debate between pakistan solider and taliban scholar

[takari_sharsi]

A Debate Between Pakistan Army Soldier and Taliban Scholar Part -1 - YouTube

[emkhan]

Very well answers by Talib jan. The army thug was asking stupid questions.
I appreciate the talib guy.

[Alchemist]

It's interesting that 18:34 the taliban scholar says that at the time of the Soviets when they (mujahids) were receiving aid from Pakistan they didn't see the Pakistanis for who they were...but after the soviets they see them unveiled. He even says that they made a mistake ...how much is "unees u sal talees"? But I don't understand ..why does this Taliban consider Pakistan his home country and then speak as if he was on the frontlines of Afghanistan?

[emkhan]

It's interesting that 18:34 the taliban scholar says that at the time of the Soviets when they (mujahids) were receiving aid from Pakistan they didn't see the Pakistanis for who they were...but after the soviets they see them unveiled. He even says that they made a mistake ...how much is "unees u sal talees"?

But in the debate if you see the talib's arguments carries more weight.
and what is "unees u sal talees"
the army thug is a big munafiq amrican slave.

[Alchemist]

he said that jihad became farz after some year ..19 something... what year?

[emkhan]

1947

[Al Hanif]

Quote from Youtube.

TTP are not at all the army of Imam Al Mahdi (AS). . .They are the forces of Kharjites that Holy Prophet (SA) fortetold us that they will be a part of Dajjal's army and will fight against Muslims. . . . .

These Kharjites will face a terrible fate. Pak Armed Forces will slaughter them in this world and in the hereafter they will be the DOGS OF HELLFIRE . . . .

ra688 il y a 7 heures
TTP are kharjites and according to Hadith they are DOGS OF HELLFIRE . They will be destroyed completely by Pakistan Armed Forces. Islam never allows Armed Aggression against the Muslims rulers and their authority...

Islam never allows Suicide Bombing, killing of Innocents and bombings of Mosques . I would request all to read the FATWA ON TERRORISM by Dr. Tahir ul Qadri against these DOGS of HELLFIRE i.e Tehreek e Taliban Pakistan. . . .

ra688 il y a 7 heures

Is Pakistan an Islamic state ? No.

Is Pakistan implementing sharia ? No.

Is Pakistan taking Americans as their friends and protectors against muslims. Yes.

So Pakistan is definitely an apostate state.

Islam never allows Armed Agression against the Muslims rulers and their authority.

Pakistani rulers are not muslims, they are apostates.

Why we Pakistani People are Fighting against our Muslim Brothers??? only to please Americans? yes it is, this Pashtoon man looks more truthfull,,,
pakifungama il y a 8 heures

Indeed...
...
...
...
...

I have a question !

Do Pakistani Talibans (TTP) pledge allegiance to Mollah Omar ? Or to somebody else ?

[Karachi]

taliban guy made more sense. the army guy sounded like a Ghulam, which he is

[Afghanistan2010]

The voice of the TTP spokesperson is very intense,he is the spokesperson for the TTP Umar Media videos.

[PakistaniAtheist]

Hi this debate is between an educated smart Pakistani soldier using logic reasoning against a simple minded Pathan bhai who is a quran literalist taking the world for simple white or black. All of you supporting this Talib according to his reasoning you are all murtads because you live in western countries support their dajjal system you pay tax contributing to their military. So you deserve to be killed according to this Talib backward guy. The more he shows arrogance the more you cheer for his ghairaat imaan unlike the coward beghairaat pakistani soilder but you are just like that Pakistani solider when I ask you why you live in kaffir country in kaffir system with your families. You give your majboori reasons you tell me that it is not simple white or black just like this Pakistani solider who use reason unlike simple minded Pathan bhai mulana who only see the world straight. If I tell you and show you from your own muslim sources your contribution to kaffir dajjal system kills muslims you should leave for muslim land you wont because you are not that stupid. Its you dont believe in what quran teaches living in kaffir landing supporting kaffir system having career education with family or you like pakistani solider dont see world as black and white. Here you are but supporting simple minded talib bhai who only see one way. You people are hypocrites. Talib bhai doesnt know that without pakistan support shelter control claim over border he will be dead with in 1 day. He lives in Waziristan thanks to pakistan not going to war. He is alive because Pakistanis are not stupid like mullavi omar who burnt whole of afghanistan for one arabic guy. Why are you guys sitting in kaffir dajjal countries supporting their system with your families with education career business tax money. In this case you are very smart and put your quranic teaching away pretend to be ignorant like any reasonable smart person will. Only your religion make you act stupid and support this stupid talib mentality. Just look at your self to understand what the Pakistani solider was saying. This is why you are not fighting jihaad on the ground but behind from computer it is that simple. You are not simple backward minded crazy believing in some jewish abrahmic god fantasy stolen by christains and muslims.

Later pathans blame pakistanis punjabis for their twisted sense of ghairaat jihaadi pride taking jewish fairy tales from arabia seriously word for word. Why pakistanis are not fighting kaffirs? same reason why you living in kaffir country. Its exact same reason logic. Yet here you are supporting this jahil village backward Talib mentality who still thinks the world is flat and drones are demons from jahanam controlled by blackmagic.

[sokaniwaal]

But in the debate if you see the talib's arguments carries more weight.
and what is "unees u sal talees"
the army thug is a big munafiq amrican slave.

Wah wah more weight...
i can't express my opinion about this mullah in english that's why..

Pa Pukhto ke,

Da mullah argument zka drana khkari che agha da sara mani na, che da mashumano qatal wale kege?

Pa islam ke Khudkushi Haram da haram pejanai, aw che dumra da batoor zaman de, no pa america ke pa lakono munafiqeen de, lar de she pa yo stadium ke de oke che somra pake mre, dalta pa khpalo pukhtano bande attack kae..

Pa jumatono ke damake kae...
No Pa Aghe ke che kam Quran Majeed aw ahadees book oswazedal da aghe ba sok zemawar we..
dase kho agha kafir om na kae
che Kam bible ya nor books ye we da aghe hifazat kae..

No da zaliman kho om khpal muqtadas ketabona swazae (Nauzubillah)

Aw tolo na lwe khbra da che yo insan haram shy zan da para halal ke, no sahe dalayel tol bya mat she, zka da mulah os da na mani..

[Soldat_Amir]

I find it quite amusing, how this Taliban scholar was not caught, through a tracking device and sent to jail where he belongs. Plus I think I have heard his voice on the TTP videos before.

Its cute to seeing Taliban Bhai and Pakistan Army Bhai speaking in such a civilised way, through a telephone, its sad they couldnt meet up, I guess that would make the ISI look abit more exposed than usual.

[Afghanistan2010]

Oh if you have seen how many of these napak soldiers were killed in past years...they are nothing for the Taliban soldiers,because most of them are local tribal people who have deep and experience in warefare and these napak soldiers can't even hold a simple compound even with their weaponary and chinese made AH-Helicoperts

[takari_sharsi]

A Debate Between Pakistan Army Soldier and Taliban Scholar Part -2 - YouTube

[Talal]

so its ok for u guys to use footage from the movies that theses 'kuffar' basterds made ?