Taliban Commander's Letter to Malala Yousufzai

[khushal]

i find it hard to believe that someone who understands how to spell "institution" and "curriculum" should not know how to spell "break" and instead spell it as "brake". That is a deliberate mistake to make it seem like it was written by someone who is very likely of not knowing English that well. For instance, a Talib. And if this is a letter to malalai then why is it written in English and not Pashto?? Why is it typed on a computer rather than written on a simple piece of paper??

"curriculum" and "institution" are words that are commonly used in paksitani schools and most paksitanis don't know how to write in Pashto.

so far I have only met one paksitani in my life that knew how to write in Pashto and he told me he learned it from a village mullah.

[Registerwal]

So if Malala would be a Khattak he had enjoyed Malala´s suffering or the attack on her?

[khushal]

^^The remark of an idiot farsiban.

[Khostai]

Why is my comment deleted??? What is going on here???

[Khostai]

You people still think all talibs are evil now?

Yes

[DaZahroJaam.]

well then. in that case, i would like to mention that kabulies can write pashto just fine. furthermore, that wasn't my point. a person who can spell those things should be able to spell break too. someone is doing a lousy job of pretending he is a talib. and by someone,( just because you are all too stupid to figure it out on your own) i don't mean the person who supposedly wrote this letter.

[khushal]

well then. in that case, i would like to mention that kabulies can write pashto just fine. furthermore, that wasn't my point. a person who can spell those things should be able to spell break too. someone is doing a lousy job of pretending he is a talib. and by someone,( just because you are all too stupid to figure it out on your own) i don't mean the person who supposedly wrote this letter.

the writer is not kabuli and neither is malala so I don't know why you mentioned that.
you don't get it. brake is not spelled wrong, the writer does not understand there is more than one way to spell it. and the other two words are used everywhere in schools. just because one word is longer than the other does not mean anything. you are grasping at best. Everyone knows who this guy is, he has been in the papers before. you have to read the source explanation of who this guy is. it is not that hard. stop being arrogant and humble yourself.

[DaZahroJaam.]

it's sad enough that plenty of you have humbled yourselves. i would like to spare myself the humbleness and question things until they start making sense rather than believing what some pakistani channel who is in good regards of a terrorist has to say about his character. that happens to be the sort of humbleness that God has gifted you with. i wasn't blessed enough.
i mentioned the kabulies because i figured it would be a good opportunity to sprinkle salt over your wounds. seeing how you and that manzareh are always criticizing non pashto speaking afghans of being full of hatred for pashto, pashtons and whatnot.
tell me something kushal..do you not feel ashamed that you back stab your own fellow pashtons in the back by saying they don't or barely understand or read pashto when you as well as i know of various members who are the only individuals contributing to the pashto language and literature sections in this forum?? why, now that i recall, i have never heard you speak or write in pashto. not even use roman letters to type pashto sentences..
i would like to ask yousefzai pakhton, feroz afridai and shehbaz khan to kindly shed some light over which mullah gave them their knowledge of the pashto language as khushal here likes to claim on their behalf.

this was written by a family friend who happens to be a hazara...i would say choke and die from shame but i am afraid, in order for you to experience that, you have to have some knowledge of the language by the mullah which you seem to have been clearly deprived of.





people like you are only good for one thing. spreading hatred and fitna. may shaitan abandon you.
and za fiqer na kawom, za fiker kawom.

[khushal]

DZJ, te fiqir ke wai che ze pakhtun na yum?

Also I was referring to pak Pashtuns that I have met in real life including my cousins who were born and raised in peshawar. they write Urdu and English. My criticism was towards the institutions. Don't be so desperate.

[Shamlawar Khurasani]

Why should he write the letter in pashto? He is being kind to her by addressimg her in her own language. After all she is angrez now.

[Badlun]

I'm not actually defending the TTP's action of shooting a little girl, but the Prophet Muhammad did order the beheading of a Jewish girl, as well as the entire male population of the Banu Qurayza for their action (or lacks thereof) at the Battle of the Trench.


There's a whole lot of people who don't know the history of Islam. I wonder if they will still be a Muslim if they learn a little about it. I love when they get shaken and question their believes. I'm perfectly secure with mines

If the prophet Muhammad did order beheading a girl then it is a Sunna and you should defend shooting of Malala as an act of virtue and Jihad!

This is why I always try to explain that Prophet Muhammad was prophet only for religion(beliefs, worship, morality) and beyond these three spheres he was just a common man who would fight as a commander, and perform his duties as a political Arab leader but not at all as a prophet.

Otherwise beheading little girls, having 12 wives, marrying a 7 or 9 years old girl , killing entire male population of an enemy tribe etc will be Sunna, obligatory for all Muslims and the world would be a hell.

The same is being applied by Wahabis/Salafis and we see what happens in Taliban and Al Qaeda controlled areas in the world like Waziristan and Afghanistan.

[khushal]

^^Its 9 wives and the girl was 12-16 your mixing up your numbers mr Sufi

[ډګروال]

excuse me guys

Adnan Rasheed worked at pakistani ariforce as a technician.
he wrote in english so that more people than just mulala understand it.

[Badlun]

^^Its 9 wives and the girl was 12-16 your mixing up your numbers mr Sufi

Let us consider it 9 wives and 12 years, so is it a Sunna to marry 9 wives and with 12 years age?

However

Bukhari , the so called most authentic book after Quran says this

Sahih Bukhari Volume 7, Book 62, Number 64
Narrated 'Aisha:
that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death).


Sahih Muslim Book 008, Number 3310:
'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported: Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) married me when I was six years old, and I was admitted to his house when I was nine years old.

According to Anas ibn Malik, the Prophet Muhammad used to visit all eleven of his wives in one night; but he could manage this, as he had the sexual prowess of thirty men.[Sahih Bukhari 1:5:268]

The historian Al-Tabari calculated that Muhammad married a total of fifteen women, though only ever eleven at one time; and two of these marriages were never consummated.[Al-Tabari, Vol. 9, pp. 126-127.] This tally of fifteen does not include at least four concubines.

Here are details of prophet Muhammad's wives and concubines with Islamic sources

List of Muhammad's Wives and Concubines - WikiIslam

[randolph85]

A senior representative of Tehrek-e-Taliban has said they will shoot Malala Yousafzai if she chose to return to Pakistan.

The representative said that the group had no sympathies with the teenager, who was shot last year for demanding education for girls.
The representative said that neither was Adnan Rashid a senior commander of the Taliban nor did the Taliban have anything to do with the letter that was written to Malala on Wednesday.
According to the Express Tribune, he said that Malala had been targeted because of her efforts in promoting secular education in Pakistan.
The representative said that the Taliban Council had obtained the draft of the letter that Rashid had sent Malala, and whether it had any content that went against the rules of the Taliban was being assessed.
He added that the council will also look into the purpose for which the letter had been written to Malala.
Taliban's prominent leader in Pakistan Adnan Rashid said that he was 'shocked' after Malala was attacked by the Taliban in October last year.
Rashid had been convicted in 2003 by the state of Pakistan for trying to assassinate former president Pervez Musharraf.
He wrote Malala advising her to return and join a religious school for women in Swat, the report added. (ANI)
- See more at: Afghanistan News - 'Real' Pakistan Taliban vows to kill Malala on return to country