Tweet
US administration 'divided' over Afghanistan, says book
By Mark Mardell BBC News, Washington
Obama hopes to start a withdrawal from Afghanistan next year
President Barack Obama's special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan believes the current strategy cannot work, according to a new book.
The claim, published in the New York Times, is from a book by veteran reporter Bob Woodward.
Reports say the book paints a picture of in-fighting in the administration.
Some key players doubt the president's strategy of sending 30,000 more troops to Afghanistan and starting to withdraw next summer.
Bob Woodward, who made his name exposing President Richard Nixon's cover-up of Watergate has written a searing series of books about President Bush and the Iraq war so his latest work "Obama's war" has been eagerly awaited in Washington.
Now the New York Times say it has a leaked copy.
Holbrooke: "It can't work"
It cites quotes from Richard Holbrooke, the special envoy to the region, saying "It can't work" and the president's main advisor on Afghanistan says that the painstaking White House review which took months "didn't add up" to the policy that was adopted.
It says the CIA has a 3,000-strong secret army inside Afghanistan and that intelligence reports suggest the Afghan President Hamid Karzai has been diagnosed as a manic depressive.
Mr Woodward's book paints a picture of President Obama demanding an exit strategy, saying "I can't lose the whole Democratic party" and irritated with the military for boxing him.
Perhaps most significantly it hints at conflicts to come over the timetable for a US withdrawal.
It quotes the top US soldier in Afghanistan, General David Petraeus, as believing they could "get more time on the clock", and then being told by a senior advisor: "That's a dramatic misreading of this president."
More on This Story
Taliban Conflict
Key maps
Watch/Listen
From other news sites
Related Internet links
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites
Share this page
In association with
Ads by Google
Top South Asia stories
RSS
Top Stories
Advertisement
.prWrap, .prWrap div, .prWrap table, .prWrap table tbody, .prWrap table tr, .prWrap table td, .prWrap img { margin: 0px; padding: 0px; overflow: visible; direction: ltr; background: none repeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; }
Features & Analysis
Most Popular
Shared
Read
Watched/Listened
In association with
Elsewhere on the BBC
In association with
Advertising Partners
Programmes
By Mark Mardell BBC News, Washington
Obama hopes to start a withdrawal from Afghanistan next year President Barack Obama's special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan believes the current strategy cannot work, according to a new book.
The claim, published in the New York Times, is from a book by veteran reporter Bob Woodward.
Reports say the book paints a picture of in-fighting in the administration.
Some key players doubt the president's strategy of sending 30,000 more troops to Afghanistan and starting to withdraw next summer.
Bob Woodward, who made his name exposing President Richard Nixon's cover-up of Watergate has written a searing series of books about President Bush and the Iraq war so his latest work "Obama's war" has been eagerly awaited in Washington.
Now the New York Times say it has a leaked copy.
Holbrooke: "It can't work" It cites quotes from Richard Holbrooke, the special envoy to the region, saying "It can't work" and the president's main advisor on Afghanistan says that the painstaking White House review which took months "didn't add up" to the policy that was adopted.
It says the CIA has a 3,000-strong secret army inside Afghanistan and that intelligence reports suggest the Afghan President Hamid Karzai has been diagnosed as a manic depressive.
Mr Woodward's book paints a picture of President Obama demanding an exit strategy, saying "I can't lose the whole Democratic party" and irritated with the military for boxing him.
Perhaps most significantly it hints at conflicts to come over the timetable for a US withdrawal.
It quotes the top US soldier in Afghanistan, General David Petraeus, as believing they could "get more time on the clock", and then being told by a senior advisor: "That's a dramatic misreading of this president."
Taliban Conflict
- Fear and anger ahead of poll
- Q&A: Afghan elections
- Women threatened in poll
- Unusual poll contenders
- Civilian toll shows Nato dilemma
- Q&A: Fighting the Taliban
- Who are the Taliban?
- Challenges for Afghan forces
Key maps
Watch/Listen
From other news sites
- Chicago Tribune Book describes Obama aides' doubts on Afghanistan 31 mins ago
- Seattle Post Intelligencer Book says aides doubt Obama's Afghan strategy 54 mins ago
- San Jose Mercury News Woodward book details Obama battles with advisers over exit plan for Afghan war 1 hr ago
- Yahoo! New Woodward expose details Afghan policy battles 1 hr ago
- Mirror.co.uk Nine die in Afghan helicopter crash 24 hrs ago
- About these results
Related Internet links
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites
Share this page
In association with
Ads by Google
- New World War 2 Game
Check Out Trailers, Tutorials & Developer's Diaries For RUSE Here!
ubi.com/RUSE - Coffee Exposed
A secret coffee co's don't want you to know
www.coffeefool.com - Brain Health Grade™
Developed by Neuroscientists Complete brain analysis - Free.
www.braingradetest.com
Top South Asia stories
RSS
-
Australia athletes may quit Games
More Australian athletes may withdraw from the Commonwealth Games in Delhi, Australia's sports minister says, as concerns about safety and facilities persist. - US 'in-fighting' over Afghanistan
- Nine killed in Afghanistan crash
Top Stories
- Australia athletes may quit Games
- Key Obama economy adviser to quit
- 'Lost' frogs found after decades
- US Supreme Court allows execution
Advertisement
.prWrap, .prWrap div, .prWrap table, .prWrap table tbody, .prWrap table tr, .prWrap table td, .prWrap img { margin: 0px; padding: 0px; overflow: visible; direction: ltr; background: none repeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; }
<img name="prti" style="width: 1px; height: 1px; float: none;" width="1" height="1">
Features & Analysis
-
Pole position
Who is going to rule the route through the Arctic? -
Living like dogs
Defectors tell of starvation and death in North Korea -
God=MC²
How religion and science rub along together
Most Popular
Shared
- 1: Police release 'lettuce' e-fit
- 2: Vatican Bank 'being investigated'
- 3: Girl's horror over Facebook RSVPs
- 4: Twitter flaw pumps out spam links
- 5: CCTV man 'dumps' limping pet dog
Read
- 1: Huge fossil cache unearthed in US
- 2: Australia athletes may quit Games
- 3: US Supreme Court allows execution
- 4: Girl's horror over Facebook RSVPs
- 5: 'Lost' frogs found after decades
- 6: Key Obama economy adviser to quit
- 7: Life for 'sex game' wife killer
- 8: Nuclear power at heart of Russia's Arctic ambition
- 9: Tales of starvation and death in North Korea
- 10: Winds 'may have parted Red Sea'
Watched/Listened
- 1: 'Bust' California making deep cuts Watch
- 2: Delhi Games bridge collapse Watch
- 3: The floating nuclear power station Watch
- 4: Delhi Games village 'is filthy' Watch
- 5: Motor racing with a difference Watch
- 6: CCTV shows man dumping dog Watch
- 7: Delhi Games village 'uninhabitable' Watch
- 8: Winds may explain parting of Red Sea Watch
- 9: Delhi Games village 'unliveable' Watch
- 10: Gadgets available to early spies Watch
In association with
Elsewhere on the BBC
-
Walk this way
BBC Travel sets out on foot to enjoy Britain's hills, moors and coastline
In association with
Advertising Partners
Programmes
-
World News America Watch
How the home of cricket is breaking a sporting taboo and making room for baseball
In association with