HI my name is Soldat Amir

[Khostai]

hahaha he just made a new facebook profile ...hilarious

http://www.facebook.com/Soldat.Amir

he claims to be from Khost now

OMG what??? He was Pakistany how the hell is he sudenly from Khost???

[ډګروال]

دا بلکول رښتیا وایی
او ار یو کس چی داسی کوښښ کوې نو مخ یی تور دی.
داسی خلکو ته په پښتو کښی متل دی : ،نه د دین شول نه د دنیا

[RevolutionThroughReason]

just another example of this desperation for Pakistanis] wishing they were Afghan.

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Why do You reflect so much on one single persons ideas , errors and problems?
It seems You are glad of the things You all list and attribute to Amir, sometimes even much more than he self has ever said.
Any person can speak for himself, with his thoghts, words, actions. If those three are unworthy to You, do not spend time on discussing unworthy things and do something worthy.
If You have issues to Amiror any other person discussed here by others, isn't it much easier to ask the person the things You do not understand and hear his answer and if he has no answer to make him search and think to find it?

I agree when it comes to his conversion to Christianity, I don't care , but he wants to join overtly hostile groups towards Afghans, I think that should be known

[Tjanaparh]

I agree when it comes to his conversion to Christianity, I don't care , but he wants to join overtly hostile groups towards Afghans, I think that should be known

Than discuss it with him, if it makes You think to create a problem to Afghans and You think Amir's missunderstandings create it, try constructively to work on the root of the problem. This discussion brings no positive results, I am sure You can see it with your critical approach.

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Than discuss it with him, if it makes You think to create a problem to Afghans and You think Amir's missunderstandings create it, try constructively to work on the root of the problem. This discussion brings no positive results, I am sure You can see it with your critical approach.

No there's nothing to discuss, he's a traitor. I will treat him just as I treat Afghanistan2010 and other munafiqeen. No forgiveness No compromiose

[Tjanaparh]

No there's nothing to discuss, he's a traitor. I will treat him just as I treat Afghanistan2010 and other munafiqeen. No forgiveness No compromiose

Dear RTR, it is easy to label everybody as traitors, both Amir and Afghanistan2010(whoes name i do not know) are however from Your country and they are not alone in their position as I see, if You see something goes wrong why labeling people who are from your country? You are nobody to lable somebody as a traitor as long as your actions concernng your nation do not talk for themselves. Here are some people who call You in anyways too! What have You personally done to avoid Your brothers distance from Your nation and become "traitors" as You say?
Shouldn't it be better to work on that issue?

[IamDZJ]

three years ago when i told everyone that he is crazy, no one believed me. he changed his views from one thing to the other, you all gathered up around him and cheered for him.
when he loses his audience, he will adopt a new political and religious stand and at this point the more outrageously ridiculous, the better for him.
i don't know about the rest of you but i am bored.

[Afghanistan2010]

you were supporting him weren't you ?

[IamDZJ]

i knew soldat from a different forum where he got himself permanently banned after acting like a nut case during an argument with me. i couldn't have ever supported him.
wasn't it just yesterday when i told you to eff off and not talk to me anymore??

[IamDZJ]

I have to reveal that you also used to change your views,sometimes pro communism,,sometimes pro islamism....and to be continued when i have more time

there are lots of view out there that coincide with the view of people who favor "communism" or "islamism". it's not my fault that you are blind to patterns of thought other than those two. don't waste my time. you can argue over such meaningless terms with each other like a bunch of dogs for as long as you want. i would rather move on to other subjects so go chew on someone else's brain.

[Afghanistan2010]

It was never my intention to discuss any such issues here but i did not believed that people have made out of themselves clogs

as Allah says in Surah Al Munafiqun :

And when you see them, their forms please you, and if they speak, you listen to their speech. [They are] as if they were pieces of wood propped up - they think that every shout is against them. They are the enemy, so beware of them. May Allah destroy them; how are they deluded?

[KhyberKhan]

Soldat you're too late, they've already got a token brownie.

Might wana try the BNP?

[Karachi]

is soldat even a real person? i find it hard to believe. what if he is some spy pretending to be pashtun?

[RevolutionThroughReason]

Dear RTR, it is easy to label everybody as traitors, both Amir and Afghanistan2010(whoes name i do not know) are however from Your country and they are not alone in their position as I see, if You see something goes wrong why labeling people who are from your country? You are nobody to lable somebody as a traitor as long as your actions concernng your nation do not talk for themselves. Here are some people who call You in anyways too! What have You personally done to avoid Your brothers distance from Your nation and become "traitors" as You say?
Shouldn't it be better to work on that issue?

No sir, Correction;YOU ARE NOBODY to EVEN COMMENT or LABEL in this situation since you're an outsider.

You're right it is very easy to label Soldat Amir and Afghanistan2010 as traitors because they very blatantly act treasonous. Your question is totally incoherent; We have brains, we have reason we thus have the ability to LABEL and determine who's treasonous. It doesn't require any special cognitive ability or specialization other than awareness.

The problem is we're not doing ENOUGH to label such people; LABELING leads to identification, identification helps us differentiate and differentiatuon allows us to separate and repel such influences. Whether Soldat or Pakistan2010 are alone is not the issue; they're against the well being of their people. That's enough

Remember the Young Turks couldn't do what they did to the Armenians without treasonous Armenians themselves joining with them to help. They were not alone either.