.. I wish they won again and Khattak will deal with the border as we know his views already

Uhu, but NATO drones were required in Waziristan and military aid was required from US to fight the so called self imposed insurgency? Right.

As long you got my point that's cool, no need to come up with untruthful counter argument. :-)

[Peacelove]

Uhu, but NATO drones were required in Waziristan and military aid was required from US to fight the so called self imposed insurgency? Right.

As long you got my point that's cool, no need to come up with untruthful counter argument. :-)

No counter but we will do what we feel right ;-)