Imaginary Durrand line

[fzpz]

This is hilarious. Gas station clerk logic. Does more damage than good when you have illeterates 'representing'. Not surprising from the 'death to durand line' click. Good thing they don't make any academic of legal sense, nor could they ever. I suggest reading up on some professional studies rather than illogical and incoherent babbling:

http://www.bu.edu/aias/reports/durand_conference.pdf
http://www.scribd.com/doc/3372077/Durand-line-the-truth
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Durand_Line_Agreement
http://afghanmirror.tripod.com/id25.html
http://www.ecmsas.org/panels/P36_abstracts.pdf

[BLS_1919v2.0]

This is hilarious. Gas station clerk logic. Does more damage than good when you have illeterates 'representing'. Not surprising from the 'death to durand line' click. Good thing they don't make any academic of legal sense, nor could they ever. I suggest reading up on some professional studies rather than illogical and incoherent babbling:

http://www.bu.edu/aias/reports/durand_conference.pdf
http://www.scribd.com/doc/3372077/Durand-line-the-truth
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Durand_Line_Agreement
http://afghanmirror.tripod.com/id25.html
http://www.ecmsas.org/panels/P36_abstracts.pdf

Afghanmirror is a joke and is not a reputable site, wikipedia is barely one and scribd buddy anyone can upload on pdf format. If you want proper academic sources start easy like Selig Harrison.

[tor_khan]

This is hilarious. Gas station clerk logic. Does more damage than good when you have illeterates 'representing'.

Spelling Correction: Illiterate

People in glass houses shouldn't ... etc.

[Shehbaz Khan]

I've seen Pakhtuns of Afghanistan carrying a 'Mohajir Card' in Pekhawar? And we say it's imaginory.. !!

Da Pekhawro Pukhtani khwaindi kabalai malalai,
Khpal pekhawar ta che razi nu hum pa wraka razi .. !!

[BLS_1919v2.0]

I've seen Pakhtuns of Afghanistan carrying a 'Mohajir Card' in Pekhawar? And we say it's imaginory.. !!

Da Pekhawro Pukhtani khwaindi kabalai malalai,
Khpal pekhawar ta che razi nu hum pa wraka razi .. !!

Its imaginary for Pashtuns as we cross it without problems (for the most part)...the "mahajir card" is due to the existence of the state that you support, otherwise it is Afghan land. The poem that you posted was written by nationalists who support Pashtun unity. Ironic for you no?

[Shehbaz Khan]

^ It's without problem and than it's illegal.. Muhajir Card is because you don't belong to this land or If I may say this land doesn't belong to you anymore.. Pashtun Unity is also supported by me but mine and your way is different

Regards

[Toramana]

^ It's without problem and than it's illegal.. Muhajir Card is because you don't belong to this land or If I may say this land doesn't belong to you anymore.. Pashtun Unity is also supported by me but mine and your way is different

Regards

No, it is because some Pashtuns and those (i.e., Punjabi-Mahajar elite) who they are subordinate to (mentally and ideologically) think that the land doesn't belong to Pashtun brothern on the other side of the Durand Line.

Political reality, which is not a permanent condition, aside, who the Pashtun land realy belong to speaking ethnically, culturally, and historically...the Punjabi-Msahajars on the other side of the Indus or the Pashtuns on the other side of the imaginary line?

[Shehbaz Khan]

Keep all your emotions aside and think to whom this land belong right now?

[Michin Khel]

Afghanistan should declare war on pakistan to claim its lost terrorities, i hope they will win the war as afghanistan is graveyard of empires and afghans eat meat instead of vegetables. Skinny pakis will be no match to brawny afghans.

The other option is to buy the land, i am sure pakis will sell KP to afghanistan if trillion of dollars are offered to them.

[Nadir Shah]

Keep all your emotions aside and think to whom this land belong right now?

Malgariya, the defacto control of the territory by the Pakistani state does not invalidate the concept of 'Milli Wahdat' nor does it give ligitimacy to the Durand Line agreement of 1893. If that were the case the defacto control of the State of Isreal of the West Bank and Gaza should be seen as rightful sovereign authority. Same goes for the Iraqi, Iranian, Turkish and Syrian control over Kurdistan. These defacto 'realities' are not concrete and will change according to the geo-political situation in the region. Stronger states and stronger 'defacto' realities have failed to stand the course of time.

[fzpz]

Spelling Correction: Illiterate

People in glass houses shouldn't ... etc.

That's...kind of the point...

Personally i wouldn't want inane verbal diarrhea 'representing' me, but that's just me.

[Shehbaz Khan]

Actually the problem here with all of you (Jasmine Khorai, with due respect) is that when I say something and you dis-agree you all just come and say that I am brainwashed .. That proves that you have nothing else to say about it


Ok I would like to ask you that the treaty through which this land was sold to the Britishers in which statement/clause of that treaty it's written that 'This land must be returned to Afghanistan?'


Manana

[Shehbaz Khan]

And let my next generation come, I will introduce them to you

[graveyardofempires]

Actually the problem here with all of you (Jasmine Khorai, with due respect) is that when I say something and you dis-agree you all just come and say that I am brainwashed .. That proves that you have nothing else to say about it


Ok I would like to ask you that the treaty through which this land was sold to the Britishers in which statement/clause of that treaty it's written that 'This land must be returned to Afghanistan?'


Manana

no one sold the land you are being more than brainwashed

there was treaty liek the one with hong kong
if you hate pashtun unity than thats your own opinion ,no one is goin to waite for you.

you are like somone who want to say as part of british raj
where is your ghairat

[Shehbaz Khan]

^ haha no laka ta way che that land was not sold? Have you read that document?
Who is against Pashtun unity? how can you say that I am against Pashtun unity?

And where is British Raj? LOL

My Ghairat is with me