Tweet
‘A struggle of integration’: Deportation used to counter gang activity within Toronto’s growing Afghan community
Facebook | Twitter | Email | Instapaper
Stewart Bell
Friday, Mar. 22, 2013
AFG gang graffiti in Toronto's Flemingdon Park area, near Thorncliffe Park. Gang members began tagging Afghan neighbourhoods with Afghan For Life (AFL or A4L) and Afghan Fighting Generation (AFG) symbols a decade ago. Peter J. Thompson/National Post
The tattoo on Farhad Abdul Fatah’s right shoulder shows an AK-47 assault rifle over a burning Afghan flag.
AFGUN, it reads.
According to Toronto police, the tattoo is the mark of an Afghan street gang whose members have been implicated in stabbings, shootings, drugs, robberies, thefts and, most recently, automobile-insurance fraud.
Afghan For Life and its more violent-sounding offshoot, Afghan Fighting Generation, emerged partly in Toronto’s Thorncliffe Park neighbourhood, a hub of Canada’s fast-growing Afghan population. Police and immigration enforcement officers have now launched deportation proceedings against several alleged members, including Mr. Fatah, a 28-year-old Russian-speaking Afghan from Thorncliffe Park.
Since 2002, more than 23,000 Afghans have become permanent residents of Canada. Gang members began tagging Afghan neighbourhoods with Afghan For Life (AFL or A4L) and Afghan Fighting Generation (AFG) symbols a decade ago.
“The evidence shows that the AFL/AFG evolved within smaller neighborhoods of Toronto, where a number of Afghan youth lived or went to school,” according to the Immigration and Refugee Board. “The membership of the AFL/AFG is made up largely of persons of Afghan background.”
Members of AFL/AFG range in age from 16 to 24. While most are Afghan, at least one is Iranian. Police said 10 were known to have variations of the ‘AFGUN’ tattoo worn by Mr. Fatah. Over time, the gang armed itself with handguns, clashed with the rival Flemo Boys and shot a member of the Rascals.
“The activities of the members include simply ganging up on a fellow student, evolving to possession of multiple weapons,” the Refugee Board wrote last August when it dealt with Mr. Fatah’s deportation case.
Jehad Aliweiwi, executive director of the Thorncliffe Neighbourhood Office, a local social agency, said gangs were not a significant problem in the area, although he had seen AFL graffiti in the past. “When I used to walk a little bit around the park you will see ‘Afghan’ or ‘Afghan For Life.’ And young kids in our youth centre, we have a lot of Afghan kids,” he said.
But he said he was less worried about gangs than the high drop-out rate among Afghan boys. “That said, I think there is a lot of affinity with a group like the Afghan For Life for maybe social and belonging reasons, Afghan pride and all that,” he said. “I think it’s a new community that’s trying to find its place in here. It’s part of a struggle of integration.”
Toronto's Thorncliffe Park neighbourhood. Since 2002, more than 23,000 Afghans have become permanent residents of Canada. Matthew Sherwood for National Post
Also known as Kanishka, Mr. Fatah was born in Afghanistan in 1985 but fled to Russia shortly after Soviet troops withdrew from the country. He came to Canada as a refugee, arriving in Vancouver in 2003. According to the Refugee Board, his gang involvement began three years later.
“He acquired a tattoo in 2006 commonly used by members of the AFL/AFG,” the Board wrote. “He claims he did so as a symbol of the violence in Afghanistan. Mr. Fatah could not explain why he expended hundreds of dollars and went through hours of pain to obtain a tattoo to symbolize events that he had no personal recollection of.”
Between 2006 and 2011, he amassed a criminal record involving weapons, threats and drugs. He was convicted of possession of a prohibited weapon — brass knuckles — and possession of cocaine and magic mushrooms. He was arrested following a 2009 stabbing (and acquitted after the victims recanted their statements at trial).
By 2010, Mr. Fatah had been seen repeatedly in the company of other AFGL/AFG gang members. An informant told police Mr. Fatah wanted to become a gang leader.
That December, Toronto police responded to a shooting and found Mr. Fatah in a car with three others. A Bryco 380 automatic handgun was found under his seat. Mr. Fatah claimed he found it in bushes outside a Tim Hortons. He pleaded guilty to unauthorized possession of a firearm. In addition to a 224-day sentence, he was banned from possessing weapons for 99 years.
‘I think it’s a new community that’s trying to find its place in here’
The Canada Border Services Agency brought Mr. Fatah’s case to the Refugee Board last year, arguing that as a foreign national and a member of a criminal organization, he should be deported. Mr. Fatah denied any gang affiliation and portrayed himself as a peaceful person with no interest in weapons or violence.
The IRB did not believe him.
“He has not been able to credibly explain his gang tattoos, his repeated associations with gang members, or his weapons possession convictions,” the board wrote in its ruling. A deportation order was issued on Aug. 2.
The crackdown on Afghan gangs is Canada’s latest attempt to use immigration laws to tackle street gangs. Despite being responsible for much of the gun violence in Canadian cities, gang members sometimes escape prosecution because victims won’t cooperate and witnesses fear retribution.
While that makes criminal convictions challenging, in recent years, police and immigration officials have teamed up to try a different approach: breaking up gangs by deporting key members to their home countries.
A wall mural in the Flemingdon Park area of Toronto, near Thorncliffe Park. Peter J. Thompson/National Post
In Montreal, the tactic has been used against Haitian gangs. Honduran gangs have been targeted in Vancouver, while in Toronto immigration enforcement was partly responsible for ending the open warfare between Tamil gangs. Now Afghan gangs have been added to the list.
Since immigration officers went after Mr. Fatah and his colleagues, the AFL/AFG has become involved in automobile accident fraud — staging fake car crashes to collect insurance money, according to police.
But while the gang is still active, it has scaled back its violence, said Det. Const. Steve Kerr, a member of the Toronto Police Service’s Guns and Gang Task Force who testified at Mr. Fatah’s immigration hearing.
“A couple of years ago they were very active with regards to a lot of the violent crime that was happening in around Thorncliffe and that area … and Fatah was one of the well known guys that was trying to be the leader of that gang,” he said.
The deportation order against Mr. Fatah appears to have been a turning point. “Since that decision, things have quieted down. They’re still active but their violence has de-escalated. I guess you could say that they’re more into frauds.”
Mr. Fatah has been in custody since October, 2011. The government is currently deciding whether his deportation is justified when the danger he poses to Canadians is balanced against the risks he could face in Afghanistan, a country he last saw in 1991, when he was six years old. “He is still here,” his lawyer Rodney Woolf said. “He is in detention and the minister is seeking to remove him, that’s all I can tell you at the moment.”
At a detention hearing, he gave his occupation as “grass cutter” and said he needed to get back to work to help his father, who is 60 and on a disability pension. “Maybe you are just looking at his tattoo,” he said, speaking through a Russian interpreter, “that is why you think that he is a member of the gang.”
National Post
• Email: sbell@nationalpost.com | Twitter: [external] StewartBellNP
Posted in: News, Posted Toronto Tags: Canada, Afghanistan, Gangs, Immigration
Facebook | Twitter | Email | Instapaper
Stewart Bell
Friday, Mar. 22, 2013
AFG gang graffiti in Toronto's Flemingdon Park area, near Thorncliffe Park. Gang members began tagging Afghan neighbourhoods with Afghan For Life (AFL or A4L) and Afghan Fighting Generation (AFG) symbols a decade ago. Peter J. Thompson/National Post
The tattoo on Farhad Abdul Fatah’s right shoulder shows an AK-47 assault rifle over a burning Afghan flag.
AFGUN, it reads.
According to Toronto police, the tattoo is the mark of an Afghan street gang whose members have been implicated in stabbings, shootings, drugs, robberies, thefts and, most recently, automobile-insurance fraud.
Afghan For Life and its more violent-sounding offshoot, Afghan Fighting Generation, emerged partly in Toronto’s Thorncliffe Park neighbourhood, a hub of Canada’s fast-growing Afghan population. Police and immigration enforcement officers have now launched deportation proceedings against several alleged members, including Mr. Fatah, a 28-year-old Russian-speaking Afghan from Thorncliffe Park.
Since 2002, more than 23,000 Afghans have become permanent residents of Canada. Gang members began tagging Afghan neighbourhoods with Afghan For Life (AFL or A4L) and Afghan Fighting Generation (AFG) symbols a decade ago.
“The evidence shows that the AFL/AFG evolved within smaller neighborhoods of Toronto, where a number of Afghan youth lived or went to school,” according to the Immigration and Refugee Board. “The membership of the AFL/AFG is made up largely of persons of Afghan background.”
Members of AFL/AFG range in age from 16 to 24. While most are Afghan, at least one is Iranian. Police said 10 were known to have variations of the ‘AFGUN’ tattoo worn by Mr. Fatah. Over time, the gang armed itself with handguns, clashed with the rival Flemo Boys and shot a member of the Rascals.
“The activities of the members include simply ganging up on a fellow student, evolving to possession of multiple weapons,” the Refugee Board wrote last August when it dealt with Mr. Fatah’s deportation case.
Jehad Aliweiwi, executive director of the Thorncliffe Neighbourhood Office, a local social agency, said gangs were not a significant problem in the area, although he had seen AFL graffiti in the past. “When I used to walk a little bit around the park you will see ‘Afghan’ or ‘Afghan For Life.’ And young kids in our youth centre, we have a lot of Afghan kids,” he said.
But he said he was less worried about gangs than the high drop-out rate among Afghan boys. “That said, I think there is a lot of affinity with a group like the Afghan For Life for maybe social and belonging reasons, Afghan pride and all that,” he said. “I think it’s a new community that’s trying to find its place in here. It’s part of a struggle of integration.”
Toronto's Thorncliffe Park neighbourhood. Since 2002, more than 23,000 Afghans have become permanent residents of Canada. Matthew Sherwood for National Post
Also known as Kanishka, Mr. Fatah was born in Afghanistan in 1985 but fled to Russia shortly after Soviet troops withdrew from the country. He came to Canada as a refugee, arriving in Vancouver in 2003. According to the Refugee Board, his gang involvement began three years later.
“He acquired a tattoo in 2006 commonly used by members of the AFL/AFG,” the Board wrote. “He claims he did so as a symbol of the violence in Afghanistan. Mr. Fatah could not explain why he expended hundreds of dollars and went through hours of pain to obtain a tattoo to symbolize events that he had no personal recollection of.”
Between 2006 and 2011, he amassed a criminal record involving weapons, threats and drugs. He was convicted of possession of a prohibited weapon — brass knuckles — and possession of cocaine and magic mushrooms. He was arrested following a 2009 stabbing (and acquitted after the victims recanted their statements at trial).
By 2010, Mr. Fatah had been seen repeatedly in the company of other AFGL/AFG gang members. An informant told police Mr. Fatah wanted to become a gang leader.
That December, Toronto police responded to a shooting and found Mr. Fatah in a car with three others. A Bryco 380 automatic handgun was found under his seat. Mr. Fatah claimed he found it in bushes outside a Tim Hortons. He pleaded guilty to unauthorized possession of a firearm. In addition to a 224-day sentence, he was banned from possessing weapons for 99 years.
‘I think it’s a new community that’s trying to find its place in here’
The Canada Border Services Agency brought Mr. Fatah’s case to the Refugee Board last year, arguing that as a foreign national and a member of a criminal organization, he should be deported. Mr. Fatah denied any gang affiliation and portrayed himself as a peaceful person with no interest in weapons or violence.
The IRB did not believe him.
“He has not been able to credibly explain his gang tattoos, his repeated associations with gang members, or his weapons possession convictions,” the board wrote in its ruling. A deportation order was issued on Aug. 2.
The crackdown on Afghan gangs is Canada’s latest attempt to use immigration laws to tackle street gangs. Despite being responsible for much of the gun violence in Canadian cities, gang members sometimes escape prosecution because victims won’t cooperate and witnesses fear retribution.
While that makes criminal convictions challenging, in recent years, police and immigration officials have teamed up to try a different approach: breaking up gangs by deporting key members to their home countries.
A wall mural in the Flemingdon Park area of Toronto, near Thorncliffe Park. Peter J. Thompson/National Post
In Montreal, the tactic has been used against Haitian gangs. Honduran gangs have been targeted in Vancouver, while in Toronto immigration enforcement was partly responsible for ending the open warfare between Tamil gangs. Now Afghan gangs have been added to the list.
Since immigration officers went after Mr. Fatah and his colleagues, the AFL/AFG has become involved in automobile accident fraud — staging fake car crashes to collect insurance money, according to police.
But while the gang is still active, it has scaled back its violence, said Det. Const. Steve Kerr, a member of the Toronto Police Service’s Guns and Gang Task Force who testified at Mr. Fatah’s immigration hearing.
“A couple of years ago they were very active with regards to a lot of the violent crime that was happening in around Thorncliffe and that area … and Fatah was one of the well known guys that was trying to be the leader of that gang,” he said.
The deportation order against Mr. Fatah appears to have been a turning point. “Since that decision, things have quieted down. They’re still active but their violence has de-escalated. I guess you could say that they’re more into frauds.”
Mr. Fatah has been in custody since October, 2011. The government is currently deciding whether his deportation is justified when the danger he poses to Canadians is balanced against the risks he could face in Afghanistan, a country he last saw in 1991, when he was six years old. “He is still here,” his lawyer Rodney Woolf said. “He is in detention and the minister is seeking to remove him, that’s all I can tell you at the moment.”
At a detention hearing, he gave his occupation as “grass cutter” and said he needed to get back to work to help his father, who is 60 and on a disability pension. “Maybe you are just looking at his tattoo,” he said, speaking through a Russian interpreter, “that is why you think that he is a member of the gang.”
National Post
• Email: sbell@nationalpost.com | Twitter: [external] StewartBellNP
Posted in: News, Posted Toronto Tags: Canada, Afghanistan, Gangs, Immigration
Comment