Pakistan & Afghanistan .Would you accept merger of both these countries?

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

Pakistani nationalist might think that the merger will upgrade the Pakistani status of a bigger territory country and far bigger influence

But if this ever happened,Pakistan will collapse within less than a decade.

It will be hell alot of a task to put pakistaniat into 30Million people of Afghanistan as does the present Pakistani are blindly following.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

The best i would want is to invite all the Afghanistan pashtun into FATA,KPK and Balochistan and live under the present day Pakistan leaving the whole of afghanistan to tajiks,uzbeks etc and than fence the border once for all.

The pashtun regions of Afghanistan are of no importance and we will never get those rich mines regions of Tajiks/Uzbeks.

We can easily absorb 10-12Million pashtuns from Afghanistan without any biger problem

[Pakwatan]

Afghans are our brothers. I would love to share a nation with them. We would rival Iran with 4x the population.

But I think certain ethnic groups have their own vested interests.

Punjab of Pakistan was once the bread basket of the Durrani empire. Punjabis themselves invited Ahmad Shah Durrani to fight the kaafir peoples. Hindus and Sikhs.

The problem would be of only of this nasal of Afghan. Afghans and Pashtuns of history considered Lahore and all people as their people. But today we have Afghan nationalists, that are obsessed with skin color and language.

I honestly feel that Pashtun leaders from history have nothing to do with the Afghans of today.

I support Pakistan and Afghanistan confederation, because Afghans are our people.

If Afghans did not find a certain affinity with us then they have their options with Iranians, Turkmens, Uzbeks, and Tajiks.

Pakistan has the most Pashtun people in the entire world. If an Afghan says that Pashtuns only belong to Afghanistan, then I would have to laugh at his face. Pakistan is the home of Pashtuns, and Afghanistan today the graveyard of Pashtuns.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=haCuenXc65k

[rednwhite99]

The best i would want is to invite all the Afghanistan pashtun into FATA,KPK and Balochistan and live under the present day Pakistan leaving the whole of afghanistan to tajiks,uzbeks etc and than fence the border once for all.

The pashtun regions of Afghanistan are of no importance and we will never get those rich mines regions of Tajiks/Uzbeks.

We can easily absorb 10-12Million pashtuns from Afghanistan without any biger problem

Bro i m not pakistani nationalist , i just said that 'if this happens' which i know will never happen. 90 percent pakistanis and afghans dont want it to happen which u can clearly see from the poll results.

Hope one day pakistan and afghanistan can be peacefull countries with no hatred amongst them

[Loy Afghanistan]

You are absolutely sick , what i suggested u earlier was go and start ur research from pashtun areas of khyber kurram and orakzai and u will get the answer there about loy afghanistan.
u feel u r superior person but u hav done nothing for ur people, At least my family is supporting the zazai from afghanistan, what r u doing by living in a foreign country and propogating ns like loy afghanistan. i think u need to open ur eyes, nobody in kpk wants loy afghanistan but i think if these countries are united they might accept it .
But with sick people like u i think i shud take my question back

You are the sick one. You new generation brainwashed apes have no right to take ancient Hindustan land to divide more hindus families. Then again I am against mix racing because real Pashtuns does not mix over their race. The most important thing people should not forget, pakistan is an british project nothing more. If you want justice, rightfulness, to become even more stronger you should join Hindustan why? because mostly of punjabs, sindhis etc look like Hindustanis and even share same language and culturally similarity. How can I be racist when I want hindu people like yourself join together with your brother and sisters in hindustan? and same way goes to the Iranian speaking people Pashtuns, Balochs, Iranians, Tajiks, etc joining hand together?

Split british made project. kick out all foreign bases and parasites NATO etc, and Loy Afghanistan, with Iran, Tajikistan etc make a federation or a simple union and punjab provinces etc will have autonomy rule over themselves in a big federation in Hindustan. Then it will be autonomy ruled provinces and a Big country Hindustan. in Afghanistan official languages should be like it has been for thousands of years Pashto but with our parsiwans refugees from the times of alexander-arabs-mongols, dari is needed to to respect our cousins traditions. Not only that, hopefully many professors, law makers and other scholars will make Dari to an official language in Iran and Tajikistan because their farsi is not pure as one preserved in Afghanistan.

And the provinces should have 100 % right to their own dialect languages and culturally like it has been since the times of Ariana.

And in the future, nor will Arabs, Europeans, + Russia, china ever bother nor Pashtuns or hindustan again with proxy's and puppet states.


This sounds more logical, history correct, and will make all poor people involved stronger, than any other ISI Mafia dream or NATO mafia dream they have for the area.

@Toramana

Grana wroor, I am not afraid of unification? I want unification with all our Iranian speaking brothers that mostly even include in our race, because many of us look very alike. But I can bet my life on Khushal Khan Khattak didn't mean with Moghul-hindus, rather Pashtuns tribes and our Iranian speaking family for freedom against the mongol-hindu empire and other aggression forces.

[Pakwatan]

You are the sick one. You new generation brainwashed apes have no right to take ancient Hindustan land to divide more hindus families. Then again I am against mix racing because real Pashtuns does not mix over their race. The most important thing people should not forget, pakistan is an british project nothing more. If you want justice, rightfulness, to become even more stronger you should join Hindustan why? because mostly of punjabs, sindhis etc look like Hindustanis and even share same language and culturally similarity. How can I be racist when I want hindu people like yourself join together with your brother and sisters in hindustan? and same way goes to the Iranian speaking people Pashtuns, Balochs, Iranians, Tajiks, etc joining hand together?

Split british made project. kick out all foreign bases and parasites NATO etc, and Loy Afghanistan, with Iran, Tajikistan etc make a federation or a simple union and punjab provinces etc will have autonomy rule over themselves in a big federation in Hindustan. Then it will be autonomy ruled provinces and a Big country Hindustan. in Afghanistan official languages should be like it has been for thousands of years Pashto but with our parsiwans refugees from the times of alexander-arabs-mongols, dari is needed to to respect our cousins traditions. Not only that, hopefully many professors, law makers and other scholars will make Dari to an official language in Iran and Tajikistan because their farsi is not pure as one preserved in Afghanistan.

And the provinces should have 100 % right to their own dialect languages and culturally like it has been since the times of Ariana.

And in the future, nor will Arabs, Europeans, + Russia, china ever bother nor Pashtuns or hindustan again with proxy's and puppet states.


This sounds more logical, history correct, and will make all poor people involved stronger, than any other ISI Mafia dream or NATO mafia dream they have for the area.

@Toramana

Grana wroor, I am not afraid of unification? I want unification with all our Iranian speaking brothers that mostly even include in our race, because many of us look very alike. But I can bet my life on Khushal Khan Khattak didn't mean with Moghul-hindus, rather Pashtuns tribes and our Iranian speaking family for freedom against the mongol-hindu empire and other aggression forces.

Post your picture so we can see your Iranic face?

I have already posted my pics here.

Surprise, Surprise your Afghan ancestors were Hindus and Bhuddists before Islam. LOL

[rednwhite99]

You are the sick one. You new generation brainwashed apes have no right to take ancient Hindustan land to divide more hindus families. Then again I am against mix racing because real Pashtuns does not mix over their race. The most important thing people should not forget, pakistan is an british project nothing more. If you want justice, rightfulness, to become even more stronger you should join Hindustan why? because mostly of punjabs, sindhis etc look like Hindustanis and even share same language and culturally similarity. How can I be racist when I want hindu people like yourself join together with your brother and sisters in hindustan? and same way goes to the Iranian speaking people Pashtuns, Balochs, Iranians, Tajiks, etc joining hand together?

Split british made project. kick out all foreign bases and parasites NATO etc, and Loy Afghanistan, with Iran, Tajikistan etc make a federation or a simple union and punjab provinces etc will have autonomy rule over themselves in a big federation in Hindustan. Then it will be autonomy ruled provinces and a Big country Hindustan. in Afghanistan official languages should be like it has been for thousands of years Pashto but with our parsiwans refugees from the times of alexander-arabs-mongols, dari is needed to to respect our cousins traditions. Not only that, hopefully many professors, law makers and other scholars will make Dari to an official language in Iran and Tajikistan because their farsi is not pure as one preserved in Afghanistan.

And the provinces should have 100 % right to their own dialect languages and culturally like it has been since the times of Ariana.

And in the future, nor will Arabs, Europeans, + Russia, china ever bother nor Pashtuns or hindustan again with proxy's and puppet states.


This sounds more logical, history correct, and will make all poor people involved stronger, than any other ISI Mafia dream or NATO mafia dream they have for the area.

@Toramana

Grana wroor, I am not afraid of unification? I want unification with all our Iranian speaking brothers that mostly even include in our race, because many of us look very alike. But I can bet my life on Khushal Khan Khattak didn't mean with Moghul-hindus, rather Pashtuns tribes and our Iranian speaking family for freedom against the mongol-hindu empire and other aggression forces.

What abt the pashtuns in mardan, peshwar and swat who look like punjabis i.e hindus in ur context. should they join hindustan too. What about dark balochs too.
U i think need to be vanished from this earth. u wana follow khushal but not islam where it says nobody has skin colour superiorty . On the other hand it seems like u afghans are white europeons and punjabis sindhis are africans. Bro come to the reality, in the eyes of europeon u too are considered brown maybe a shade lighter than other non pashtun pakistanis.

I look hindu to you thankyou i admit it, what abt you do u have a picture to prove that u look europeon.

Why dont u join with russia than if u think u r white, ur kinds have much in common with them as u might be having russian blood running through ur veins. hope u got what i meant

[rednwhite99]

Post your picture so we can see your Iranic face?

I have already posted my pics here.

Surprise, Surprise your Afghan ancestors were Hindus and Bhuddists before Islam. LOL

ignore this guy , he loves white people and that is why he is making stupid attempts to be associated with them

[Loy Afghanistan]

What abt the pashtuns in mardan, peshwar and swat who look like punjabis i.e hindus in ur context. should they join hindustan too. What about dark balochs too.
U i think need to be vanished from this earth. u wana follow khushal but not islam where it says nobody has skin colour superiorty . On the other hand it seems like u afghans are white europeons and punjabis sindhis are africans. Bro come to the reality, in the eyes of europeon u too are considered brown maybe a shade lighter than other non pashtun pakistanis.

I look hindu to you thankyou i admit it, what abt you do u have a picture to prove that u look europeon.

Why dont u join with russia than if u think u r white, ur kinds have much in common with them as u might be having russian blood running through ur veins. hope u got what i meant

Don't run away from the argument. I know you don't look fully hindu or punjabi, but your mentally is 100 % punjab ISI. That's why I told you to join them, better for you, get high status as well in their culture view.

I know the different people's skin tone on south, west, north and east of Pashtunistan. I have not said one thing against them. Why do you want to insult a hardcore Pashtun with European look or that Russian insult? I don't get red or pork skinned like russian- north europeans do. That's the different between a white and bleach looking. Why you all get so sensitive when we talk about skin tone? It is in your racist panjabi culture you like lighter skin, why does pakistan use so much white cream then? come to reality "bro", we have already talked about these skin tone it is much more sensitive in your culture than Pashtun culture.

Back to ON TOPIC, my idea is much better than the wet dreams of ISI or NATO etc. This will make the indo-aryan people much stronger in the end.

[Loy Afghanistan]

Post your picture so we can see your Iranic face?

I have already posted my pics here.

Surprise, Surprise your Afghan ancestors were Hindus and Bhuddists before Islam. LOL

Ariana had always been multicultural, and No my ancestors was zoroaster, you dumb little monkey!! Stop coming with OFF TOPIC!!

[Al-Afghani]

30 million Afghans would be completely dissolved by 180 pakis. Goodbye sovereignty!

[DSM0305]

I voted no, for the sole purpose that Pakistanis are fascists without human conscious. I am not talking about all Pakistanis in Pakistan, because there is no way I can know 180+ million people. Rather my comment is directed toward Pakistanis in this forum. If you guys pay close attention, then not a single Pakistani had anything good or relevant to say. While most Afghans(not all, but most of them) had a reasonable opinion and were ready for a serious topic. Unfortunately majority of Pakistanis have the very same opinion as these Pakistanis in this forum. I be ready to discuss this topic when an educated person from Pakistan shows up, until then I be probably ignoring those with underdeveloped brain(you guys probably already know who you're).

[Kushan Prince]

Pashtuns and punjabis are living together since a long tym bro. Can you tell me any time period when pashtuns and punjabis were not under one empire except from 1850 to 1893 before that they were together during durrani mughal ghaznavid, mamluks etc.
the prob is the farsiwans who would not accept pashtun and punjabi rule. they dont like pashtuns ruling in afghanistan and want divided afghanistan, what i am suggesting is if they could become one pakistan and afghanistan would be a very strong country,

I think you're forgetting that Pashtuns and Punjabis are separated by a natural border called the indus river.

[Kushan Prince]

The best i would want is to invite all the Afghanistan pashtun into FATA,KPK and Balochistan and live under the present day Pakistan leaving the whole of afghanistan to tajiks,uzbeks etc and than fence the border once for all.

The pashtun regions of Afghanistan are of no importance and we will never get those rich mines regions of Tajiks/Uzbeks.

We can easily absorb 10-12Million pashtuns from Afghanistan without any biger problem

LOL you actually think Afghan Pashtuns will be willing to become part of a artificial british created harami state? Either your completely delusional or just wishful thinking. I think you're forgetting that Afg has 5000 years of history while your pakistan only has 40, lol you actually think that will happen? I knew pakis were funny clowns.

Seriously, this Banu murtad's trolling is getting on my nerves.

[Friends of Baloch]

Punjabis themselves invited Ahmad Shah Durrani to fight the kaafir peoples. Hindus and Sikhs.

Bundjabis werent even Muslim when Ahmad Shah slaugheterd and humiliated you Indians. Majority of you pakis were still Hindus and Sikh in the 18th century.

These dirty pakis sure know how to let their imaginations run wild away from reality like no other.