Herat

[Fish]

What do you mean by "Afghan" ? pashtun or inhabitant of afghanistan.

Afghanistan is land of Afghans. Afghans=Pashtun, Tajik,Hazara,Uzbek and etc.

Whether the nationalists like it or not Afghanistan is land of Afghans and Afghan consists of every ethnic groups.

Nationalists need to thank, I am no leader of Afghanistan otherwise you would never heard the term Pashtun,Tajik,Hazara etc again. I will eliminate these terms and use only AFGHAN.

[آريا]

de hirat pe ddeero kelo keh Pakhtaane (atsakzi, nurzi, aw nor) ham di: http://www.nps.edu/Programs/CCS/Docs...ibal/Herat.pdf

[tor_khan]

Herat looks beautiful - my paternal line goes back to Herat.

[Laila]

Stop making this thread about ethnicity!!! Damn can we not have a thread that involves with language or ethnicity. Seriously! Is it that hard to accept it as an Afghan city of Afghanistan. Damn!


Anyways, Herat is a beautiful city. Just like someone said, clearly the pictures show the clean environment.

[Laila]

How would you like it if a punjabi comes here and starts posting about his city ?

I could really care less of his ethnicity. If he has good photos to share, by all means do share.

[pukhtana]

Herat is a city in Afghanistan that all Pashtuns love and will always love. Historically Pashtuns have been living in Herat. I love these pictures manana for sharing.

[shehram]

Abbotabad Pukhtoonkhwa

[Feroz Afridi]

ايبټ اباد ډير ښائيسته وطن دے خو د افسوس خبره دا ده چې کوم د ښار زړه دے هغه فوځيانو نيولې دے
دغسې هر يو ښار کښې چې کوم خائيسته ځائي وي هغه د فوځيانو چهاونئ وي
او خائيسته ځکه وي چې د عوامو مداخلت پکښې نه وي او فوځيانو هغه ځائي پخپله جوړ کړې وي۔

[Admin Khan]

Herat is a beautiful city. Herat is full of brave Pashtun tribes such as Noorzais, Kakars and so forth.

[IamDZJ]

what the hell is with the competition? it all belongs to one earth. you can't take it to hell with you so leave it alone as it is. it's not a show and tell competition.

[Mayana]

How would you like it if a punjabi comes here and starts posting about his city ?

What the hell kind of comparison is this?
How dare you compare Punjabis to Afghans? Have some shame!
It's a city in Afghanistan, we are all Afghans. If you consider yourself otherwise, Pakistaniyat di mubarak.

Think. Think before you post. That city in itself probably has more Pashtuns than you've seen in your whole life if that is what you care about, so please. THINK before you post.

[IamDZJ]

DaZahroJaam its a lot more than a city. Its our life and they are calling it just a farsiwaan city. Its an Afghan city

so? do you know what afghanistan means? or what an afghan is?
afghanistan is not only home to you pashtoons. it's also a home to uzbaks tajiks and hazaras. no stranger with intentions of creating frictions between you should be allowed to walk in and tell you which one of you belong where.
had you been an honest muslim with a good heart first and a selfish pashtoon, hazara tajik or uzbak later, you wouldnt have claimed to be anything other than an afghan first. you would have not put your own interest ahead of your country by betraying it and defending yourself by denying your own countrymen.
you are a bloody traitor. go ahead fight for yourself and yourself only. tomorrow when some one comes in to your house to tell you which sibling to strangle, do that too.
30 years of fighting among yourselves like a bunch of hungry dogs didn't teach any of you anything. you people don't have any respect for yourself, why should any one else respect you. you can't afford standing up for your country first, your own needs are too dire and overwhelming. i don't know to what, but you have sold off your moral sense of being. insaniyat yaw ta zda na dey, d pukhto khabari kawey.

[IamDZJ]

Your calling me a traitor?

YES
o my goooosh! shadow caster..please please don't speak like that. herat is not dominated by farsiwans. it's home to proud pashtoons.
please please...pashtoons own afghanistan. we are not tajiks or parsiwans.

AND NOT JUST YOU, EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU STINK OF TREACHERY. WHEN YOU DIE AND ROT, THERE WILL BE NO ONE TO BURY YOU. EVEN THE EARTH WOULDN'T TAKE YOU IN. OR AT LEAST I HOPE NOT.

[IamDZJ]

I M NOT A LOT BETTER THAN ANYTHING. IF ANYTHING, I AM A LOT WORST THAN tHIS.
YOU DEFENDED YOURSELF BY SAYING IT'S NOT A FARSIWAN CITY. AS IF BEING A FARSIWAN IS A CURSE OR SOMETHING..YOU DIDN'T DO ANYTHING TO CORRECT ANY ONE FURTHER THAN THAT EITHER. GOOD NIGHT.

[Mayana]

I think the point is that we should defend the city regardless of its Pashtun population. It's an interesting fact to refute Shadow Caster's point, but if it was Takhaar that's being attacked, would be react the same? Or would we say, it's a buncha "Parsiwaans" that deserve being attacked? A few rhetorical questions to ponder upon


Now let's stick to the topic, please.