Would you like to live under Taliban rule?

[El Camello]

I see a few people here support the Taliban and believe them to be a very good form of government, but yet these individuals seemed to have left Afghanistan to settle in the West, either while the Taliban were in power or before or after that. I feel that the Taliban implement unnecessary laws.

I for one would probably not want to live in such a repressive society.

To those who support the Taliban, why would you like to live under their rule?

Why don't you go to one of the Taliban-controlled districts in Afghanistan to experience how life is over there?

I would be particularly surprised if any female says she wants to live in such a place under Taliban control.

Many people have also said that there were positive aspects of their governance, but they banned almost anything which is remotely "fun".

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

I see a few people here support the Taliban and believe them to be a very good form of government, but yet these individuals seemed to have left Afghanistan to settle in the West, either while the Taliban were in power or before or after that. I feel that the Taliban implement unnecessary laws.

I for one would probably not want to live in such a repressive society.

To those who support the Taliban, why would you like to live under their rule?

Why don't you go to one of the Taliban-controlled districts in Afghanistan to experience how life is over there?

I would be particularly surprised if any female says she wants to live in such a place under Taliban control.

Many people have also said that there were positive aspects of their governance, but they banned almost anything which is remotely "fun".

Taliban are better than any other form of government we have seen in the last 40 years in Afghanistan. They are closer to Islam than any other government in Afghanistan.

But they are not the ideal type of government. Not because they are repressive but because they lack competencies to govern appropriately.

[El Camello]

Taliban are better than any other form of government we have seen in the last 40 years in Afghanistan. They are closer to Islam than any other government in Afghanistan.

But they are not the ideal type of government. Not because they are repressive but because they lack competencies to govern appropriately.

I agree that they had good intentions but were largely incompetent.

However, they did have many bogus laws.

[Khostai]

^The Best govermnet in 40 years plus the closest to Islam and still thay can't govern appropriately? Even women on pms are not that contradicting like what you are saying now lol

[El Camello]

^The Best govermnet in 40 years plus the closest to Islam and still thay can't govern appropriately? Even women on pms are not that contradicting like what you are saying now lol

Do you think they were better than Najib, Hekmatyar, etc.?

What about Karzai?

[Khostai]

Do you think they were better than Najib, Hekmatyar, etc.?

What about Karzai?

No they were failures, like all the others in the past 40 years.