A Soldier's Journal: Day 5

[ScimitarXEdge]

As an example, lets say no law is in a certain place of Afghanistan. The various terror networks can come into a house force you to let them live there and then they go and blow people up...all against your will.

are you referring to American bases in Afghanistan? because they were set up against the will of the people; and Afghanistan is their home, and the people are forced to let these bases stay there and they go and blow people up ...against their will.

[MDresden]

why was he not put on death row. Oh and btw the other guy was released.

In any case the US army is a bunch of losing criminals. You can learn Islam if you are sincere, but supporting the war against the Afghans is not a show of respect for them.'

have a good day

Since when have I said I support a war "against the Afghans"??????? Makawa, you twist my words and my intentions.

[ScimitarXEdge]

We have different laws for different acts of crime. I have no say on what makes each act more worse then another act nor can I say the length of time needed in prison for such acts.

Our prisons are the same as other countries. Living on a small bed behind metal bars leave for 1 hour a day to workout and the rest of time sitting in your cell.

I simply can't say what is justice as I am not the one to make justice. (Like the ANA/ANP and the Afghan government determines its own justice.)

Well then that affirms what I am saying; an impotent law does very little to suppress injustice.

[MDresden]

are you referring to American bases in Afghanistan? because they were set up against the will of the people; and Afghanistan is their home, and the people are forced to let these bases stay there and they go and blow people up ...against their will.

Theh land the bases are buildt on...I'm sure is rented from the people. To simply take like the Russians would would be an "occupying force" which is against NATO and something I'm sure we simply can't do. [As always, please know this is words from a soldier and I make no rules nor do I know all the rules of NATO/war.]

[emkhan]

Since when have I said I support a war "against the Afghans"??????? Makawa, you twist my words and my intentions.

He seems to be well-versed in Pashto language. Don't take him real

[MDresden]

Well then that affirms what I am saying; an impotent law does very little to suppress injustice.

And who are you to declare a law impotent? If you deem a law impotent what will/would you do to change it? You will understand what the American people have to work with. If we see something as corrupt (keep in mind this is a human world, run by humans and human culture) we may take a job to go in and try to fix such things.

I am in no place to determine justice or law and I stop now any discussion on it.

[ScimitarXEdge]

Theh land the bases are buildt on...I'm sure is rented from the people. To simply take like the Russians would would be an "occupying force" which is against NATO and something I'm sure we simply can't do. [As always, please know this is words from a soldier and I make no rules nor do I know all the rules of NATO/war.]

You're sure it's rented? Even if we say that's true; even rental agreements can be forced. My point being, that terms like justice/injustice are easily *******ized to win sway and sway in favor of a certain camp. Like the early settlers of the Americas were delivering "justice" upon the natives.

anyways I won't expect you to answer for your leaders; but I don't agree with your rationale on certain topics discussed here.

[MDresden]

He seems to be well-versed in Pashto language. Don't take him real

I have only learned the very basic words so far, the greetings of day and common responses. It's how I'm able to learn Pashto, sentences and responses. I have broken the language barrier and to some people I can ask such as "bad - english - pashto?" And the Afghans are smart people and can translate easily.

[ScimitarXEdge]

And who are you to declare a law impotent? If you deem a law impotent what will/would you do to change it? You will understand what the American people have to work with. If we see something as corrupt (keep in mind this is a human world, run by humans and human culture) we may take a job to go in and try to fix such things.

I am in no place to determine justice or law and I stop now any discussion on it.

I'm a person who's not been reduced to a lemming; and hence have the ability to declare a law impotent.

Well I know what I would do in this case, ....tie this creep bound to four horses, one at each limb and have him ripped apart in four places; and have it televised to make him a public example.

Anyways carry on.

[MDresden]

justice/injustice are easily *******ized to win sway and sway in favor of a certain camp. Like the early settlers of the Americas were delivering "justice" upon the natives.

Exactly Scimitar. Like the Russians invading Afghanistan. I personally wouldn't do such things that have been done in the past...but...even for me to say that is to lay blame on someone which I do not take fondly...........

[ScimitarXEdge]

EMKHAN ..shayad hagha yaw Pakhtun dai aw zemung sara maskharah kawi ....w wayal "darega" pa angrezi ki mana lari "Stop" . LOL der maqboul dai kana?

[MDresden]

Scimitar kunni bacha-bas? KUNNI! KUNNI! :P

Makawa, no rorjana.

[emkhan]

I have only learned the very basic words so far, the greetings of day and common responses. It's how I'm able to learn Pashto, sentences and responses. I have broken the language barrier and to some people I can ask such as "bad - english - pashto?" And the Afghans are smart people and can translate easily.

Im looking for a piece of brain to believe Americans. I may find it in the land of brainless and stupid people

[ScimitarXEdge]

na yum, ze da khezo depara dera meena larum ....tanha da san fransico sarrayano ta bacha bazi khwakh dai NAMBLA shuru wakarr

[MDresden]

Brothers wouldn't be so quick to judge one another based on someone else's actions. I have no faith in your ability to equally judge people. You seem biased on the workings of a large group to individual people.

While I will continue on these forums I will take your words with camel spit.