Mixed Discussion: Jinnah, Drinking and Creation of Pakistan

[Espresso]

Jinnah himself and his struggle is so much controversial. It is quoted and interpreted completely different on 180 degrees in Pakistan and the remaining world. Some scholars in Pakistan like Dr safdar mehmood and dr israr tried their best to prove he was very much religious person, however others are there who are proving him a secular politician. Both claim to be Jinnah lovers.
However there are other scholars who deny his struggle as the real struggle in politics. They claim he was a puppet in Britains hands.
That is why he was given such a gesture thta he is a great leader equalling Gandhi, however he did not have the capability. It was the reason why he was unable to dismiss the firts army chief although he refused to obey his orders.

As far as his private life is concerned, like drinking, eating pig, marrying parsi girl etc are his private things, and we are not answerable for his actions.

But above all what he was, he have had qualities therefore he was choosen by Britains as he has the abilities to bring their plans into actions.

well said spot on !

not only the indian muslims and bangladeshis his pakistani nationalism under the pretext of religion has even put Afghans/khyber pakhtoonkhwa/baluchistani and kashmiris under the dirty wrath of the most malicious entity for the entire muslim world called the Pakistan Army and I.S.I

[erlangner]

One thing very much clear about Jinnah, that he did one very much best thing to pashtoons donating 1/3rd of his property to Islamia college peshawar. The worse thing he did to pashtun was to crash Khudai Khitmatgar, who were propagating peace harmony in Pashtun society. It was due to him that khudai khitmatgar movements schools, offices and office bearers were jailed and tortured. What he did with balochis is not our issues. The worse thing which he did is then announcement of urdu as the national language under the influence of Liaqat Ali Khan. Due to this mistake Bagla desh went away, although role of Begalis was much in creation fo pakistan than the present day Pakistan geography. However, our issue is to discuss his role which affected Pashtuns.
It is ok, he drank, but it did not harm pashtuns. Sangar is saying he did not know how to pray, but brother sangar, if his not praying did any thing wrong to us. nothing.

His crash and action against Khudai Khitmatgar destroyed the pashtun politics and social workers movement. This loss is much than anything else.