Retired Pashtun general arrested for fueling ethnic tension.

[khushal]

oh my english was maybe to bad like i said pashtuns living there longer than 200 years so longer than rahman khan and gul momand your settler kings :D but pashtuns was already there alone in panjsher are somany pashtuns that living there over 200 years long time before panjsher even became the province right.if i find the book i will send it to you.sry for the bad englisi

There are Pashtuns everywhere in Afghansitan but that does not mean they were the original inhabitants of all the places in Afghanistan. Ahmed Shah annexed certain areas where he made agreements with local rulers to be administered by him. The reason he was successful was because he did not care about who was Pashtun and who wasn't, he knew that if everyone worked together, everyone benefits.

[Khilji]

are you sure parwan is majority Pashtun?
What about tokhar, faryab, sar I pol?

if you try to say majority is now parsiwan in nothern afghanistan than yes thats true.but if you say pashtuns just living there because some kings settled them there thats not true.

[Khilji]

There are Pashtuns everywhere in Afghansitan but that does not mean they were the original inhabitants of all the places in Afghanistan. Ahmed Shah annexed certain areas where he made agreements with local rulers to be administered by him. The reason he was successful was because he did not care about who was Pashtun and who wasn't, he knew that if everyone worked together, everyone benefits.

you wanna say before ahmad shah durrani dont lived pashtuns in this region?? this is also a lie this was never tajikistan.dont forget tajikistan was never existing it came 1992 to life with the fall of the soviets

[Kushan Prince]

There are Pashtuns everywhere in Afghansitan but that does not mean they were the original inhabitants of all the places in Afghanistan. Ahmed Shah annexed certain areas where he made agreements with local rulers to be administered by him. The reason he was successful was because he did not care about who was Pashtun and who wasn't, he knew that if everyone worked together, everyone benefits.

True, but we can also say KPK wasn't Pashtun in ancient times.

[khushal]

you wanna say before ahmad shah durrani dont lived pashtuns in this region?? this is also a lie this was never tajikistan.dont forget tajikistan was never existing it came 1992 to life with the fall of the soviets

no, I think you didn't understand what I said. I said Ahmed Shah annexed or connected Tajik areas with his own people. He created an atmosphere where people worked and lived together in peace. During that time Tajiks didn't feel threatened by Pashtun and Pashtuns didn't feel threatened by Tajik like they are today.

The current US leaders puts fascists in power so you can hate each other and destroy each other. They create turmoil to dominate the region.

[khushal]

True, but we can also say KPK wasn't Pashtun in ancient times.

your changing goal posts

[Kushan Prince]

your changing goal posts

How? I'm adding on to your post by saying KPK wasn't Pashtun just like your saying half of afg wasn't.

[DaZahroJaam.]

and let's face it. One day someone comes up to them, telling them they are not afghans unless they are Pashtuns. The next day when they repeat the same thing, everyone is upset. Would it really be too much on their part to be bitter and upset with us?? Are we not to be blamed for not speaking against the statements of individuals as this man??
We are amongst ourselves. Are we being honest and fair here??

[Khilji]

no, I think you didn't understand what I said. I said Ahmed Shah annexed or connected Tajik areas with his own people. He created an atmosphere where people worked and lived together in peace. During that time Tajiks didn't feel threatened by Pashtun and Pashtuns didn't feel threatened by Tajik like they are today.

The current US leaders puts fascists in power so you can hate each other and destroy each other. They create turmoil to dominate the region.

look this region was many times invaded by diffrent invaders lol sry for the bad english for exampls beginning from ghaznavi to changez khan this is one of the reason for the diffrent ethnics that living there but pashtuns in this region claiming like every other ethnic in this region that they live there longer than 1000 years.in nothern afghanistan are tribes ethnics claiming they are arabs living there since islam arived.so you cant say this nothern region is nativ tajik land that is hypocraci that is a lie.pashtun history and the pashtun tribe and their land is older than durrani bro.

[gadoonwal]

Well said taqat saib
He is 102% right to say afghanistan is the home of pashtuns.
Pashtun can not say the truth in his own country.
It is nothing to do with ethnic tension but since punjsheri and tajik rule afghanistan so they can do anything they like.
So many tajiks and azaras inulted the name afghanistan but they walk free.
Some of them call for the partation of the country and still free.
Many of them like dostum killed and rape pashtanay and even enjoy in govt.
If tajiks can call their homeland tajikistan,uzbik uzbikistan so why can,nt pashtun call their country with real name pashtunistan?
If afghanistan mean pashtunistan then why this word pashtun so offensive in that country.

afzos,,,,,,pashtuns will be arested on both side of durand if say pashtunistan is my country.
Lets all pashtuns from abaseen to amu unite and teach these outsiders(tajiks uzbiks etc) and punjabis some listens.
They will destroy our identity and language if we stay divided.
Ths is great that we still have some naran pashtana like taqat .
At least he is not influence by parsdo like many others.
tal de we pashtunistan/afghan

[DaZahroJaam.]

Do you have the complete video of that YouTube video? That was a great share.

unfortunately, I don't. If I do come across it, I will share it with pf.

[khushal]

How? I'm adding on to your post by saying KPK wasn't Pashtun just like your saying half of afg wasn't.

KPK is not the argument here. That's a different argument.

[randolph85]

the guy was a communist general

he may talk a big game but he and his kind have done more harm to pashtuns than anyone else in afghan history.

[Kushan Prince]

KPK is not the argument here. That's a different argument.

Whatever KPK relates to what I'm saying and what's the point of arguing about this? It's leading no where.

[khushal]

look this region was many times invaded by diffrent invaders lol sry for the bad english for exampls beginning from ghaznavi to changez khan this is one of the reason for the diffrent ethnics that living there but pashtuns in this region claiming like every other ethnic in this region that they live there longer than 1000 years.in nothern afghanistan are tribes ethnics claiming they are arabs living there since islam arived.so you cant say this nothern region is nativ tajik land that is hypocraci that is a lie.pashtun history and the pashtun tribe and their land is older than durrani bro.

ghaznavi did not invade Afghanistan, he was from Afghanistan. If Arabs migrated to the north as you say that does not mean that tajiks are not indigenous. Pashtuns history precedes durrani but Afghanistan as a nation of today is influenced by him. He created the northern borders.