Was Jinnah a Sahabi?

[Yaggi]

************************************

[unknownprince]

Karachi,

^How are you so sure Pakistan will exist? How are you so sure America will exist? Or China will exist?

This world is changing very rapidly. The suffering of the Afghans will not go on forever.

Time can not go backwards.

The greatest crime of Pakistan is bending to American pressure, and allowing the US to conduct drone attacks, and also allowing US supply routes to Afghanistan.

[tor_khan]

Jinnah is respected simply because he created a seperate state for muslims, it wasn't only Jinnah who did this, it was a whole movement started even well before Jinnah, and 99% of pakistanis wouldn't want to be with India even today, doesn't matter how many problems there are in pakistan, and i dont consider myself a pakistani nationalist, just because i am defending the existence of the country doesn't make me a nationalist. Even Shehbaz khan is not a nationalist, he is only countering the crap being spread against pakistan on this forum from people who have never even been inside pakistan. Pakistan as country will survive, i know you also want to see it break, but it wont happen, keep dreaming.

Interesting statistic - 99%. Did your sample include Baluchistan?

One thing is clear, your passion runs high to the point where you speak in certainties, eg, 'Pakistan will survive'. Even the religious and secular wings within Pakistan are fighting over the way the country should be run, so nothing is certain.

All else said, tell me Karachi Jan, on balance are you be able to consider the notion that an undivided India would have been 'better' for most hardworking, balanced Muslims in retrospect?

[Toramana]

Pakis believe Pakistan is a kind of God's gift to humanity to last till eternity and destined to achieve some divine glory. The fact is that it got dismembered once (1971) and, plagued with corruption and terrorism, is fast on the way to the dustbin of history. Jinnah and all Muslim League leaders were dishonest to the core and were used by the British Empire to keep Indian freedom movement divided.

An error of history, it needs to be undone. Separating Punjabi and Urdu speakers who are the same people as other people of Gangetic plains need to return to their original source.

pa dranavi

[afghan]

the reason i have posted it here and to see the reaction of patriotic pakistanies like shabaz and many other, how much jinah is admired by pakies. how much the young kids are brain washed in schools even the teachers believe now that he was a holy man. there is a hadis "
The Messenger of Allah, Sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam, said: the one who sees me in a dream has truly seen me for indeed the devil can not take my shape to deceive people.
when jinah was told to creat a muslim state and lead the nation. did the prophet tell him to serve the british and apoint them on high level positions? why would prophet ask for a puppet state to be created. the hindustan was ruled by muslim non has claimed seeing prophet in their dream.