Should Pakistan give Citizenship to Afghan Refugees?

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

I believe after living for more than 3 decades in Pakistan
Having alot of similarities and are now almost integrated into the pakistani society

We should give afghan refugees citizenship status.

80% of the rich refugees had already got citizenship.Only the poor are remaining.

What do you guys think?

[Smarty]

No, they should return back to their motherland.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

No, they should return back to their motherland.

But i believe those who want to stay on their will should be given citizenship

After they are now one of us.I wont like KPK without them

[M17ArnoBaloch]

NO.

They are welcome in KPK Because that's their land. Citizenship to Daalkhor lands like Punjab, Lahore, Karachi should be strictly prohibited.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

NO.

They are welcome in Balochistan or KPK. But not in Daalkhor areas like Punjab, Lahore, Karachi etc. NO NO NO and NO.

majority of them are in either kpk or balochistan

those in punjab are extremely less in number

[M17ArnoBaloch]

majority of them are in either kpk or balochistan

those in punjab are extremely less in number

This should be the law:

They are welcome in KPK Because that's their land. Citizenship to Daalkhor lands like Punjab, Lahore, Karachi should be strictly prohibited.

Make this a law.

[Smarty]

This should be the law:

They are welcome in KPK Because that's their land. Citizenship to Daalkhor lands like Punjab, Lahore, Karachi should be strictly prohibited.

Make this a law.

Most of the Afghan mohajirs have already acquired citizenship of Pakistan through bribes any way. They first make fake district domiciles through bribes, then on the basis of that domicile and other fake documents they make NIC in nadra office by bribing the officers. Only few lakh rupees are needed.

In tribal areas you are not allowed to buy lands even if you are a pashtun, though they themselves are settling in settled areas of KPK due to ongoing military operations, they are buying lands and plots in adjacent districts of KPK.

[Da Bannu Mazdigar]

This should be the law:

They are welcome in KPK Because that's their land. Citizenship to Daalkhor lands like Punjab, Lahore, Karachi should be strictly prohibited.

Make this a law.

If they get the citizenship they can remain in KPK.

no one would be forcing them to leave kpk for punjab or sindh

[Badlun]

If they wish and they have interest in staying in Pakistan and have business and other opportunities then why not government of Pakistan give them citizenship legally , without bribes on the same pattern many get citizenship in US and Europe.

The same way once Afghanistan is a democratic stable and peaceful state in near future Pakistani Pashtuns can apply for Afghan citizenship if they see better future there.

[ډګروال]

NO

i think the people in pukhtunkhwa and balochistan should be given Afghan citizenship cards and also to those in karachi.

[Kushan Prince]

No just give us back our land.

[Smarty]

No just give us back our land.

And people?

[Kushan Prince]

And people?

Same thing?

[gadoonwal]

This should be the law:

They are welcome in KPK Because that's their land. Citizenship to Daalkhor lands like Punjab, Lahore, Karachi should be strictly prohibited.

Make this a law.

you are on the wrong track here by saying kpk only.
The pashtunland inside pakistani control starts from chetral to Bolan.
Half of BALUCHISTAN is pashtunland not some baluchiland.
You are in the south and that is the real Baluchistan.
The northren part got nothing to do with Baluchistan or baluch identity.

The afghans inside pashtunkhwa are welcome but it is in the interest of pashtuns of afghanistan to go back to their country and defend pashtun and afghan interests.

[Levanaye Zalmaye]

No, they should return back to their motherland.

Peshawar and Quetta are just as much their motherland as Kabul and Kandahar.

Interestingly, wasn't Pakistan made so it could be a home for all Muslims? Or was it just some sort of a mischievous experiment in which a group of Indian nawabs got to rule over the mostly illiterate and politically aloof Pashtun, Baloch and Sindhi?