A united Pakistan and Afghanistan

[Nadir Shah]

A big example is of the afghan communist or socilaist inqilab of noor muhammad tarakai. peolpe were not ready and they brought inqilab and we see afghanistan red till today.

I would not agree with you in entirety but that, I believe, is the point, readiness of masses.

[Shayesta]

Tell me what you think of the two countries unified.

What I am thinking is; Shlombay? Are you out of your mind!?

We can call it "United states of Asia" The two of us.

United States of Asia or United Slaves of America?

Pakistani Pashtuns are allergic to Loy Afghanistan. We should be fair and make it USOA

And we, Afghans, are allergic to our enemies and you actually want us to unity with our enemies? What good are 30 million Pukhtoons in Pakistan getting that another 15 million should follow them?

Do Punjabis have 10 babies like we do?

If you are expecting all Pukhtoons to get educated once unified, do you truly believe first thing the educated ones will do is bring ten children to the world, just to outnumber other ethnics? Man.......

Why Bacha Khan baba prefer to be burried on the other side of Durnaline.

If majority Pakistanis portray him as a traitor, then why on earth would he want to be buried between a bunch of unthankful and idiotic creatures?

[Son of Mountains]

Munga thabaah shu islamabad da laasa

Da senga wrora????
Our own nation had done nothing in this destruction?

[Son of Mountains]

My wish is
A united Pakistan
A strong Afghanistan
In both countries, pashtuns must have good share in the respective Govt.

[AfghanSoulja]

er shlombay so far the only point you have by which pashtuns will be able to overtake the punjabis is by popping out more babies than the punjabies can

thats a .. good plan, but you should know that ISI can easily foil this plan by promoting the use of contraceptives among the pashtuns

[Son of Mountains]

I am against this idea. we need LOY Afghanistan. I do not want to be called Pakistani.

Who call you pakistani....u r hidden Afghanistani actually

[Shayesta]

^ Hidden Afghanistani because he doesn't want to be called Pakistani? Does the same apply to Maseed, BLS, Master, Qrratugai, Khaney, Farhan, Muhsina, etcetera?

@Shlombay
Surely our present situation is hurting us! But what makes you think 15 million Afghans want to live under Punjabi rules? Just like how Pakistani Pukhtoons point their fingers at Tajiks when we are in trouble, exactly same wise our people point their finger at Punjabis when Pakistani Pukhtoons are in trouble. Our people are striving for unity with Tajiks, while Pakistani Pukhtoons think Punjanis are their 'loyal' countrymen. We can't even decide who our true enemy is so what made you think we can decide how to satisfy one another?

I would be the most happiest person on earth if Pukhtoons unite, honestly. But what's more important to me is our stability and education to the level we can manage our own state and understanding of how to manage at least 45 million people. Right now, none of the Durrand Line side is capable of that and none of the side is able to satisfy those whom they have besides them right now, let alone 45 million people. We have been fighting so many times when we were/are united (first Iranians, and now Tajiks and Punjabis) that we can't afford to unite with others again. We must learn to stand on our own two feed and if we ever think of changing our country's demography on the world map, then it must be changed in a way it benefits both of the sides. In Afghanistan Tajiks won't allow extra 30 million Pukhtoons, in Pakistan 30 million Pukhtoons despite of being more educated than our side already are falling for the made-up trap. What guarantees we Pukhtoons of Afghanistan won't fall in the same trap and that like them we won't be most underdeveloped people of 'United States of Asia' as well?

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Da senga wrora????
Our own nation had done nothing in this destruction?

Of course, we are the most to blame for this all. And do you why? Because like donkeys we followed other people's interests over others. 30 years ago we fought US, Pakistan's and Saudi's war on our soil, even today we have Pashtuns who will support someone else's stance over their own. This isn't a coincidence that our areas are the worst off. However, one of the ways to remedy these issues is to recognize our interests (aka Pashtuns/Afghans) and somebody elses (i.e. India, Pakistan, Peerangyaan, etc).

[erlangner]

To understand this cooperation, we should look at the world history, although it seems very difficult however time does it and will do it again.
Very recently, USSR was the 1st or 2nd most powerful country in the world sitting on the throat of Germany in Berlin and USA was sitting on the remaining body of Germany. What happened suddenly? USSR and USA saw unification of Germany helplessly. Now one can see everywhere in Germany in different parks etc Deutschalnd id unteilbar, 3 Oktober 1990, means Germans are indivisible, 3rd october 1990. Same will happens to pashtoon. It does not matter pashtoons happy or not happy, but sooner or later this Pakistani army armed with atmoic weapons will be watching and international commissions will deciding for the indus river as the eastern border of Pakhtoonistan or Afghanistan. It is very much bitter, but un-natural conditions cannot prevails, is the decision of nature. Then stability will come. The today instability is hidden this un-natural division of people. People will see, how Kashmiris will get together. How one can diviide such units so brutally.
But one thing is there, The awakened and wise nations put these changes as per their wishes, however, sleeping and aggressive and emotional nations like Pashtoons, time decide for them, and they accept the decision of times, like they did in 1893, then in 1947, then in 1971, then in 1978, then in 1991, again in 1996, and again in 2001. They are completely dependent what time decide for them.