Bakht Zamina - ey sarbaza yara

[graveyardofempires]

YouTube - Ey Sarbaza Yara Patriotic Pashto Sandara For Afghanistan And Pashtunistan

[darwezkhail]

^Wasn't this sung for Communists?

[graveyardofempires]

^Wasn't this sung for Communists?

communists dont speak pashto,do they?

[darwezkhail]

communists dont speak pashto,do they?

I'm referring to the song. It was supposedly dedicated to Afghan communists.

[graveyardofempires]

I'm referring to the song. It was supposedly dedicated to Afghan communists.

do you really think afghans were communists?

[darwezkhail]

do you really think afghans were communists?

Lol, are you trying to say the members of Khalq or Parcham were not Afghans?

[graveyardofempires]

Lol, are you trying to say the members of Khalq or Parcham were not Afghans?

no im not
but saying that Afghans were communists is not true
there were a handful communists in the upper echalon
Afghan were more like nationalists

[darwezkhail]

no im not
but saying that Afghans were communists is not true
there were a handful communists in the upper echalon
Afghan were more like nationalists

Well the true Khalqian were subservient to a pro-Moscow, Marxist agenda and sought to implement a communist-style governance in the country to the best of their abilities, although they ultimately failed. And there were those who merely supported and advocated for such an agenda who, by definition, also fall into the category of communists. Whether they were nationalists or not doesn't abrogate them from their close association with Moscow and Marxist ideals.

By the way, are you one of those Afghan "Nationalists"?

[Toramana]

graveyard in Islam it is haram to watch movies...

[graveyardofempires]

Well the true Khalqian were subservient to a pro-Moscow, Marxist agenda and sought to implement a communist-style governance in the country to the best of their abilities, although they ultimately failed. And there were those who merely supported and advocated for such an agenda who, by definition, also fall into the category of communists. Whether they were nationalists or not doesn't abrogate them from their close association with Moscow and Marxist ideals.

By the way, are you one of those Afghan "Nationalists"?

i cant stand nationalism or communism

[ScimitarXEdge]

graveyard in Islam it is haram to watch movies...

stop claiming Deobandism and Wahhabism are the normative viewpoints of Islam


thanks in advance.