Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

New/old Video of Idahoan Taliban captive

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • New/old Video of Idahoan Taliban captive

    By DEB RIECHMANN, Associated Press – 5 mins ago


    KABUL, Afghanistan – Spc. Bowe Bergdahl, the only known U.S. soldier held captive in Afghanistan, appears briefly in a newly released Taliban video standing next to a smiling insurgent commander who once threatened to kill him.

    The 24-year-old from Hailey, Idaho, has bags under his eyes and what appears to be an abrasion on his left cheek in the footage. The video was the fourth to appear since he was captured nearly 18 months ago and was provided to reporters Wednesday by IntelCenter, a private, U.S.-based organization that tracks Islamic extremist activities and communications.

    His parents, Bob and Jani, have declined to speak with reporters throughout the ordeal, but Idaho National Guard spokesman Col. Tim Marsano said Wednesday that they had confirmed that the man in the video was their son.

    "They responded that it was him, based on the screen shots," Marsano said. "It's been an extremely difficult year and a half. Without any concrete news, everyday brings more challenges. They do continue to take some comfort in the support they've gotten, from the community, their family and friends."

    NATO spokesman Brig. Gen. Josef Blotz said the coalition was not sure whether the footage was old or new. Bergdahl is seen wearing an Afghan-style, lightweight tan shirt, suggesting that the video was shot during warmer weather.

    "We are still investigating this case and hope Bowe Bergdahl is still fine," he said."


    My note: I have been following this loosely over time because I think the US and NATO officials decided to write him off from the first day.

    It's sad that they would not BARTER. In short, exchange him for 9 or 10 taliban prisoners.

    But the words of this General betray that NATO could CARE LESS about his fate! They are merely polite mincings. Nothing more.

    This case is a minor one compared with for example, Victor Bout, the Russian national recently extradited to the US for no real reason except a big show.

    I hope that good sense will prevail and Bout will be traded by American authorities for some Westerners held by Russia, if there are some.


    This is the only way to operate in all such cases, in my opinion. It's practical and efficient.

    As for Bergdahl, I predicted when he was first found by the Taliban that the worst he would suffer is protein deprivation.
    Sure enough the pictures seem to confirm this ! He looks fine.

    All the huge fuss about the Taliban mistreating or killing him is ridiculous. Based on Mullah Omar's former Eid Message, they are just upset that the US is not even interested in serious negotiations for their own national. Too bad, because the whole DRAMA - which is what the media easily turns it into - is a waste of everyone's time.

    PS: the proper English is "They responded that it is HE". Not "him". Reminder for everyone!
    Last edited by Catya Sher; 12-08-2010, 02:03 PM.

  • #2
    Originally posted by MI6
    Catya Sher AKA FSB

    When you watch the full video you can see a Punjabi Paki British accent speaking to him. I can tell from accents that he must be Mir Puri/Punjabi Paki with a British accent.

    The Taliban used this a bargaining chip to free their Paki sister Aafia. Who cares, the world should never speak to terrorists, who use people as human shields and battle with international forces from civilians homes.

    The only solution is for America to drop a couple of bombs into Rawalpindi and you will see the Taliban will come to an end.
    Would you kindly post the full video so I can hear for myself

    Comment


    • #3
      I assume Mr Mig-23 is referring to the ORIGINAL video released in 2009. There was only a few split seconds where Bowe appears, hair slightly grown out, on this one.

      I haven't learned how to post videos yet. If anyone else wants to, go ahead.

      Then all members here can have a look.

      In today's release, they make a big deal over "an abrasion" on his face, seeming to
      imply that Bergdahl was beaten by his captors. Most likely, he tripped on a twig along the path.

      It actually looks to me as though Bowe has sort of joined the Taliban group.
      He does NOT look like a captive at all.

      There was speculation when he left his base that he abandoned his military position out of disgust for the American war effort in Afghanistan.

      Supposedly, he went willingly with some Afghans who may have turned him over to his present captor group.

      I doubt he planned on that development, but maybe he adapted to their life over this year and a half held by them.

      Comment

      Working...
      X