Would Andamase people be considered black?

[Karachi]

Andamase people are from a island on the coast of india, would they be considered black?

[Karachi]

yes, they look black. like the sheedi in pakistan.

sheeda are recent arrivals in south asia like 300-400 years ago, but these people posted above were the first south asians, they have been in south asia for more then 50,000 years. i believe darker indians and even some pakistanis are related to them some what

[Karachi]

they are clearly afros

true, they did come from africa, but over 50,000 years ago, they are not considered africans anymore

[graveyardofempires]

wow how relevant

[Karachi]

^ thanks

[Soldat_Amir]

They look Black. They have the typical nappy hair, flat noses, and fat lips.

[Karachi]

^ true, these guys are also very unique, they are the original population of south asia, they died out in mainland india mostly, but have survived in these isolated islands

[al-arab]

^ true, these guys are also very unique, they are the original population of south asia, they died out in mainland india mostly, but have survived in these isolated islands

I thin I once read that they were very early settlers from Africa? Is that truth?

Also on on of their Islands they speak a language thay nobody know anything about expect themselves.

[Karachi]

^ true, they did come for africa, their language is very different yes, but they can understand hindi

Jarawa man denounces poachers invading their land - YouTube

[al-arab]

^ true, they did come for africa, their language is very different yes, but they can understand hindi

Jarawa man denounces poachers invading their land - YouTube

This is interesting. I don't remember the name of the islands but I am pretty shure that on one islands nobody can understand them expect for those 500 people who live on the island.

Karachi, you are from Pakistan is that not truth? If so are you a Sindh or Punjabi? And how big a difference are there between Sindh, Punjabi and Pashtun language? I know all are Indo-European languages and that Urdu and Hindi are very similar.

How similar? Very much like Arabic dialects or less?

Thank you.

[Karachi]

^ originally my family came from Delhi, my grandfather was a religious scholar he could speak Urdu, Dari/Farsi, Arabic etc... They settled in pakistan (Lahore) in 1946, just before the creation of pakistan. So i am neither punjabi or sindhi.

As for Sindhi, Punjabi, they are closer languages since they are indic, though sindhi has been influenced by balochi as well because many baloch tribes settled in Sindh

Pashto is of east iranic origin, it is quiet different from punjabi and sindhi, though through ancient language like Sanskrit, there are many similarities.

Hindi/Urdu are very close languages, however hindi uses heavy Sanskrit, while Urdu uses many Dari/Farsi words. Pure Urdu is like 30-40% Dari/Farsi, while pure Hindi is like 30-40% Sanskrit, but today both of these languages have become much closer because both of these languages are not spoken in the pure form anymore

[graveyardofempires]

^ true, these guys are also very unique, they are the original population of south asia, they died out in mainland india mostly, but have survived in these isolated islands

are you a racist,sire?

[Karachi]

^ no, i am actually anti racist, why?

[graveyardofempires]

^ no, i am actually anti racist, why?

the guy above,the racist soldat made racist remarks about a people (those people do consider it racist and stereotypical) and you sire said "true".

[Karachi]

^ oh i see, i dont know if his intent was racist, if he was saying it in a bad way then i will disagree with what he said, but i think he was just describing the features in the pics