Pakistan should be split in half and given to India and Afghanistan

[Forreigner]

Pakistan has no legitimacy to exist. India has more Muslims than Pakistan even.

Eastern Pakistan belongs to India and should be given back to India, while Western Pakistan to Afghanistan.
That way India and Afghanistan can continue good relations and directly trade with each other. havig Pakistan between the two nations is hindering both nations development.

[Firdousi]

Pakistan has no legitimacy to exist. India has more Muslims than Pakistan even.

Eastern Pakistan belongs to India and should be given back to India, while Western Pakistan to Afghanistan.
That way India and Afghanistan can continue good relations and directly trade with each other. havig Pakistan between the two nations is hindering both nations development.

I used to be a hardcore supporter of Loy Afghanistan. But now, after witnessing Pashtun barbarism, I strongly oppose the idea. We have already 12 million Pashtuns and our country is a mess. Last thing we need is to bring 28 million Pashtuns.

This does not mean at all that i support Dalkhoristan. Actually I think we should split up both, Afghanistan and Pakistan along ethnic lines: create Khorasan (western, central and northern provinces of Afghanistan), Pashtunistan (eastern and southern Afghan provinces and also Khyber), Baluchistan and cede the eastern Pakistani regions to their motherland India.

[Forreigner]

I used to be a hardcore supporter of Loy Afghanistan. But now, after witnessing Pashtun barbarism, I strongly oppose the idea. We have already 12 million Pashtuns and our country is a mess. Last thing we need is to bring 28 million Pashtuns.

This does not mean at all that i support Dalkhoristan. Actually I think we should split up both, Afghanistan and Pakistan along ethnic lines: create Khorasan (western, central and northern provinces of Afghanistan), Pashtunistan (eastern and southern Afghan provinces and also Khyber), Baluchistan and cede the eastern Pakistani regions to their motherland India.

Khorasan wouldn't be a good idea. It would be land locked nation. you need a coastline to become a big trade country. trade = development.

Beside Khorasan is in the past now. Afghanistan culture is different from Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan (which made up the ancient Khorasan) even if all nations speak Farsi.

[Sarbani]

Wouldn't it be better if we have Pakistan (Punjab, Sindh) as a buffer state between Loy Afghanistan and India?

If Punjab/Sindh go to India, then I feel like India will have too much influence on Afghanistan. And if Afghanistan were to ever have border spats with India, then Afg wouldn't be able to do much since India is a much much more powerful country.

Also, how would the Muslim-Hindu/Sikh relations be under Greater India? Would it be really significant internationally? I know not many Muslims in India cause a ruckus, but that's cause they're not the majority anywhere (except Kashmir), but Punjab & Sindh are overwhelmingly Muslim majority and could have separatism and religious violence issues when Hindus/Sikhs start moving to Sindh/West Punjab from neighboring Indian states and vice versa.

[jaal]

Hindu troll and dimwitted pathans will decide fate of Pakistan on PF of all places LMAO

[jaal]

Wouldn't it be better if we have Pakistan (Punjab, Sindh) as a buffer state between Loy Afghanistan and India?

If Punjab/Sindh go to India, then I feel like India will have too much influence on Afghanistan. And if Afghanistan were to ever have border spats with India, then Afg wouldn't be able to do much since India is a much much more powerful country.

Also, how would the Muslim-Hindu/Sikh relations be under Greater India? Would it be really significant internationally? I know not many Muslims in India cause a ruckus, but that's cause they're not the majority anywhere (except Kashmir), but Punjab & Sindh are overwhelmingly Muslim majority and could have separatism and religious violence issues when Hindus/Sikhs start moving to Sindh/West Punjab from neighboring Indian states and vice versa.

Pathan ka bacha na ghar ka na ghat ka, you can move to Afghanistan but land belong to Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

[jaal]

I used to be a hardcore supporter of Loy Afghanistan. But now, after witnessing Pashtun barbarism, I strongly oppose the idea. We have already 12 million Pashtuns and our country is a mess. Last thing we need is to bring 28 million Pashtuns.

This does not mean at all that i support Dalkhoristan. Actually I think we should split up both, Afghanistan and Pakistan along ethnic lines: create Khorasan (western, central and northern provinces of Afghanistan), Pashtunistan (eastern and southern Afghan provinces and also Khyber), Baluchistan and cede the eastern Pakistani regions to their motherland India.

If you want then take back 28 million pathans from Pakistan back to Afghanistan for Loy Afghanistan. But anything east of Hindukush as name suggest is part of Indian subcontinent and hence current day Pakistan. We only care about land, if someone isn't happy then he can move out.

People in Pakistan are tired of pathan terrorists blowing up schools and killing kids.

[Loy Afghanistan]

Pakistan has no legitimacy to exist. India has more Muslims than Pakistan even.

Eastern Pakistan belongs to India and should be given back to India, while Western Pakistan to Afghanistan.
That way India and Afghanistan can continue good relations and directly trade with each other. havig Pakistan between the two nations is hindering both nations development.

British created porkistan for this sole purpose only. To have a parasite venomous smelly traitors between our regions to divide ancient lands and its people. They did the same thing with f-aggot Iranians in 1953-79. Destroyed Iran's democracy and elected a arab big noosed smelly king named Mohammed Reza kuni P to be their house arab (read niggggger). hahahah Mohammed Reza what a non Iranian name. But today Iran is smarter than the rest of us sadly. They are a super power. and I am glad that at least there is peace in some corners of our ancient Ariana states.

[Samandri]

Khayali Pulao !

Its funny that Khayali Pulao eaters always ignore the sentiments and feelings of Baloch people. Every one is salivating over their coast line.

[Forreigner]

Khayali Pulao !

Its funny that Khayali Pulao eaters always ignore the sentiments and feelings of Baloch people. Every one is salivating over their coast line.

Dude Baloch people have equal rights and treated equal in Afghanistan. In Pakistan they are genocided by Punjabis. A daalkhoor paki boy like you should be last one to talk about Baloch people. Afghanistan have a lot of Baloch, and I think Baloch on the pakistani side would more than be happy to merge Balochistan with Afghanistan.

[Firdousi]

Khorasan wouldn't be a good idea. It would be land locked nation. you need a coastline to become a big trade country. trade = development.

Beside Khorasan is in the past now. Afghanistan culture is different from Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan (which made up the ancient Khorasan) even if all nations speak Farsi.

Khorasan would be a great idea. Coastline is an old Pashtunist obsession. Truth is you don't need it if you are a good neighbor. If Pashtun nationalist did not mess up our relationship with Pakistan now we would have full access to the sea. We don't need a port, we are already a crossroad. Once we get rid of Pashtuns and their barbaric culture, we may improve our rlationship with all our neighbors. There is plenty of landlocked countries out there who have done a good job despite being resourceless countries: Switzerland, Czech Republic, Austria, and so on. Those countries should be our role model, not Loy Awghanistan.

BTW I don't want to join Iran or Tajikistan nor I want a war against Uzbekistan in order to take back Samarkand, Bukhara and Termez. I believe we must first get rid of Pashtuns, secondly improve our life standards and finally improve our relationship with our neighbors. Create a sort of "cultural and economical" union a la EU, where Farsi will be used as a tool to bring all the people together. With Iran gaining momentum this is a possibility. I am not some sort of crazy warmonger Pashtunist obsessed with war.

[Firdousi]

If you want then take back 28 million pathans from Pakistan back to Afghanistan for Loy Afghanistan. But anything east of Hindukush as name suggest is part of Indian subcontinent and hence current day Pakistan. We only care about land, if someone isn't happy then he can move out.

People in Pakistan are tired of pathan terrorists blowing up schools and killing kids.

You brought it upon yourselves. You can not feed snakes in your backyard and don't expect them to bit you. They are snakes after all.

You have been playing with fire and now you are testing a bit of your own medicine. Your "good and bad terrorist" policy has backfired badly. Now Pakistan is completely isolated. Your Punjbai establishment brainwashed and took advantage of Pashtun stupidity. Enjoy the outcome.

[Samandri]

Dude Baloch people have equal rights and treated equal in Afghanistan. In Pakistan they are genocided by Punjabis. A daalkhoor paki boy like you should be last one to talk about Baloch people. Afghanistan have a lot of Baloch, and I think Baloch on the pakistani side would more than be happy to merge Balochistan with Afghanistan.

You dont know much about Balochs. There are only few lakhs Balochs in the desert of South Afghanistan, they are insignificant . The Baloch nationalists leading the separatist movement in Pakistan are actually educated people , not some unaware nomads of Nimroz and southern Helmand. Beside Punjab bashing, their most frequent targets are Afghan refugees in Balochistan, which always cause their friction with Pashtun politicians of Balochistan. The senior Baloch leaders are of opinion that Pashtun districts of their province have nothing to do with Balochistan, they can have their own province or join KPK. But the young hardliners are opposing division of Baluchistan province. Right now they are fixated on Punjab for the moment, but their next targets will be Iran and Afghanistan who are in possession of certain Baloch areas. Ask any Baloch, he will oppose Afghanistan's claim on Balochistan.

Check out this facebook page of Baloch with 24,000 likes, the content there is very hostile is against Afghans and Pashtun nationalists. History of Baloch

[Aryana]

Khorasan would be a great idea. Coastline is an old Pashtunist obsession. Truth is you don't need it if you are a good neighbor. If Pashtun nationalist did not mess up our relationship with Pakistan now we would have full access to the sea. We don't need a port, we are already a crossroad. Once we get rid of Pashtuns and their barbaric culture, we may improve our rlationship with all our neighbors. There is plenty of landlocked countries out there who have done a good job despite being resourceless countries: Switzerland, Czech Republic, Austria, and so on. Those countries should be our role model, not Loy Awghanistan.

BTW I don't want to join Iran or Tajikistan nor I want a war against Uzbekistan in order to take back Samarkand, Bukhara and Termez. I believe we must first get rid of Pashtuns, secondly improve our life standards and finally improve our relationship with our neighbors. Create a sort of "cultural and economical" union a la EU, where Farsi will be used as a tool to bring all the people together. With Iran gaining momentum this is a possibility. I am not some sort of crazy warmonger Pashtunist obsessed with war.

Big dreams for a dancing bacha boy. Look at the state of Tajikistan; it is not even in a war and yet half the economy is from Tajiks working abroad in Russia sending money back home.

[Aryana]

Pakistan has no legitimacy to exist. India has more Muslims than Pakistan even.

Eastern Pakistan belongs to India and should be given back to India, while Western Pakistan to Afghanistan.
That way India and Afghanistan can continue good relations and directly trade with each other. havig Pakistan between the two nations is hindering both nations development.

The land south of the Oxus and west of the Indus historically has always been Afghanistan, and rightfully belongs to Afghanistan.