plans to break up afghanistan

[єѕαρχαι]

Sher Khan you are confused kid...you change political stands like we all change shirts. Pashtunkhwa has minorities as well...what do you want to do? Wipe them out? Deport them? Ignore them? Speak with some sense. Loy Afghanistan is in essence Pashtunkhwa, but bigger and strategically more sound. And no Pashtuns are not foreigners to each other, that so called line was british imposed...maybe sher khan you enjoy lines created by Angraezaan, but majority of Pashtuns don't accept it. They cross it constantly. Maybe to you they are foreigners, but not to us. I saw what brotherhood your people within the state had for IDPs of Swat and Buner....yeh because a border really dictated that one lollz. As usual too fickle to make a convicted stand and to unsure to stick by it.

Amir jaana sar pae ma khuraa 3-5 million pashtaana da Afghanistan pa Pashtunkhwa kae raaghalee dee..Yousafzai ham pa zaroona Afghanistan kae oseegee da asae zaan na leegyaa dae. Kakar, Yousafzai, durrani, ghiljai, shinwari, mohmand, ao nur ham dasae ghatt ttabaroona pa lar au bar kae oseegee.

Bls wrora. I know how northern alliance messed up afghanistan and I wouldnt like to be a part of such country where there is a second language next to pashtu (darri) and we have larger population of various ethnicities. Smaller populations are always negligible.

People at my village (yarhussain) shared their houses with idps.

[Admin Khan]

Hi Sher Khan, I hope you are in great health.

Do you mind explaining to me how you expect a state in which no other ethnicity exists? Do you plan to add Kandahar to this state?

Dera manana.

-Admin Khan

[єѕαρχαι]

Hi Sher Khan, I hope you are in great health.

Do you mind explaining to me how you expect a state in which no other ethnicity exists? Do you plan to add Kandahar to this state?

Dera manana.

-Admin Khan

Admin khan wrora , I support a state which exists of pashtun majority areas. We may have smaller ethnicities but not large ones which could be problematic.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Bls wrora. I know how northern alliance messed up afghanistan and I wouldnt like to be a part of such country where there is a second language next to pashtu (darri) and we have larger population of various ethnicities. Smaller populations are always negligible.

People at my village (yarhussain) shared their houses with idps.

Yes people of swabaii did as they were Pashtuns...swabaii also housed millions of Pashtuns from Afghanistan. However how did your fellow countrymen east of the indus treat them? Che waar raaghlo nu bya dyuu pa khpl mulk kae pradee shwalll ao agha afghanistan wo che Qibaello la ae pnaah war krrla. Za na waemaa che swabai ya nur pakhtano seemae na dee warkarrae...kho ka stha khabaraa samaa wa nu da gerda pakistan walae na kawala?

Sher Khan there will always be second third fourth languages and communities in a state. This is the reality of our region and most of them. However there is wisdom in bringing such communities together, especially when it is strategically in your advantage to do so.

Norther Alliance wasn't the only one who did, and neither are they representative of a state or the majority of people. Those who did should be convicted. That still doesn't prove anything though, you are just laying blame on a militant group.

Oh and shumaaliyaan are not one group, there are many ethnicities in them. Tajiks are not the same as uzbeks, turkmens are not the same as tajikis or hazaras, same is the case with aimaks.

[Admin Khan]

Admin khan wrora , I support a state which exists of pashtun majority areas. We may have smaller ethnicities but not large ones which could be problematic.

Fair enough, but what you said here sort of forced me to raise a red-flag.

I support a country only for pashtuns. Where we wouldnt have tajik , hazara , panjabi

Would you like to analyze the above? or do you realize how impossible that is? In Southern Afghanistan, Pashto serves as the lingua-franca. What does that mean? That means nearly everyone can speak Pashto.

The reason why I asked you about Kandahar province is despite Kandahar being a Pashtun majority that speaks nearly 100percent Pashto, they have a Tajik minority that probably speaks better Pashto than the both of us. What do we do with them? Hitler? Ethnic cleansing? Push them to the north?(may I remind you, I have some Hazara friends who can't speak a word Dari, they speak Pashto, read Pashto and write in Pashto) sa pa wako?

I am not born in Pakistan or Afghanistan, If you were to meet me would you consider me a foreigner? Hagha zmosh ittifaq sa so? hagha yaw-waley mo sa so gulaba?

[єѕαρχαι]

Fair enough, but what you said here sort of forced me to raise a red-flag.
Would you like to analyze the above? or do you realize how impossible that is? In Southern Afghanistan, Pashto serves as the lingua-franca. What does that mean? That means nearly everyone can speak Pashto.

The reason why I asked you about Kandahar province is despite Kandahar being a Pashtun majority that speaks nearly 100percent Pashto, they have a Tajik minority that probably speaks better Pashto than the both of us. What do we do with them? Hitler? Ethnic cleansing? Push them to the north?(may I remind you, I have some Hazara friends who can't speak a word Dari, they speak Pashto, read Pashto and write in Pashto) sa pa wako?

I am not born in Pakistan or Afghanistan, If you were to meet me would you consider me a foreigner? Hagha zmosh ittifaq sa so? hagha yaw-waley mo sa so gulaba?

Wrora If your father is a pashtun then you are a pashtun. Place of birth doesnt matter. I have only concerns about northern afghanistan. The minorities within southern afghanistan are not that large, so they are tolerable.

[єѕαρχαι]

Yes people of swabaii did as they were Pashtuns...swabaii also housed millions of Pashtuns from Afghanistan. However how did your fellow countrymen east of the indus treat them? Che waar raaghlo nu bya dyuu pa khpl mulk kae pradee shwalll ao agha afghanistan wo che Qibaello la ae pnaah war krrla. Za na waemaa che swabai ya nur pakhtano seemae na dee warkarrae...kho ka stha khabaraa samaa wa nu da gerda pakistan walae na kawala?

Sher Khan there will always be second third fourth languages and communities in a state. This is the reality of our region and most of them. However there is wisdom in bringing such communities together, especially when it is strategically in your advantage to do so.

Norther Alliance wasn't the only one who did, and neither are they representative of a state or the majority of people. Those who did should be convicted. That still doesn't prove anything though, you are just laying blame on a militant group.

Oh and shumaaliyaan are not one group, there are many ethnicities in them. Tajiks are not the same as uzbeks, turkmens are not the same as tajikis or hazaras, same is the case with aimaks.

wrora. na me pajabyan khwakh de na tajikan na hazaragan awo na sindhyan..
Za ka khpala weena bayom nu sirf da pakhtunkhwa da para.

[parsiwaan]

I would always be on the side of my people

You make no sense... who are you people? Ranjit Sing army? Please explain will you side with pakistan or Afghanistan...seriously if you pashtonsitan pashtons had made your mind...Afghanistan will not be in this miseries...I personally think its time for us in Afghanistan to accept Durand line and move on...you people play both side...but at the end were more royal to british creation cancer Pakistan...since she can pay more....time to recognize durrand line so paksitan will stop interfering and imposing their filthy Talibi culture on us.

[parsiwaan]

i am a KAKAR.....how stupid would i sound...calling my fellow KAKAR from ZHOB a foreigner because of a stupid line

now multiply the stupidity of that by a 100 when applied to ALL PAKHTUNS

like it or not Sher Khan saheb....ta AFGHAN yay

This madness need to stop...seriously go to Pakistan and almost all Pashtons there call themselves pakistani... and yet ppl like you want to impose "Afghan-ness" on their mouth...seriously if they talk like a ****, if they walk like a **** and if they act like a **** then they are a ****...identity is self perception ...it all depends on how one identify him/her self...if he identity with Ali Jenah as his BABA…if he value Indian culture…Bangra, Urdu and… then what the hell is the point calling him Afghan? He is no Afghan.

[pekhawar]

So you think Pashtun/afghans are hindus? Have you lost your mind?

Afghan/Pashtuns do have hindus khyaal.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

This madness need to stop...seriously go to Pakistan and almost all Pashtons there call themselves pakistani... and yet ppl like you want to impose "Afghan-ness" on their mouth...seriously if they talk like a ****, if they walk like a **** and if they act like a **** then they are a ****...identity is self perception ...it all depends on how one identify him/her self...if he identity with Ali Jenah as his BABA…if he value Indian culture…Bangra, Urdu and… then what the hell is the point calling him Afghan? He is no Afghan.

So when did you become an expert of Pashtunkhwa? Really please tell me about my own culture. Clearly we here from Pashtunkhwa are talking out our backsides lolzz. Parsiwaan Pakistani is a citizenship, legally they have to say that, but on their domicile cards, NIC it is written Afghan. We don't have to prove this, it is what we are. And btw we walk like pashtuns, talk like Pashtuns, we act like Pashtuns. Maybe you should come to Waziristan, Bajaur, quetta, or dir, we would all show you who ***** are and who Pashtuns are. Daa gazz ao daa maidaan.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

wrora. na me pajabyan khwakh de na tajikan na hazaragan awo na sindhyan..
Za ka khpala weena bayom nu sirf da pakhtunkhwa da para.

Nnu anddeewaala domra zar da Pakistan milli urdu ao ISI saraa walae odhraegae? Domra zar da Pashtano mufaadath par zidh walae kaegae?

[Toramana]

...specially when pashtons have nothing in common in terms of race, language, culture and history with punjabis? Or the Balochs in Iran and Pakistan...and the Tajiks in Uzbakistan.

You are wrong Parsiwan. There are some here who have much in common with Punjabis in terms of language, culture, history, and probably also race. Some are outright Punjabis pretending to be Pashtuns.

[Michin Khel]

Realist Pakistan has no history of defeating invaders.

our motherland is known the grave yard of empires.

so realist, the US is losing in Afghanistan.

We should be proudful of our history but this pride should not become superiority complex.

[Michin Khel]

Only the peons of the Punjabi elite and their certified slaves love Pakistan which is a Punjabi empire.

Ther referender was a fake one. There was no option for opting to be a part of Afghanistan and hence the sole representatives of Pakhtuns at that time the Khudai Khidmatgars boycotted the referendem.

Pakhtunsonce aware about what has the Punjabi empire done to them will tear this banana republic apart and the day is fastly appraoching.

Muhsina your people (hindkowans) are very faithful to Pakistan. Tell us the stance of your people in 1947 refrendum.