Pro Pakistan VS Anti Pakistan

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Peshawar is hell for Pashtuns.

I would not call it a hell per say. Many Afghanistan pashtuns have made a very good life there too, and now a generation or two later are locals. However, the bad that happened to Afghans of Afghanistan was in Peshawar, or nowkhaar...whereas other areas like south pashtunkhwa, swat/malakand, FATA, etc did not do those things.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

doesnt peshawar call them muhajir.

Yes unfortunately they do in peshawar. This is something that peshawriis have done and some other parts that is not done in other areas of Pashtunkhwa. I mean compare the attitude of southern pashtunkhwa and fata or malakand to peshawar, trust me its night and day.

[Son of Mountains]

doesnt peshawar call them muhajir.

if they r in freindly circumstances there in peshawar, then i ll respect them a lot as my elder brother..............but if they ll spread hate for my homeland, then term for them is Mohajir in my dictionary....then i ll wish their return to afghanistan.....no arguments will be accepted

[Son of Mountains]

Yes unfortunately they do in peshawar. This is something that peshawriis have done and some other parts that is not done in other areas of Pashtunkhwa. I mean compare the attitude of southern pashtunkhwa and fata or malakand to peshawar, trust me its night and day.

my experience does not matches the words you are claiming here my brother

[BLS_1919v2.0]

What will you tell the pashtunkhwa pashtuns who have reservations against Pakistan?
Son of Mountains, these things actually did happen, and the cops were (corrupt people) terrible towards Afghanistan Pashtuns. They used to harrass them for money. Then at times locals would say bad things about them. However, Afghanistan pashtuns now make a huge chunk of peshawar, and Id like to see their balls this time around harrass them :-).

[Son of Mountains]

what u mean spread hate? so pashtuns spread hate?

wrora, i met many afghan pashtuns who love pak-land.....i found only a few strays who hate pakistan and spread hate for it and try to bring argumentations. I am talking about them......those are mohajirs in my point of view who spread hate for pakistan. and those are my brothers afghans who are kind for pakistan.....simple!

[tor_khan]

if they r in freindly circumstances there in peshawar, then i ll respect them a lot as my elder brother..............but if they ll spread hate for my homeland, then term for them is Mohajir in my dictionary....then i ll wish their return to afghanistan.....no arguments will be accepted

Weren't we all "Mohajirs" at some point in our histories? You, me, everyone else?

When does a person stop being a Mohajir??

[Son of Mountains]

Weren't we all "Mohajirs" at some point in our histories? You, me, everyone else?

When does a person stop being a Mohajir??

dear my concerning thing is only 1 thing...that is one's love or hate for pakistan!

If 1 spreads hate for pakistan after crossing durand line: he is mohajir to me

If 1 does not do it after crossing durand line, either loves pakistan or is neutral: he is most welcome, is not mohajir, he is upon his own land, he is my elder brother

[tor_khan]

dear my concerning thing is only 1 thing...that is one's love or hate for pakistan!

If 1 spreads hate for pakistan after crossing durand line: he is mohajir to me

If 1 does not do it after crossing durand line, either loves pakistan or is neutral: he is most welcome, is not mohajir, he is upon his own land, he is my elder brother

To some the Durand Line is precisely the problem.

To others it's precisely the solution.

Whether one is Mohajir or not depends on whether you think problem or solution.

[Son of Mountains]

^^it depends on the person crossing it......either he brings problems (negativity) or brings solutions (positivity)

[tor_khan]

^
The question was not about people crossing the Durand Line.

It was whether someone thinks the Durand Line is a good thing or not a good thing.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

^^it depends on the person crossing it......either he brings problems (negativity) or brings solutions (positivity)

ironic isn't it...that is how many pashtuns feel about those that cross the indus and ruin our areas.

[Son of Mountains]

^
The question was not about people crossing the Durand Line.

It was whether someone thinks the Durand Line is a good thing or not a good thing.

if u ask to me, i dont believe in durand line......so its not a goood thing

[Son of Mountains]

ironic isn't it...that is how many pashtuns feel about those that cross the indus and ruin our areas.

you are right sir.....i agree with many of the points you bring

[MazloomyarMaseed]

dear my concerning thing is only 1 thing...that is one's love or hate for pakistan!

If 1 spreads hate for pakistan after crossing durand line: he is mohajir to me

If 1 does not do it after crossing durand line, either loves pakistan or is neutral: he is most welcome, is not mohajir, he is upon his own land, he is my elder brother

Spoken like a true Pakistani, I wonder what the PMAP members here would say about this.

You see, you speak like a dictator, if somebody crosses the line and says bad things about Pakistans means hes a Mojjahir?

We will see soon when Pakistan blows your whole village off the ground and we will see if you say such things again, just to tell you know, why dont you stop asking little sons of pak officers and government workers and ask the real people in the idp camps, the day will come when every pashtun will take its revenge on Jinnahpur and you will see.

We will see if the pakistani messiah Jinnah the ismaili non muslim will return to save his indian muslims haha