What does Afghanistan have to do to improve its status?

[Son of Mountains]

That was the past.

Mashallah many pashtuns of Pakistan do not consider themselve Afghan.

look at afridi he is a proud pakistani.

they are 2 different things. you are confusing yourself.

Look in the world map. its not one country.

right said punjabi wrora

[Punjabi]

Pashtuns can never become Afghans.

That was when Pakistan was Afghanistan.

Just like how Tajiks of Afghanistan say they are not Tajikistani. same thing.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Pashtuns can never become Afghans.

That was when Pakistan was Afghanistan.

Just like how Tajiks of Afghanistan say they are not Tajikistani. same thing.

Panjabi if you don't understand even these basic things, then it would be best if you read up on them. Lollzz now you are commenting on the history of tajiks as well? Do you know their culture or history, because that is a bad example.

[Punjabi]

Panjabi if you don't understand even these basic things, then it would be best if you read up on them. Lollzz now you are commenting on the history of tajiks as well? Do you know their culture or history, because that is a bad example.

you are Pashtun nationalist and you dont know what you are talking about.

Pashtun does not mean Afghan.


Afghan is a nationality.

Tajik uzbek hazara and pashtun of Afghanistan are Afghan

pashtun punjabi sindhi baluchi of Pakistan are Paksitani.


stop please.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

you are Pashtun nationalist and you dont know what you are talking about.

Pashtun does not mean Afghan.


Afghan is a nationality.

Tajik uzbek hazara and pashtun of Afghanistan are Afghan

pashtun punjabi sindhi baluchi of Pakistan are Paksitani.


stop please.

Prove me wrong then. Clearly you know very little about pashtuns, I mean your proof is a cricket player lolzz...please.

BTW you don't know my political orientation, but nice try.

[Punjabi]

My proof is the map.
Pashtuns are Pakistani, not Afghan. If they are born there then they are Afghan

[BLS_1919v2.0]

My proof is the map.
Pashtuns are Pakistani, not Afghan. If they are born there then they are Afghan

Then you are blind. I told you that yes it falls under the state of Pakistan. However, in terms of nation and identity they are Afghan (as I have shown you examples). By your logic, then Palestine does not exist right? Hence there are no palestinians, just israelis, and arabs in west bank and Gaza.

[Son of Mountains]

My proof is the map.
Pashtuns are Pakistani, not Afghan. If they are born there then they are Afghan

If you go to peshawar and ask even a taxi driver that being a pashtun, are you consider yourself an AFGHANi.............his way of looking towards you will tell the truth.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

If you go to peshawar and ask even a taxi driver that being a pashtun, are you consider yourself an AFGHANi.............his way of looking towards you will tell the truth.

That is ignorace son of mountains. When this same peshawri gets his domicile and NIC, or when he needs to get out of the country, trust me he will then realize lolzz. You can't eat the cake and have it too, and ignorance is not a substitute from reality and documentation.

[Son of Mountains]

That is ignorace son of mountains. When this same peshawri gets his domicile and NIC, or when he needs to get out of the country, trust me he will then realize lolzz. You can't eat the cake and have it too, and ignorance is not a substitute from reality and documentation.

wrora, i can never deny the fact that we all are Afghans....Lar aw Bar yaw afghan etc
But i mentioned that thing which i observe! And wanted to realize you that thing and your anti-pakistan false efforts

[BLS_1919v2.0]

wrora, i can never deny the fact that we all are Afghans....Lar aw Bar yaw afghan etc
But i mentioned that thing which i observe! And wanted to realize you that thing and your anti-pakistan false efforts

First of all, you are assuming that my efforts for Pashtuns is automatically anti-Pakistan. Now lets break it down:
1) I too believe in lar au bar yaw afghan.
2) I believe in their political unity
3) I believe that pak policy has been detrimental to pashtuns.

Now if all these are true and I want to suggest Loy Afghanistan as the alternative, does that make me anti-pakistan or pro-pashtun? Better yet, are you suggesting (if what you say is true) that lar au bar yaw afghan is anti-pakistani efforts?

[Son of Mountains]

First of all, you are assuming that my efforts for Pashtuns is automatically anti-Pakistan. Now lets break it down:
1) I too believe in lar au bar yaw afghan.
2) I believe in their political unity
3) I believe that pak policy has been detrimental to pashtuns.

Now if all these are true and I want to suggest Loy Afghanistan as the alternative, does that make me anti-pakistan or pro-pashtun? Better yet, are you suggesting (if what you say is true) that lar au bar yaw afghan is anti-pakistani efforts?

U said right sir.....but for the above points, i want to suggest pashtuns of pakistan to rise for their rights from pakistani Govt

[Punjabi]

BLS,
You are being blind. No one in Pakistan considers themselve as Afghan.

This a theory of pashtun nationalists.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

BLS,
You are being blind. No one in Pakistan considers themselve as Afghan.

This a theory of pashtun nationalists.

lollzz whatever makes you sleep at night.
Son of Moutains, I used to think the same and now I don`t see that as a plausible approach.

[Son of Mountains]

Son of Moutains, I used to think the same and now I don`t see that as a plausible approach.

I expect something better in future for Pashtunkhwa