Why we are fighting eachother down??

[Kushan Prince]

What has Mr. Sadat to do with Pashtuns?

His name tells a big story....SADAT = SAYED = Farsi speaking Kabuli from Arab descent.

Sadat doesn't really equate with arab ancestry because there are both pashtuns and tajiks that carry them as last names but that doesn't mean they are arab.

[MostafaM]

Dear Mostafa,

If we go for your logic half of Pashtuns maybe are no more Pashtuns. Please don´t devide us like this. Forget all these categorization. First we are all human beings belonging to a common family and group. How can one still be an ''Arab'' after 1400years marrying into non-Arab societies? Mr. ''Sadat'' is not from Kabul. That´s what he claims just to sound ''educated''. His family hails originally from Khost and Nangarhar province. Half of his family still live in Khost. He can´t even speak properly Dari. When he was ''professor'' he used to talk only in English. Read his book and biography. Afghanzwak.com is one of his pages he is running with his relatives and friends. Take a look there. Feel free to write him on Tweeter https://twitter.com/nematsadat

Here is a short information about him http://www.khaama.com/afghan-gay-com...of-closet-3013

His family is relativly well known.
His father was a big-time Parchami and with Afghan journalists he talks normally in Dari.

I dont know where you got your informations from but only his mother is a Mohammadzai, his father is a Sadat and Sayeds are a distinguished ethnicity inside Afghanistan.
People carry the terms Pashtun, Tajik, Usbek, Turkmen, Hazara and Sadat in their IDs (taskera).

Sayeds don´t consider themselves as ethnic Pashtun or Tajik. This is a fact.

I don´t divide anyone, I just go by the Islamic and Afghan way of the definition of ancestory. Afghans belong to a patriachal sociaty and the children belong familywise to the family of the father.

And since when you sound "educated" when you claim from Kabul? haha
Kabul isn´t known for education but for other stuff.


To quote your link on Khama.com:

"....“So get over it! Now, I can live life without all the kala jaan’s & kaaka jaan’s (aunties & uncles) harassing and pressuring with questions like, Nematee, tu chura zan nakardee?”..."

He seems to be pretty good in talking Dari since he quotes his aunts so well.

[MostafaM]

Sadat doesn't really equate with arab ancestry because there are both pashtuns and tajiks that carry them as last names but that doesn't mean they are arab.

It does because every Sayed who claims to be from the family of the prophet naturally must have Arab ancestory.

And since people know his family, uncle and father, everyone knows what kinda Sadat he is.

Sadat/Sayed is written under "ethnicity" in your taskera.
I know that because my own grandfather (mother´s side) was a Sayed and had written it in his taskera/ID card.