Communists?

[HalloIsBack]

Aryan Sakazai opened one of his stupid thread with this poll.
How does it come that so much voted for communist?
I can't understand it because communist brought to Afghanistan lots of pain which is still continuing.

[Pisho]

Well I didn't vote because it was all stupid choices
I'd go with Islamic law but that was attached to Taliban which us not exactly the same
And communism failed in it's own country why would anyone in their right mind chose communism in this day and age ? After seeing it fall in Russia :-/

[afghan]

Aryan Sakazai opened one of his stupid thread with this poll.
How does it come that so much voted for communist?
I can't understand it because communist brought to Afghanistan lots of pain which is still continuing.

what do you expect from a stuped poll? a stuped voting result as well.

[Kushan Prince]

Communism has its ups and downs. One of the positives is that it keeps its people in check like controlling the amount of freedom someone has which is not really a bad thing. For example porn websites and magazines and the sale of illegal material which are all banned and serve jail time. Something the west needs to learn from.

[ufo973]

I was shocked too, but i think result is out of a joke, they can't be serious.
I myself also want an Islamic government but i am against Taliban's behavior.

[khushal]

Hallo,
The vast majority of afghan in the west are communists.

[SiiNii]

Hallo,
The vast majority of afghan in the west are communists.

How so?

[HalloIsBack]

Hallo,
The vast majority of afghan in the west are communists.

ok that's why afghans are loving me

@at all: i don't like this system and don't want to represent this system on pf

[MostafaM]

Hallo,
The vast majority of afghan in the west are communists.

As far as I know, the vast amount of Afghans in the west were made homeless by the communists and fled Afghanistan.

Just after 1992 alot of Ex-Communists arrived in the west, mainly in the Netherlands, Sweden, some in England and Germany.

I don´t think your comment is correct.

[SiiNii]

Communism has its ups and downs. One of the positives is that it keeps its people in check like controlling the amount of freedom someone has which is not really a bad thing. For example porn websites and magazines and the sale of illegal material which are all banned and serve jail time. Something the west needs to learn from.

Resist the cultural Marxist indoctrination of your school teachers

I have yet to meet a single person who has actually lived under Communist regimes that regrets leaving.

Restriction of freedom of the press doesn't require Communism at all. See your own Canadian government's actions against 'hate' speech...

[Pisho]

U cannot say that most afghans in the west are communist well first because ur including ur self in it and then.. No one has actually counted lol it's mixed where I live there are a whole bunch of mujaheddin that are hiding the money they stole from Afghanistan :-/ a few religious peope and a whole bung of masood followers that are so jacked up they speak of the guy like a Prophet:-/ which is sickening

[randolph85]

They must be a bunch of lurkers who are too ashamed to admit to being communists among the other pashtuns here.

[Pisho]

TheRe are too many reasons why people won't admit not just one and it's pathetic because if u believe in something why won't u support it till the end
Ahh who cares the system was a failure anyways

[randolph85]

these are the people who just disappeared from afghanistan after 92, literally and figuratively. look at rashid dostum, after najib he was no longer a communist commander but a "mujahadin" commander.

[MostafaM]

We young people can hardly be associated with Khalq/Parcham style communists/ex-communists because this whole crap happened way before we were even able to understand politics.

I think the communists you are talking about, Randolph, have their own websites and communicate in Dari and Pashto.

And since communism itself is not an ideology or a religion but a form of state (the state of a sociaty), no one can actually be a communist per se. You have to live in such a system and work for it´s sustainment otherwise you can´t be a communist.

According to Marxist theory Communism can be achieved after the world has overcome a socialist form of state. As far as we know this hasn´t been accomplished.

So everyone who calls himelf a communist must be a fraud or a guy from the future.
And since time machines haven´t been invented yet, we can go for the first.


There were no Afghan communists.
There were some Afghan socialists who tried to change sociaty but failed.
And there were alot of hacks who just went with the flow and were beneficiaries of that system.