FB group of Pathan

[Azmal]

I friend send me this page... i have deleted my fb so can not access it...but judging for link its anti-Afghanistan page by a Pathan. What you guys think danger of this kind of page for pashton national interest? Instead of youtube vid of some non-pashton we should first try to put our own house in order.


I-am-a-Pakistani-Pakhtoon-and-thank-u-I-dont-want-loy-Afghanistan/156838081027578

[Wrayun]

That FB page has nothing derogatory about Pukhtoons of Afghanistan or Pakistan.
The YouTube videos are created and mainly directed at Afghan Pukhtoons, if not all Pukhtoons. So, it is imperative for Pukhtoons to get involved in flagging those.

Your comparisons of the two is silly.

[Azmal]

That FB page has nothing derogatory about Pukhtoons of Afghanistan or Pakistan.
The YouTube videos are created and mainly directed at Afghan Pukhtoons, if not all Pukhtoons. So, it is imperative for Pukhtoons to get involved in flagging those.

Your comparisons of the two is silly.

The youtube vid shows the frustration of pashton’s enemies and can never hurt pashtons...while the page above has potential to turn half of pashtons into Hindustani Muslim...cultureless, ta bandi ma bandi makani Fathans…To continue the subjection, and humiliation of pashton using holy Islam as tool…to keep pashtons divided and in check.
It seems deep in your heart you also hold the anti-Pashton view of the page above…no wonder you don’t see the lethalness and danger it posses to pashton nation.

[Azmal]

It's a shame and these are mostly ran by Punjabi Pathans who have blended in Punjabi main stream culture but still have 'Pathan' blood.

I don't want to create a fb account...we need someone to join this page and write in pashto...to see if these are really pashton or some fathan.

[Wrayun]

It seems deep in your heart you also hold the anti-Pashton view of the page above…no wonder you don’t see the lethalness and danger it posses to pashton nation.

Oh yes of course, how could I have not guessed it. Same old ***t..don't you ever get tired of it? Don't you get sick and tired of your pretentious rhetoric....everyone anyone and no matter where is an agent and of dubious character as long as they don't agree with you or take your grandiose arguments apart.

Get over yourself man. Grow up, seriously.

[Azmal]

Oh yes of course, how could I have not guessed it. Same old ***t..don't you ever get tired of it? Don't you get sick and tired of your pretentious rhetoric....everyone anyone and no matter where is an agent and of dubious character as long as they don't agree with you or take your grandiose arguments apart.

Get over yourself man. Grow up, seriously.

lol your such a pansy boy....its not my idea...its very simple logic….even Talitabi supporter like you can comprehend….what Durand legitimization..and continue Punjab occupation real means. Even if you judge it in term of holy islam…we're all the same in terms of ethnicity, and homeland we're different….. in Islam the caliphate is not a single nation, but much like the European union, a organized cooperative of nations each with their own sovereign state and identity in Allegiance towards the cause of Islam. There is no central absolute authority of a Khalifa , the Khalifa acted primarily as a administrator and balance of order…..Contrary to what harlots like you preach….using Pan Islamism to subservient Afghanistan and Pashtons.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

Just report it, it should do the trick...plus this is in a way good news. Majority of the pashtun groups are all about lar au bar, so in haste they create this. There will always be khar pathans on both sides, in real life and in the cyber world.

[Amir al Ghaznavi]

lets raid that biiitch, i already did

[Master Khan]

ignore these punjabi puppets

[Feroza_Banu]

don't get in argument with these type of people. u can just report the group and thats all.
such people will always exist, God knows who they are and what their purpose is.

there are alot of insecure people in this world... and such groups and videos are product of someone's insecurity

[Roshina]

Um. You folks have a problem with a group of Pukhtuns deciding to create a group to unite with other Pukhtuns who share their views of a Pakistani nationality? What the hell. And some are suggesting that we REPORT them?! Why? Do they not have the right to create groups in which call themselves Pakistani? And and and why not?

Goodness gracious. This is just tiring. Do you people seriously like sit around and condemn folks for calling themselves what you don't want THEM to call themselves? If so, go get something to read or something. 'Cause that's just dumb. Let them be.They're not harassing you; why're you harassing them? It's the same old pathetic deal of "*MY views are right, *MY* understanding of identity, *MY* interpretation of history and being Pukhtun is better than yours, so *I* can call myself Afghan and create groups that support loye Afghanistan, but since *I* don't believe you're right in supporting Pakistan, *YOU* cannot call yourself Pakistani."

I don't support Pakistan; I consider Afghan my foremost identity. It is my blood, and my blood cannot change no matter where I go or what I do or believe or say or think. But why should that mean I can't allow another Pukhtun to call her/himself Pakistani instead of Afghan?

[Wrayun]

!

Um. You folks have a problem with a group of Pukhtuns deciding to create a group to unite with other Pukhtuns who share their views of a Pakistani nationality? What the hell. And some are suggesting that we REPORT them?! Why? Do they not have the right to create groups in which call themselves Pakistani? And and and why not?

Goodness gracious. This is just tiring. Do you people seriously like sit around and condemn folks for calling themselves what you don't want THEM to call themselves? If so, go get something to read or something. 'Cause that's just dumb. Let them be.They're not harassing you; why're you harassing them? It's the same old pathetic deal of "*MY views are right, *MY* understanding of identity, *MY* interpretation of history and being Pukhtun is better than yours, so *I* can call myself Afghan and create groups that support loye Afghanistan, but since *I* don't believe you're right in supporting Pakistan, *YOU* cannot call yourself Pakistani."

I don't support Pakistan; I consider Afghan my foremost identity. It is my blood, and my blood cannot change no matter where I go or what I do or believe or say or think. But why should that mean I can't allow another Pukhtun to call her/himself Pakistani instead of Afghan?

Not all sanity is lost. Great post!

This thread and the argument behind is epic fail.

[Toramana]

Actually, this Aqil Khan guy is Hazarawal Hindkowan and has been doing these things since 2008...He created such a group previously but that failed.

[Khidr]

The Pathans/Pashtuns who feel affinity/attachment to the modern state of Pakistan and to its diverse Punjabi, Sindhi and Baluch ethnics groups, are no less or no more Pathan/Pashtuns than the Pashtuns/Pathans who feel affinity to the modern state of Afghanistan and its diverse Tajiks, Hazaras and Uzbeks ethnic groups.

[BLS_1919v2.0]

The Pathans/Pashtuns who feel affinity/attachment to the modern state of Pakistan and to its diverse Punjabi, Sindhi and Baluch ethnics groups, are no less or no more Pathan/Pashtuns than the Pashtuns/Pathans who feel affinity to the modern state of Afghanistan and its diverse Tajiks, Hazaras and Uzbeks ethnic groups.

Khidr don't turn the argument on its head. The issue isn't diversity. Had Pakistan not adopted the policies it did or went about in its creation the way it did....no one here would argue against diversity. Pashtunkhwa and Afghanistan are diverse, that is something we accept and are willing to work within. The military/ISI junta backing the Mullah diesalee alliance on the other hand is just digging our grave.