Did you support Pakistan's illegal act of aggression in their Swat operation?

[ghundal]

I would especially require the input from Pir Rokhan, Toramana, Khyaal, Comrade, BLS, Maseed, and company.

Thanks

I would like to discuss this, and see what especially, the above think of this.

Knowing where the other person stands on a specific issue is beneficial before a proper debate (which I doubt exists in regard to this) can ensue. So far, on all the occasions I have asked Toramana and Khyaal about this, they never answer me.

[KingKhan]

If your going to make a poll, make it a little less bias.

[Nokia_Apridy]

hahaha Pir lala ba kha Post wakey hasay hem da ISI Tavez Gaharay ka garzaye...

Bls khu da ISI pa Doc laru Green Card ya wagestu awo Wos ya Khleaf shu sam chalak da..

Khyal khu da ISI da KHEY las KAshoga da gani 18 feb 2008 election Boycot ba ya na kwalay.....

Awo Patay shu MAsed haga Spen kas wo da Pukhtunkhwa ZKa Ban shu...

[ghundal]

I request Pir Rokhan to vote here instead of sending me PMs, and refusing to answer my question. Did you support Pakistani Army operations against Swat? If yes, then who is the servant of Pakistan, you or me?

[graveyardofempires]

Ghundal sam dey wechechel

very good polls lately,

[graveyardofempires]

hahaha Pir lala ba kha Post wakey hasay hem da ISI Tavez Gaharay ka garzaye...

Bls khu da ISI pa Doc laru Green Card ya wagestu awo Wos ya Khleaf shu sam chalak da..

Khyal khu da ISI da KHEY las KAshoga da gani 18 feb 2008 election Boycot ba ya na kwalay.....

Awo Patay shu MAsed haga Spen kas wo da Pukhtunkhwa ZKa Ban shu...

da te se gadeywadey way?

support dey ko ka ne?

[ghundal]

Here is Pir Rokhan's reply to my question in PM

He accused me of being an ISI agent serving Punjab, but look at his response below. Who is the enemy of Afghanistan?
You think this is paki propaganda? LOL, Pakistan received billions in aid for their support for US-NATO war against Afghans. You are blind. His words below


I welcome NATO presence as it is a check on paki intervention and I ask for paki army operation agaisnt the terrorists not the pashtuns. paki army will never take that action in NWA as they have harrboured all terrorists there which they use as a strategic asset agaisnt afghans and americans. you fool get an education and know the correct perspective. I cant participate in ur thread as it will be encouraging paki propaganda.
And it does matter weather you are an afghan or paki as in the former u might be a fool who needs guidance but in the latter u r for sure an enemy of afghans.

Pir Rokhan

[BLS_1919v2.0]

The poll is a little biased. The same army were supporting a lot of these so-called taliban, and then under US pressure and the distress of the people there went into the operation. On one hand majority of them were their dogs, on the other I dislike the Pakistani army in Swat harassing locals. If I had to choose, I would say ideally no, with Pakistani agencies leaving as well.

[Bengal_Tiger]

Ghundal you shouldn't post private messages in public, that is dishonourable.

Though I don't agree with Pir Rokhan, he is a good man and a patriot who wants the best for Pashtuns.

Starting threads like this, which are not even serious discussions but name calling basically, and labelling people traitors are not productive and do not help Pashtuns.

You should refrain from such behaviour brother.

Thanks.

[emkhan]

I don't want to see a single army man or isi hypocrite in swat.

[graveyardofempires]

The poll is a little biased. The same army were supporting a lot of these so-called taliban, and then under US pressure and the distress of the people there went into the operation. On one hand majority of them were their dogs, on the other I dislike the Pakistani army in Swat harassing locals. If I had to choose, I would say ideally no, with Pakistani agencies leaving as well.

talib+army=a big game?

[BLS_1919v2.0]

talib+army=a big game?

Not always, but in certain instances there was collusion. Swat was an example of that.

[graveyardofempires]

Not always, but in certain instances there was collusion. Swat was an example of that.

so were sufi muhamad and mullah radio working for army?

[faye]

i think these polls are self serving to the creator of them as this persons mind is closed to any information that doesn't support his view.

[IamDZJ]

what a dumb ****.